20 questions

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO

[cbenson5]

Was he elected to the Hall before 1970?

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO
6. Elected before 1970-Yes

[cbenson5]

Was he primarily a catcher?

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO
6. Elected before 1970-Yes
7. Primarily a catcher-NO

[cbenson5]

Did he ever play for a National League team?

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO
6. Elected before 1970-Yes
7. Primarily a catcher-NO
8. Ever play in NL-NO

[cbenson5]

Did he ever play for the Chicago White Sox?

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO
6. Elected before 1970-Yes
7. Primarily a catcher-NO
8. Ever play in NL-NO
9. Ever play for White Sox-YES

[cbenson5]

Is the player Luke Appling?

[soberdennis]

1. primarily a pitcher-NO
2. Play in 19th century-NO
3. play primarily in AL-Yes
4. Elected by Veterans Committee-NO
5. primarily an OF-NO
6. Elected before 1970-Yes
7. Primarily a catcher-NO
8. Ever play in NL-NO
9. Ever play for White Sox-YES
10. Appling-NO

[cbenson5]

OK, Eddie Collins?

[soberdennis]

If you've done your homework there is only one player left.

[soberdennis]

OK, Eddie Collins?

Yes. Good job.
You can start one. We may have to continue it tomorrow, though.

[cbenson5]

Fire Away!

[brose3312]

Is he an outfielder?

[cbenson5]

1. Is he an outfielder? NO

[soberdennis]

Did he play primarily in the NL?

[cbenson5]

1. Is he an outfielder? NO
2. Did he play primarily in the NL? NO

[soberdennis]

Did he ever play for a New York team.

[soberdennis]

I am still waiting for an answer to my last question.

[closer28]

did he play before 1950

[cbenson5]

1. Is he an outfielder? NO
2. Did he play primarily in the NL? NO
3. Did he ever play for a New York team. NO
4. did he play before 1950 YES

[soberdennis]

Was he an infielder, not a catcher?