Top 20 All-Time Yankees?

[DoubleX]

How do you rank the Top 10 All-Time Yankees? Here's what I get:

1) Babe Ruth
2) Lou Gehrig
3) Mickey Mantle
4) Joe DiMaggio
5) Yogi Berra
6) Whitey Ford
7) Mariano Rivera
8) Bill Dickey
9) Derek Jeter
10) Don Mattingly
11) Thurman Munson
12) Dave Winfield
13) Lefty Gomez
14) Bernie Williams
15) Elston Howard
16) Red Ruffing
17) Joe Gordon
18) Ron Guidry
19) Graig Nettles
20) Tony Lazzeri

Just for kicks, here are my next 30 (to round out to 50, but these are not ranked)

Allie Reynolds
Andy Pettitte
Billy Martin (gets manager points)
Bob Meusel
Bobby Murcer
Charlie Keller
Dave Righetti
Earle Combs
Ed Lopat
Gil McDougald
Goose Gossage
Hank Bauer
Herb Pennock
Jack Chesbro
Lou Piniella (gets some manager points)
Mel Stottlemyre
Moose Skowron
Paul O'Neill
Phil Rizzuto
Reggie Jackson
Roger Maris
Roy White
Sparky Lyle
Spud Chandler
Tino Martinez
Tommy Henrich
Vic Raschi
Waite Hoyt
Willie Keeler
Willie Randolph

[pacewon]

Based on what they did as Yankees only? I'd consider giving Bernie the edge over Winfield given his postseason performance - 22 HRs, 83 Runs, 83 RBIs, all Major League postseason records, all accomplished as a New York Yankee.

[DoubleX]

Based on what they did as Yankees only? I'd consider giving Bernie the edge over Winfield given his postseason performance - 22 HRs, 83 Runs, 83 RBIs, all Major League postseason records, all accomplished as a New York Yankee.

It was mostly just what they did as Yankees, hence Jackson being so low. I probably should have bumped Winfield down a few spots.

[Zito75]

How do you rank the Top 10 All-Time Yankees? Here's what I get:

1) Babe Ruth
2) Lou Gehrig
3) Mickey Mantle
4) Joe DiMaggio
5) Yogi Berra
6) Whitey Ford
7) Mariano Rivera
8) Bill Dickey
9) Derek Jeter
10) Don Mattingly
11) Thurman Munson
12) Dave Winfield
13) Lefty Gomez
14) Bernie Williams
15) Elston Howard
16) Red Ruffing
17) Joe Gordon
18) Ron Guidry
19) Graig Nettles
20) Tony Lazzeri

Just for kicks, here are my next 30 (to round out to 50, but these are not ranked)

Allie Reynolds
Andy Pettitte
Billy Martin (gets manager points)
Bob Meusel
Bobby Murcer
Charlie Keller
Dave Righetti
Earle Combs
Ed Lopat
Gil McDougald
Goose Gossage
Hank Bauer
Herb Pennock
Jack Chesbro
Lou Piniella (gets some manager points)
Mel Stottlemyre
Moose Skowron
Paul O'Neill
Phil Rizzuto
Reggie Jackson
Roger Maris
Roy White
Sparky Lyle
Spud Chandler
Tino Martinez
Tommy Henrich
Vic Raschi
Waite Hoyt
Willie Keeler
Willie Randolph

No Rickey Henderson?

[TheKingofKings]

How do you rank the Top 10 All-Time Yankees? Here's what I get:

1) Babe Ruth
2) Lou Gehrig
3) Mickey Mantle
4) Joe DiMaggio
5) Yogi Berra
6) Whitey Ford
7) Mariano Rivera
8) Bill Dickey
9) Derek Jeter
10) Don Mattingly
11) Thurman Munson
12) Dave Winfield
13) Lefty Gomez
14) Bernie Williams
15) Elston Howard
16) Red Ruffing
17) Joe Gordon
18) Ron Guidry
19) Graig Nettles
20) Tony Lazzeri

Just for kicks, here are my next 30 (to round out to 50, but these are not ranked)

Allie Reynolds
Andy Pettitte
Billy Martin (gets manager points)
Bob Meusel
Bobby Murcer
Charlie Keller
Dave Righetti
Earle Combs
Ed Lopat
Gil McDougald
Goose Gossage
Hank Bauer
Herb Pennock
Jack Chesbro
Lou Piniella (gets some manager points)
Mel Stottlemyre
Moose Skowron
Paul O'Neill
Phil Rizzuto
Reggie Jackson
Roger Maris
Roy White
Sparky Lyle
Spud Chandler
Tino Martinez
Tommy Henrich
Vic Raschi
Waite Hoyt
Willie Keeler
Willie Randolph

No Roger Maris (sorry if i didn't see him in the list)

[Myankee4life]

1. Babe Ruth
2. Lou Gehrig
3. Mickey Mantle
4. Joe Dimaggio
5. Yogi Berra
6. Whitey Ford
7. Mariano Rivera
8. Bernie Williams
9. Red Ruffing
10. Don Mattingly
11. Derek Jeter
12. Lefty Gomez
13. Bill Dickey
14. Dave Winfield
15. Paul Oneal
16. Thurman Munson
17. Ron Guidry
18. Tony Lazzeri
19. Rickey Henderson
20. Greg Nettles

[christian gentleman]

20

1. ruth
2. gehrig
3. dimaggio
4. mantle
5. berra
6. ford
7. rizzuto
8. martin
9. maris
10. munson
11. mattingly
12. reynolds
13. guidry
14. page
15. rivera
16. pettite
17. nettles
18. jackson
19. rickey henderson
20. jeter

[DoubleX]

Rickey only had 4 and half seasons with the Yanks, and one was drastically cut short by injury. Just couldn't really see him on the all-time Yankee list (same as Clemens). Jackson barely got into the top 50 because of his postseason heroics. Rickey didn't have any of those with the Yankees.

[LouGehrig]

1B Gehrig, Mattingly, Tino
2B Lazzeri, Gordon
3B Rolfe, Nettles
SS Jeter, Rizzuto
LF Ruth,
CF DiMaggio, Mantle, Combs
RF O'Neill, Meusel, Jackson
C Dickey, Berra, Howard, Munson

That equal twenty. Pitchers have their own award for outstanding pitcher because they different from everyday players.

RHP Hoyt, Ruffing, Reynolds
LHP Ford, Guidry, Pennock
RHR Mariano, Gossage, Duren
LHR Arroyo, Page

[Myankee4life]

Bernie Williams absolutely has to be on everybody's list....He's top 5 in near eevry category with them.

[johnny]

Who you gonna have managing?
Manager: Stengal/Torre/McCarthy/Huggins/
Not sure of this order.

[christian gentleman]

Who you gonna have managing?
Manager: Stengal/Torre/McCarthy/Huggins/
Not sure of this order.

Billy Martin

[mbs]

bernie williams

[DoubleX]

bernie williams

Welcome MBS. What about Bernie Williams?