20 questions

[cbenson5]

Did he record more than 2500 hits?

[soberdennis]

Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16.

[soberdennis]

Was he primarily an outfielder?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15.

[cbenson5]

Did he play in the 19'th century?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14.

[cbenson5]

Did he retire before 1950?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14. Did he retire before 1950? YES
13.

[cbenson5]

Did he record more than 2000 hits?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14. Did he retire before 1950? YES
13. Did he record more than 2000 hits? YES
12.

[cbenson5]

Did he ever play for a MLB team located in Pennsylvania?

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14. Did he retire before 1950? YES
13. Did he record more than 2000 hits? YES
12. Did he ever play for a MLB team located in Pennsylvania? YES
11.

[cbenson5]

Is the letter K in his first or last name?

[RuthMayBond]

Got called away, but
Medwick, LWaner, Roush, Cuyler, Duffy, Kelley, Hamilton or Klein

[cbenson5]

The K question should give it away. I believe I have it down to Waner, Cuyler, or Klein.

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14. Did he retire before 1950? YES
13. Did he record more than 2000 hits? YES
12. Did he ever play for a MLB team located in Pennsylvania? YES
11. Is the letter K in his first or last name? YES
10.

[cbenson5]

Is it Kiki Cuyler? If not is it Chuck Klein?

[soberdennis]

Did he ever play in New York.(Yankees, Dodgers, Giants)

[soberdennis]

Did he ever play in New York.(Yankees, Dodgers, Giants)

Scratch that. Though for Cuyler it is yes, Klein no. We basically already have it guessed. But please one question at a time. It is not fair to others to ask two in one post.

[truman]

I'm thinking of a HOF player. You have 20 questions. Go.

20. Was he primarily a picher? NO
19. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
18. Did he record more than 2500 hits? NO
17. Was he primarily an infielder, not a catcher? NO
16. Was he primarily an outfielder? YES
15. Did he play in the 19'th century? NO
14. Did he retire before 1950? YES
13. Did he record more than 2000 hits? YES
12. Did he ever play for a MLB team located in Pennsylvania? YES
11. Is the letter K in his first or last name? YES
10. Is it Kiki Cuyler? NO
9. Is it Chuck Klein? YES!!!!!!!

Check out Chuck's 5-yr run from 1929-1933:
759 Games, 3114 ABs
.359/.414/.636 160 OPS+
Averaged: 46 doubles, 9 triples, 36 homers (91 xb hits!!) and 10 SBs per year.
Averaged 139 RBIs and 132 Runs per year playing on lousy teams.
Also amassed 125 outfield assists, including mlb record 44 in 1930.

Cbenson5 is up to bat...

[cbenson5]

I've got one. Fire away!

[RuthMayBond]

Primarily a position player? (scratch one of our questions)

[soberdennis]

Was he primarily an ALer?

[cbenson5]

1. Primarily a position player? YES