
Originally Posted by
hswan
If your not troubled by the demolition of Yankee Stadium (in full or in part), then at minimum, try to understand its troubled birth. You might just change your mind. The Yankee owners paid a heavy price building that stadium and under very unfair and difficult circumstances.
After many years of research on the 1919 – 1923 Yankees, I wrote a book entitled "Ruthless Baseball Yankees Purified by Fire, Stadium Construction".
See: ruthlessbaseball.com, if interested. Tony Morante gave it some very kind words.
Read on, see if you can capture the NYC / baseball climate during the design / construction time-frame of the big park.
At the same time that the Yankee club was trying to build their own baseball plant, they were also at war with A.L. President Ban Johnson and five A. L. clubs (Phil., Det., Clev., St.L., Wash.) that fell in line under his direction. They were also fighting off corruption that engulfed baseball and NYC during this time. They also had to overcome the actions of the corrupt political downtown group called Tammany Hall as well as a guy named Arnold Rothstein who managed to have his hand in everything that moved.
The two Yankee owners, Colonels Ruppert and Huston were not only fighting to build a stadium but to survive as a club and gain an upper hand. They felt it necessary to own their own ballpark to accomplish this very essential task.
They had to contend with: Ban Johnson leaking inside info on potential ballpark sites that in turn destroyed buying opportunities, continuous construction approval delays by NYC which lead to numerous postponements in construction start dates, endless legal issues, everlasting road closing issues, actions by Charles Stoneham and John McGraw of the NL Giants such as charging excessive rents and lease termination threats at the Polo Grounds, labor strikes, adverse winter conditions, prohibition effects on Ruppert's brewery, reoccurring Yankee cash flow problems, lasting effects of World War I on the economy, convincing bankers to finance the biggest outdoor sporting structure ever built at a time when fan impact from the 1919 Black Sox scandal was at its worst, convincing the bonding companies that White Construction could handle a project bigger than anything they had ever done, serious cash flow problems for White Construction, trades ready to walk unless paid, the bank suspending all cash advances pending review of job status and the financial strength of the Yankees and White Construction to complete the job, legal issues with suppliers, growing tension between Ruppert and Huston, and the negative effects of the A.L. old boys' network working against them on all fronts. Did I mention the nation wide railroad strike which delayed the steel deliveries for well over a month which badly impacted on everything. The Giants also did everything possible to counter Yankee bookings for boxing, football, etc. to weaken their financial position. The two clubs were at war.
Then there’s the finger pointing and bickering between Osborn Engineering, White Construction and the Yankees over change orders, design changes, scheduling, cost over-runs, etc., etc..
There’s actually much, much more but I think you should get the point.
Without the unnecessary road blocks and opposition, I think the Yankees would have actually played the 1921 World Series in their own park as promised by Ruppert to the press, early that year. 1922 also came and went. Finally, after causing the 1923 A.L. baseball season to open one week later than planned, the stadium finally opened its doors in 1923.
Babe Ruth was bigger than all those problems. His economic clout pushed the construction process to its conclusion in spite of all the unnecessary opposition, trials and tribulations. The history at 161st and River is just incredible. I'm talking about before the first pitch was ever thrown. NYC life in the 1920's. This stadium has too much history. If this isn't an "historical site", what is?