20 questions

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Alright, was he a pitcher?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Did he reach 3000 hits in his career?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Was he elected before 1960?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Was he elected by the Veterans committee?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO

[soberdennis]

Hey guys. We will continue mine later after we finish cbenson's. That may carry over until tomorrow, though.
Did he play primarily in the AL?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO
5. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO

[soberdennis]

Was he an outfielder primarily?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO
5. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
6. Was he an outfielder primarily? NO

[soberdennis]

Was he not a catcher?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO
5. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
6. Was he an outfielder primarily? NO
7. Was he not a catcher? YES, he was NOT a catcher.

[soberdennis]

Did he ever play for a New York team?

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO
5. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
6. Was he an outfielder primarily? NO
7. Was he not a catcher? YES, he was NOT a catcher.
8. Did he ever play for a New York team? YES

[soberdennis]

Right side of infield primarily? (1b,2b)

[cbenson5]

1. was he a pitcher? NO
2. Did he reach 3000 hits in his career? NO
3. Was he elected before 1960? YES
4. Was he elected by the Veterans committee? NO
5. Did he play primarily in the AL? NO
6. Was he an outfielder primarily? NO
7. Was he not a catcher? YES, he was NOT a catcher.
8. Did he ever play for a New York team? YES
9. Right side of infield primarily? (1b,2b) NO

[soberdennis]

Is it Rabbit Maranville?

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Has to be Maranville.

[cbenson5]

Yes it is. Good Job.

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Back to Dennis' other player?

[soberdennis]

Ok guys. On mine, here is where we were.
1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
The last unanswered question was
3. play primarily in AL-Yes

[Richmond Hill Phoenix]

Was he elected by the Veretans Committee?

[cbenson5]

Was he primarily an outfielder?