Here's an interesting one:
Who do you think is the better pitcher, Roy Halladay or Carlos Zambrano?
Halladay has a career ERA+ of 128. Zambrano 130.
Zambrano has been more consistent the past few years......... well, I couldn't say that. Probably healthier is the right word. Halladay was on a tear in '05 before than damn Kevin Mench.
Zambrano has better stuff, and maybe hasn't even seen his best days. Halladay is usually among league leaders in IP per start, CG, and innings, including 241 and 266 in '02 and '03. It may be Bluejay bias, but it's no pink tea pitching in the A.L. East. I'll take Halladay now. Eventually, I think Zambrano will have a historical season though.