Originally posted by Stealth
View Post
Whip, Swivel, Early Bat Speed, Torque, and Such
Collapse
X
-
Last edited by FiveFrameSwing; 11-04-2009, 07:25 AM.
-
-
Originally posted by Stealth View PostWhat are they doing in frames 2-7?
Where's any change in the forearm/bat angle?Obsessed with Pitching Mechanics.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by FiveFrameSwing View PostThis is why you need to pick up a bat and experiment to understand the actions "under the hood". When I run tests with varying degrees of force that would promote forearm supination, I find that I need that force applied at swing initiation.
What matters, at least to me, is what high level hitters like Pujols and Mauer do.Obsessed with Pitching Mechanics.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Chris O'Leary View PostIf supination were to occur early on during the swing, then the angle between the front forearm and the bat, and the distance between the barrel of the bat and the deltoid, would change.
Starting from your stance ... and going through the complete motion ... inclusive of lateral tilt and triangular rotation. I want you to resist the breaking of the hinge angle (lead-forearm/barrel) early, while applying a force that would promote supination of the rear forearm. When you do this ... you should find that when you experiment with varying degrees of force to supinate the rear forearm, that an increase in that force will directly impact how your rear humerus tucks in to your side ... and it will cause it to occur at a greater rate. In a sense, you can "slam" your rear humerus down to your side simply through the force of supination of the rear forearm. In other words ... the degree of supination can force the dropping of the rear elbow.Last edited by FiveFrameSwing; 11-04-2009, 07:38 AM.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by FiveFrameSwing View PostThis is why you need to pick up a bat and experiment to understand the actions "under the hood". When I run tests with varying degrees of force that would promote forearm supination, I find that I need that force applied at swing initiation.
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank everyone. This has turned into a 180 degree opposite of what it was becoming. I believe many can benefit from this and, in fact, referenced a very good college coach to this thread since I know that he also is very interested in hitting.
THANK YOU!RIP Joe Lindley (Jake Patterson) Oct. 25, 2019, Scott Sarginson (SSarge) Nov. 17, 2016, Donny Buster (Swingbuster) June 1st 2007. Zachary "Doug" Reddell (Bluedog) December 22, 2022. Greatly missed by so many!
Comment
-
-
Getting back on topic...
Here's a 60 FPS, full body version of the clip I've been using (the frame numbers are synced up across clips).
I think it's still a (somewhat) open question as to what happens to cause the whip that occurs after Frame 27 or Frame 28, so here's a clip that focuses in on those key frames.
I absolutely agree that momentum transfer is involved in the whip, but we know that the whip isn't going to happen automatically, and the forearm/bat angle isn't going to change (and the back forearm isn't going to supinate), solely due to physics rather than muscular activation unless something happens to cause it.
So what changes between Frame 27 or 28, when the whip hasn't yet happened, and Frame 29 when the whip is definitely happening?
Well, the most obvious thing (to me at least) is that the front leg stops just externally rotating and the front knee starts extending. It's plausible to believe that that would rapidly cause the torso to stop moving forward, which would cause the hands and head of the bat to rapidly fly forward and the head of the bat to pivot around the hands.
I'd be interested in hearing other people's candidates for the cause of the whip.Last edited by Chris O'Leary; 11-04-2009, 07:45 AM.Obsessed with Pitching Mechanics.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Cannonball View PostWouldn't this then require that we have the abilities of a MLB Player?
I see many people complimenting Jim for running his experiments. Jim is not an ML level hitter.
I've seen SE swings, and appreciate his experimentation, but he is not a ML level hitter.
Same for BM, XXXXXXX, and many others. Their experiments and continuous testing is helpful ... and yet they are not ML hitters.
IMO, it would be a big mistake not to compliment the Hanson Principle with conducting tests to better understand the actions "under the hood". In fact, I'd say you would be doing yourself, and your students, a disservice.Last edited by FiveFrameSwing; 11-04-2009, 08:06 AM.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by mudvnine View Post
. . .
so if it's only "momentum transfer due to the rotation of the body" . . . what force/energy causes Uggla's (Frame #50) and DeRosa's (Frame 64/65) bats to "bend" or Rose's bat to blur while they are still almost perpendicular to the batter's box and not much further in the swing as Jim's PVC box swing?
With hands on the bat, holding the angle firm, it causes the force coming from rotation to transfer up the bat. You create a changing "moment of inertia" that prevents the lag that occurs with only a bolt at the simulated hand position. The force from the changing moment of inertia can cause the bat to bend, you don't have to try to whip early with the hands, to get it to bend.Last edited by jbooth; 11-04-2009, 07:49 AM.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by FiveFrameSwing View PostStarting from your stance ... and going through the complete motion ... inclusive of lateral tilt and triangular rotation. I want you to resist the breaking of the hinge angle (lead-forearm/barrel) early, while applying a force that would promote supination of the rear forearm.
A force that resists the breaking of the hinge angle would be pronation (because the whip is going to automatically cause your back forearm to supinate).
You can't pronate and supinate the forearm at the same time.Obsessed with Pitching Mechanics.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Chris O'Leary View PostGetting back on topic...
Here's a 60 FPS, full body version of the clip I've been using (the frame numbers are synced up across clips).
I think it's still a (somewhat) open question as to what happens to cause the whip that occurs after Frame 27 or Frame 28, so here's a clip that focuses in on those key frames.
I absolutely agree that momentum transfer is involved in the whip, but we know that the whip isn't going to happen automatically, and the forearm/bat angle isn't going to change (and the back forearm isn't going to supinate), solely due to physics rather than muscular activation unless something happens to cause it.
So what changes between Frame 27 or 28, when the whip hasn't yet happened, and Frame 29 when the whip is definitely happening?
Well, the most obvious thing (to me at least) is that the front leg stops just externally rotating and the front knee starts extending. It's plausible to believe that that would rapidly cause the torso to stop moving forward, which would cause the hands and head of the bat to rapidly fly forward and the head of the bat to pivot around the hands.
I'd be interested in hearing other people's candidates for the cause of the whip.
IMO it's the pulling forces that are created back to the ball. The shoulders and hips are rotating with the swing to help suck the barrel around. The hitter the starts out by pushing the bat creates different forces which delay the whip.
EL
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by FiveFrameSwing View PostI see many people complimenting Jim for running his experiments. Jim is not an ML level hitter.
All he's doing in his clip is demonstrating conservation of momentum, which is a physics concept (and which is why all he does is turn a PVC box with a flail attached).Obsessed with Pitching Mechanics.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Chris O'Leary View PostGetting back on topic...
Originally posted by Chris O'Leary View PostI absolutely agree that momentum transfer is involved in the whip, but we know that the whip isn't going to happen automatically, and the forearm/bat angle isn't going to change (and the back forearm isn't going to supinate), solely due to physics rather than muscular activation unless something happens to cause it.
I tell you what ... simply advance your swing to the Power-V position with varying degrees of force that would cause supination ... while maintaining the lead-arm/barrel hinge angle. Take note of what happens as you vary the degree of supination as you go from your stance to the Power-V.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Stealth View PostThe swing happens so fast, how is it possible to add something (to help the whip) after the swing has launched?
I think when you look at frames, especially at 60fps you get the wrong conclusion some times. These swings up close are so fast its hard to describe. Once these MLB guys go, the swing is over, done, complete IMHO. You better work the hands early rather than late............
It doesn't matter if the swing happens at the speed of light. Electrons have a velocity and so do body parts. Just because you can't see or sense the forces doesn't mean that they don't occur in a sequence.
Events may occur simultaneously, but energy from applied force moves in space and time, whether it be fast or slowly.
I agree, describing movements is difficult. IMO, one shouldn't teach from science, but you can't ignore it, or deny facts that can be identified, just because you don't comprehend them.
Comment
-
Ad Widget
Collapse
Comment