A's acquire John Jaso

[Phantom Dreamer]

Congratulations, that's all.

[Zito75]

I'd rather have Morse, who the M's ended up with in the 3 team deal. Jaso is mediocre at best - Norris will probably start.

[Phantom Dreamer]

I'd rather have Morse, who the M's ended up with in the 3 team deal. Jaso is mediocre at best - Norris will probably start.

Jaso is the better player. Morse has some power, that's it. Morse doesn't have a defensive position, doesn't run the bases well, doesn't draw walks, strikes out too much. Jaso is the better player who is cheaper, under club control longer. If you're an Oakland fan, be glad you have him. He was misused by Wedge last year and if the A's give him enough PA, he will be proven to be one of the best catchers in the game. Oakland won the deal, no question.

[Buffalo A's fan]

Sounds like a Jaso/Norris platoon. I see Kottars was DFA'd the day after he signed a deal.

[filihok]

I'd rather have Morse, who the M's ended up with in the 3 team deal. Jaso is mediocre at best - Norris will probably start.

Why?

Jaso Career: .359/.395 OBP/SLG. 3.6 WAR per 700 PA's
Morse Last 3: .345/.516 OBP/SLG 2.6 WAR per 700 PA's

[Zito75]

Why?

Jaso Career: .359/.395 OBP/SLG. 3.6 WAR per 700 PA's
Morse Last 3: .345/.516 OBP/SLG 2.6 WAR per 700 PA's

Morse had a breakout year in '11 and played alright after his injury in '12. He had an OPS of over .900 in '11 and has hit 3 bills or close to it over the past few years. I'd rather have that than a platoon catcher on my squad... If Jaso gets a years worth of PA's in a season, he might be able to put something decent together...

[filihok]

Morse had a breakout year in '11 and played alright after his injury in '12. He had an OPS of over .900 in '11 and has hit 3 bills or close to it over the past few years. I'd rather have that than a platoon catcher on my squad... If Jaso gets a years worth of PA's in a season, he might be able to put something decent together...

Jaso 5.5 WAR over the last 3 seasons as a platoon catcher
Morse 4.7 WAR over the last 3 seasons as a 1B/LF


You should consider the relevant talent levels
LF 2012: .326/.431
1B 2012: .336/.432

C 2012: .318/.400
*http://www.baseball-reference.com/le...12&lg=MLB#defp

Jaso is much more better than his position mates than Morse is. Thus, he's worth a lot more


EDIT: Plus, Morse makes $7 million this year and is a free agent after the season.
Jaso will probably make about $7 million over the next 3 seasons that he's under team control.

[Francoeurstein]

Terrific Beane-esque move.

Jaso/Norris platoon is the epitome of Billy Beane's methodology.

[Zito75]

Jaso 5.5 WAR over the last 3 seasons as a platoon catcher
Morse 4.7 WAR over the last 3 seasons as a 1B/LF


You should consider the relevant talent levels
LF 2012: .326/.431
1B 2012: .336/.432

C 2012: .318/.400
*http://www.baseball-reference.com/le...12&lg=MLB#defp

Jaso is much more better than his position mates than Morse is. Thus, he's worth a lot more


EDIT: Plus, Morse makes $7 million this year and is a free agent after the season.
Jaso will probably make about $7 million over the next 3 seasons that he's under team control.

WAR isn't everything - so I'm glad you have other stats posted. I'm hoping Jaso plays well that enough that he's NOT platooned...

[filihok]

WAR isn't everything - so I'm glad you have other stats posted.

Well, all WAR really is those other stats, measured against average players, converted to runs and adjusted for replacement.

I'm hoping Jaso plays well that enough that he's NOT platooned...

He hasn't shown that he can hit lefties. He's 25% above average vs righties, and 40% below average vs lefties.
vs L: 15% walks, 18% K's, .066 ISO
vs R: 13% walks, 11% K's, .151 ISO

[filihok]

Well, all WAR really is those other stats, measured against average players, converted to runs and adjusted for replacement.



He hasn't shown that he can hit lefties. He's 25% above average vs righties, and 40% below average vs lefties.
vs L: 15% walks, 18% K's, .066 ISO
vs R: 13% walks, 11% K's, .151 ISO

Though, in his minor league career (AA and above):
vs L: 378 PA, 12.4% BB, 10.6% K
vs R: 975 PA, 13.8% BB, 11.2% K

So, maybe it's not as bad as it seems.

[Zito75]

Well, all WAR really is those other stats, measured against average players, converted to runs and adjusted for replacement.

And there are different interpretations of WAR which makes me wonder how reliable it is... At any rate, I'm cautiously optimistic about Jaso's season.
I'm hoping he does as well as you all say he can do. : )

[mlazar]

Norris will start , I only hope Jaso has as many big hits as Kottares had...

[Phantom Dreamer]

If the A's were smart they'd start Jaso against RHP. Wedge had him buried behind Olivo a good portion of last season. Jaso will start the season on a defending division winning team, while Olivo remains unemployed.

[filihok]

And there are different interpretations of WAR which makes me wonder how reliable it is...

You don't have to wonder.
You can easily test it yourself

It's extremely reliable

http://www.hardballtimes.com/main/article/what-is-war-good-for/

WARvs.Wins_.jpg