It's not as inconsistent as you suggest. First, since this is only in terms of performance for the franchise, I consider only the WAR for the franchise. Franco was at his best as a Red, but that's irrelevant to whether he belongs in the Met HOF. I also look at peak performance for the franchise. Casey and Hayes had almost all their value with the Phillies, and within a span of 5 consecutive seasons. Let's look at Franco, Casey and Hayes with my main measures. I'll also throw in the weakest reliever I voted for, Kent Tekulve of the Pirates:
Originally Posted by jjpm74
career WAR with franchise 12.8
best 3 seasons of WAR with franchise 5.2
best 5 consecutive WAR with franchise 7.2
career WAR with franchise 20.6
best 3 seasons of WAR with franchise 19.0
best 5 consecutive WAR with franchise 20.6
career WAR with franchise 24.8
best 3 seasons of WAR with franchise 13.1
best 5 consecutive WAR with franchise 17.8
career WAR with franchise 18.8
best 3 seasons of WAR with franchise 9.7
best 5 consecutive WAR with franchise 11.4
Seen on a bumper sticker: If only closed minds came with closed mouths.
Some minds are like concrete--thoroughly mixed up and permanently set.
A Lincoln: I don't think much of a man who is not wiser today than he was yesterday.