1900 All Stars

[HDH]

1900 All Stars

C Ed McFarland - PHI
1B Ed Delehanty - PHI
2B Nap LaJoie - PHI
SS George Davis - NYG
3B Jimmy Collins - BOS
RF Willie Keeler - BRK
CF Honus Wagner - PIT
LF Elmer Flick - PHI

SP Joe McGinnity - BRK
SP Jesse Tannehill - PIT
SP Deacon Phillippe- PIT
SP Bill Dinneen - BOS

[Baseball Guru]

1900 All Stars



SP Joe McGinnity - BRK
SP Jesse Tannehill - PIT
SP Deacon Phillippe- PIT
SP Bill Dinneen - BOS

I think a case could be made for Jesse Burkett over Keeler, although again, can't lose either way IMO...

Also, although it doesn't reflect in his W/L record, Rube Waddell led the league in era, whip, Hits Allowed/9IP, K's and K's/9IP

[HDH]

Thanks for the suggestions. You're probably right about Jesse Burkett of STL. He's the best LF whereas Elmer Flick and Willie Keeler are RF, Flick being better this year. For that matter, so was Honus Wagner. So many good CF this year, I have to go with Billy Hamilton in BOS. Rube Waddell's 8-13 is what took him off this list.

[Baseball Guru]

Rube Waddell's 8-13 is what took him off this list.

Yeah I figured that.

I looked at most of your allstars from the different years and looking really into them, there really isn't too much debate on all your choices:)