All Blog Entries

  1. Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 4: Continued

    Part 4c – Removing Barriers to Consensus

    The Hall of Fame should communicate to the BBWAA voters that they must stop denying election to so many deserving players; that the voters have a mandate to comprehend and acquiesce to the standards established over 75 years of electing players to the Hall. So the Hall of Fame and the BBWAA should be looking for ways to promote consensus. This is not to say they should strong-arm the voters and coerce them to fall in line with how everyone ...

    Updated 11-01-2010 at 01:00 PM by Freakshow

    Categories
    Uncategorized
  2. Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 4: Building Consensus

    Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 4: Building Consensus

    By Daniel Greenia

    Part 4a – Renewed Eligibility for 20-Year Retirees / A Ballot


    Continual research into history leads to an evolving understanding of past events. The same is certainly true for baseball history. The statistical and historical knowledge are ever expanding. Our understanding of players’ quality, and their standing among the greats, advances a great deal in twenty years. This being ...
    Categories
    Uncategorized
  3. Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 3: Continued

    Part 3c – Escalating Increments

    We have seen how the 5% rule tends to restrict voters from giving all the top candidates a thorough consideration over a period of years. Another factor contributing to this is a common attitude towards first-year candidates. To be a “First-Ballot hall of famer” is usually seen as a special honor. Due to this, many voters will only vote for a player in his first year if he is a no-brainer, an all-time great player. Combine this with a wait-and-see ...
    Categories
    Uncategorized
  4. Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 3: Plausible Fixes

    Fixing the Hall of Fame – Part 3: Plausible Fixes

    By Daniel Greenia


    In a better world, fixing the Hall would be simple. Face it; you or I or anyone could come up with a better system for identifying and honoring baseball’s greatest players. Start from scratch: dump the BBWAA and develop an expert electorate; dump the simplistic up/down voting method with its 75% supermajority requirement; dump the VC and any other second chance reviews; dump the limits on candidates ...

    Updated 01-27-2010 at 10:27 PM by Freakshow

    Categories
    Uncategorized
  5. Fixing the Hall of Fame - Part 2: The Screeners and the 5% Rule

    Fixing the Hall of Fame

    By Daniel Greenia

    Part 2a – It’s Too Big: The Screeners and the 5% Rule


    The hall of fame ballot screening committee of the BBWAA was instituted for the 1968 election to cut the ballot down to a “reasonable” size. Due to expansion and the proliferation of role players, some recent ballots had included more than 60 candidates.

    Jump ahead to 1978. The screening committee was scrutinizing the list of 10-year players ...
    Categories
    Uncategorized
Page 5 of 44 FirstFirst ... 3456715 ... LastLast