Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

All-Time Yankees Vote-Off Game

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • All-Time Yankees Vote-Off Game

    This is a new version of the vote-off game featuring the best Yankees from both the past and the present.

    The rules for this version will be the same, with a couple of changes

    Rules (special thanks to otis89!!):

    Vote + for one player and - for another player. Example: If you vote + for Babe Ruth, he goes up 1 point, and if you vote - for Lou Gehrig, he goes down 1 point.

    Once a player reaches 0 points, they are eliminated.

    Each player will start with 5 points

    First player to 75 WINS!!

    You may vote only ONCE a day.

    Please copy the list from the last post in this thread to avoid any confusion.

    REMEMBER TO POST THE UPDATED LIST WHEN YOU VOTE!!

    If you feel a new player should be added, then you must state the name of the player as well as the name of a player already on the list of which 5 points will be taken from. Then, 4 other participants must agree and the new player will be included in the next list.

    Enjoy!!

    Yogi Berra 5
    Jack Chesbro 5
    Bill Dickey 5
    Joe DiMaggio 5
    Whitey Ford 5
    Lou Gehrig 5
    Rich Gossage 5
    Lefty Gomez 5
    Ron Guidry 5
    Catfish Hunter 5
    Elston Howard 5
    Reggie Jackson 5
    Derek Jeter 5
    Don Larson 5
    Tony Lazzeri 5
    Mickey Mantle 5
    Roger Maris 5
    Don Mattingly 5
    Thurmon Munson 5
    Graig Nettles 5
    Paul O'Neill 5
    Andy Pettite 5
    Jorge Posada 5
    Willie Randolph 5
    Allie Reynolds 5
    Mariano Rivera 5
    Phil Rizzuto 5
    Babe Ruth 5
    Bernie Williams 5
    Dave Winfield 5
    Last edited by Yankee Legend; 02-28-2006, 08:27 PM.
    Yankees '09

    Arod, CC, AJ, DJ and Tex

  • #2
    List from Yankee Legend #1

    Lou Gehrig +1/ Reggie Jackson -1

    Yogi Berra 5
    Jack Chesbro 5
    Bill Dickey 5
    Joe DiMaggio 5
    Whitey Ford 5
    Lou Gehrig 6
    Rich Gossage 5
    Lefty Gomez 5
    Ron Guidry 5
    Catfish Hunter 5
    Elston Howard 5
    Reggie Jackson 4
    Derek Jeter 5
    Don Larson 5
    Tony Lazzeri 5
    Mickey Mantle 5
    Roger Maris 5
    Don Mattingly 5
    Thurmon Munson 5
    Graig Nettles 5
    Paul O'Neill 5
    Andy Pettite 5
    Jorge Posada 5
    Willie Randolph 5
    Allie Reynolds 5
    Mariano Rivera 5
    Phil Rizzuto 5
    Babe Ruth 5
    Bernie Williams 5
    Dave Winfield 5
    "I was pitching one day when my glasses clouded up on me. I took them off to polish them. When I looked up to the plate, I saw Jimmie Foxx. The sight of him terrified me so much that I haven't been able to wear glasses since." - Left Gomez

    "(Lou) Gehrig never learned that a ballplayer couldn't be good every day." - Hank Gowdy

    Comment


    • #3
      What if, down the line we want to vote for someone not on this list? Like Charlie Keller?

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by DoubleX
        What if, down the line we want to vote for someone not on this list? Like Charlie Keller?
        ill just quote myself

        Originally posted by Yankee Legend
        2. If you feel a new player should be added, then you must state the name of the player as well as the name of a player already on the list of which 5 points will be taken from. Then, 4 other participants must agree and the new player will be included in the next list.
        just make sure he played at least more than one season with the yankees
        Last edited by Yankee Legend; 02-26-2006, 09:40 PM.
        Yankees '09

        Arod, CC, AJ, DJ and Tex

        Comment


        • #5
          Joe DiMaggio +
          Don Larson -

          Yogi Berra 5
          Jack Chesbro 5
          Bill Dickey 5
          Joe DiMaggio 6
          Whitey Ford 5
          Lou Gehrig 6
          Rich Gossage 5
          Lefty Gomez 5
          Ron Guidry 5
          Catfish Hunter 5
          Elston Howard 5
          Reggie Jackson 4
          Derek Jeter 5
          Don Larson 4
          Tony Lazzeri 5
          Mickey Mantle 5
          Roger Maris 5
          Don Mattingly 5
          Thurmon Munson 5
          Graig Nettles 5
          Paul O'Neill 5
          Andy Pettite 5
          Jorge Posada 5
          Willie Randolph 5
          Allie Reynolds 5
          Mariano Rivera 5
          Phil Rizzuto 5
          Babe Ruth 5
          Bernie Williams 5
          Dave Winfield 5
          Yankees '09

          Arod, CC, AJ, DJ and Tex

          Comment


          • #6
            From Yankee Legend

            Don Mattingly +
            Paul O'Neill -

            Yogi Berra 5
            Jack Chesbro 5
            Bill Dickey 5
            Joe DiMaggio 6
            Whitey Ford 5
            Lou Gehrig 6
            Rich Gossage 5
            Lefty Gomez 5
            Ron Guidry 5
            Catfish Hunter 5
            Elston Howard 5
            Reggie Jackson 4
            Derek Jeter 5
            Don Larson 4
            Tony Lazzeri 5
            Mickey Mantle 5
            Roger Maris 5
            Don Mattingly 6
            Thurmon Munson 5
            Graig Nettles 5
            Paul O'Neill 4
            Andy Pettite 5
            Jorge Posada 5
            Willie Randolph 5
            Allie Reynolds 5
            Mariano Rivera 5
            Phil Rizzuto 5
            Babe Ruth 5
            Bernie Williams 5
            Dave Winfield 5
            "I think about baseball when I wake up in the morning. I think about it all day and I dream about it at night. The only time I don't think about it is when I'm playing it."
            Carl Yastrzemski

            Comment


            • #7
              Mariano Rivera +
              Jack Chesbro -

              Yogi Berra 5
              Jack Chesbro 4
              Bill Dickey 5
              Joe DiMaggio 6
              Whitey Ford 5
              Lou Gehrig 6
              Rich Gossage 5
              Lefty Gomez 5
              Ron Guidry 5
              Catfish Hunter 5
              Elston Howard 5
              Reggie Jackson 4
              Derek Jeter 5
              Don Larson 4
              Tony Lazzeri 5
              Mickey Mantle 5
              Roger Maris 5
              Don Mattingly 6
              Thurmon Munson 5
              Graig Nettles 5
              Paul O'Neill 4
              Andy Pettite 5
              Jorge Posada 5
              Willie Randolph 5
              Allie Reynolds 5
              Mariano Rivera 6
              Phil Rizzuto 5
              Babe Ruth 5
              Bernie Williams 5
              Dave Winfield 5

              Comment


              • #8
                From Pacewon

                Mattingly+
                Catfish-


                Yogi Berra 5
                Jack Chesbro 4
                Bill Dickey 5
                Joe DiMaggio 6
                Whitey Ford 5
                Lou Gehrig 6
                Rich Gossage 5
                Lefty Gomez 5
                Ron Guidry 5
                Catfish Hunter 4
                Elston Howard 5
                Reggie Jackson 4
                Derek Jeter 5
                Don Larson 4
                Tony Lazzeri 5
                Mickey Mantle 5
                Roger Maris 5
                Don Mattingly 6
                Thurmon Munson 5
                Graig Nettles 5
                Paul O'Neill 4
                Andy Pettite 5
                Jorge Posada 5
                Willie Randolph 5
                Allie Reynolds 5
                Mariano Rivera 6
                Phil Rizzuto 5
                Babe Ruth 5
                Bernie Williams 5
                Dave Winfield 5
                Rest in Peace Jose Fernandez (1992-2016)

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Yankee Legend
                  just make sure he played at least more than one season with the yankees
                  Might I suggest that if a player's name is to be added, that this be done when it comes to the next round? If not, then these guys, especially 2 weeks from now, would have an advantage over others, in that they never got a chance to be voted off earlier.

                  BTW, who's going to vote off Mantle, DiMaggio and Gehrig?

                  I also like the idea of bolding the names of the players in the longer list that you've voted for (+) and against (-). Kind of makes it more obvious.
                  Please read Baseball Fever Policy and Forum FAQ before posting. 2007-11 CBA
                  Rest very peacefully, John “Buck” O'Neil (1911-2006) & Philip Francis “Scooter” Rizzuto (1917-2007)
                  THE BROOKLYN DODGERS - 1890 thru 1957
                  Montreal Expos 1969 - 2004

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    From 86:

                    Yogi Berra 5
                    Jack Chesbro 4
                    Bill Dickey 5
                    Joe DiMaggio 6
                    Whitey Ford 5
                    Lou Gehrig 6
                    Rich Gossage 5
                    Lefty Gomez 5
                    Ron Guidry 5
                    Catfish Hunter 3-
                    Elston Howard 5
                    Reggie Jackson 4
                    Derek Jeter 5
                    Don Larson 4
                    Tony Lazzeri 5
                    Mickey Mantle 6+
                    Roger Maris 5
                    Don Mattingly 6
                    Thurmon Munson 5
                    Graig Nettles 5
                    Paul O'Neill 4
                    Andy Pettite 5
                    Jorge Posada 5
                    Willie Randolph 5
                    Allie Reynolds 5
                    Mariano Rivera 6
                    Phil Rizzuto 5
                    Babe Ruth 5
                    Bernie Williams 5
                    Dave Winfield 5
                    Me, at a Boston restaurant, to a waiter:
                    Are you sure the Manny Ramirez (name of burger) isn't a sloppy joe?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Babe Ruth +
                      Dave Winfield -

                      Yogi Berra 5
                      Jack Chesbro 4
                      Bill Dickey 5
                      Joe DiMaggio 6
                      Whitey Ford 5
                      Lou Gehrig 6
                      Rich Gossage 5
                      Lefty Gomez 5
                      Ron Guidry 5
                      Catfish Hunter 3
                      Elston Howard 5
                      Reggie Jackson 4
                      Derek Jeter 5
                      Don Larson 4
                      Tony Lazzeri 5
                      Mickey Mantle 6
                      Roger Maris 5
                      Don Mattingly 6
                      Thurmon Munson 5
                      Graig Nettles 5
                      Paul O'Neill 4
                      Andy Pettite 5
                      Jorge Posada 5
                      Willie Randolph 5
                      Allie Reynolds 5
                      Mariano Rivera 6
                      Phil Rizzuto 5
                      Babe Ruth 6
                      Bernie Williams 5
                      Dave Winfield 4

                      Isn't it nice that something associated with the Yankees has a chance of winning???
                      Yankees '09

                      Arod, CC, AJ, DJ and Tex

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        From Yankee Legend #11

                        + Roger Maris/ - Dave Winfield

                        Yogi Berra 5
                        Jack Chesbro 4
                        Bill Dickey 5
                        Joe DiMaggio 6
                        Whitey Ford 5
                        Lou Gehrig 6
                        Rich Gossage 5
                        Lefty Gomez 5
                        Ron Guidry 5
                        Catfish Hunter 3
                        Elston Howard 5
                        Reggie Jackson 4
                        Derek Jeter 5
                        Don Larson 4
                        Tony Lazzeri 5
                        Mickey Mantle 6
                        Roger Maris 6
                        Don Mattingly 6
                        Thurmon Munson 5
                        Graig Nettles 5
                        Paul O'Neill 4
                        Andy Pettite 5
                        Jorge Posada 5
                        Willie Randolph 5
                        Allie Reynolds 5
                        Mariano Rivera 6
                        Phil Rizzuto 5
                        Babe Ruth 6
                        Bernie Williams 5
                        Dave Winfield 3
                        2006 = The Empire Strikes Back! <-- Evil Laugh

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Aussie_Stengelese

                          Don Mattingly +
                          Paul O'Neil -

                          Don actually has 8 points.

                          Yogi Berra 5
                          Jack Chesbro 4
                          Bill Dickey 5
                          Joe DiMaggio 6
                          Whitey Ford 5
                          Lou Gehrig 6
                          Rich Gossage 5
                          Lefty Gomez 5
                          Ron Guidry 5
                          Catfish Hunter 3
                          Elston Howard 5
                          Reggie Jackson 4
                          Derek Jeter 5
                          Don Larson 4
                          Tony Lazzeri 5
                          Mickey Mantle 6
                          Roger Maris 6
                          Don Mattingly 8
                          Thurmon Munson 5
                          Graig Nettles 5
                          Paul O'Neill 3
                          Andy Pettite 5
                          Jorge Posada 5
                          Willie Randolph 5
                          Allie Reynolds 5
                          Mariano Rivera 6
                          Phil Rizzuto 5
                          Babe Ruth 6
                          Bernie Williams 5
                          Dave Winfield 3
                          "I think about baseball when I wake up in the morning. I think about it all day and I dream about it at night. The only time I don't think about it is when I'm playing it."
                          Carl Yastrzemski

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Joe DiMaggio +
                            Jorge Posada -

                            Yogi Berra 5
                            Jack Chesbro 4
                            Bill Dickey 5
                            Joe DiMaggio 7
                            Whitey Ford 5
                            Lou Gehrig 6
                            Rich Gossage 5
                            Lefty Gomez 5
                            Ron Guidry 5
                            Catfish Hunter 3
                            Elston Howard 5
                            Reggie Jackson 4
                            Derek Jeter 5
                            Don Larson 4
                            Tony Lazzeri 5
                            Mickey Mantle 6
                            Roger Maris 6
                            Don Mattingly 8
                            Thurmon Munson 5
                            Graig Nettles 5
                            Paul O'Neill 3
                            Andy Pettite 5
                            Jorge Posada 4
                            Willie Randolph 5
                            Allie Reynolds 5
                            Mariano Rivera 6
                            Phil Rizzuto 5
                            Babe Ruth 6
                            Bernie Williams 5
                            Dave Winfield 3
                            Yankees '09

                            Arod, CC, AJ, DJ and Tex

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              From Yankee Legend

                              ^^^^^^ You're not following your own rule!!!!


                              Don Mattingly +
                              Paul O'Neill -

                              Yogi Berra 5
                              Jack Chesbro 4
                              Bill Dickey 5
                              Joe DiMaggio 7
                              Whitey Ford 5
                              Lou Gehrig 6
                              Rich Gossage 5
                              Lefty Gomez 5
                              Ron Guidry 5
                              Catfish Hunter 3
                              Elston Howard 5
                              Reggie Jackson 4
                              Derek Jeter 5
                              Don Larson 4
                              Tony Lazzeri 5
                              Mickey Mantle 6
                              Roger Maris 6
                              Don Mattingly 9
                              Thurmon Munson 5
                              Graig Nettles 5
                              Paul O'Neill 2
                              Andy Pettite 5
                              Jorge Posada 4
                              Willie Randolph 5
                              Allie Reynolds 5
                              Mariano Rivera 6
                              Phil Rizzuto 5
                              Babe Ruth 6
                              Bernie Williams 5
                              Dave Winfield 3
                              "I think about baseball when I wake up in the morning. I think about it all day and I dream about it at night. The only time I don't think about it is when I'm playing it."
                              Carl Yastrzemski

                              Comment

                              Ad Widget

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X