Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Blue Jays all time 25 man roster

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • j4ckdavids
    replied
    Originally posted by Steve Jeltz View Post
    Why isn't George Bell on this list?
    I was wondering about that too. Bell has been one of my favourite players.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sockeye
    replied
    Originally posted by Chadwick View Post

    This is an almost perfect roster. I would bounce Gruber, Scutaro and Clancy for Fred McGriff, Roger Clemens and George Bell. Bell starts in LF, Joey Bats in RF, Eddie E at DH. (I also start White, not Wells, in center.) Everything else is the same.

    Pitted against other all-time teams, this could arguably be the best of any expansion franchise. It's easily the best of any of the six post-1969 expansion franchises. (Can you believe it's been 20 years now for the Rays and Dbacks?)

    The only change to this in the next couple years would (presumably) be replacing Downs with Roberto Osuna.

    Great job, Sockeye.
    Thank you Chadwick. Interesting ideas. No question that Clemens was a better pitcher with the Blue Jays than was Clancy. His tenure with the Jays was so short that I hesitate putting him on an all time roster. Would love to have McGriff and Bell on the team. Both deserve to be on it. Wanted to make the roster as realistic as possible though. If I remove Scutaro and Gruber (best 3B in Jays history until 4 years ago) and Donaldson or Fernandez go down with an injury then who plays SS or 3B?

    Leave a comment:


  • Chadwick
    replied
    Originally posted by Sockeye View Post
    C: Ernie Whitt, Gregg Zaun
    1B: Carlos Delgado, Edwin Encarnacion
    2B: Roberto Alomar, Aaron Hill
    3B: Josh Donaldson, Kelly Gruber
    SS: Tony Fernandez, Marco Scutaro
    LF: Jose Bautista
    CF: Vernon Wells, Lloyd Moseby, Devon White
    RF: Jesse Barfield
    SP: Dave Stieb, Roy Halladay, Jimmy Key, Pat Hentgen, Jim Clancy
    RP: Tom Henke, Mark Eichhorn, Paul Quantrill, Duane Ward, Scott Downs

    How many games would this team win against 2016 competition if all of these Blue Jays players were together in their Blue Jays prime?

    The way I see it is the starting pitching would be among the best is baseball as would the bullpen. The hitting would be easily the strongest as would the bench. Spectacular defensive infield!! All that said 100 wins would be probable.
    This is an almost perfect roster. I would bounce Gruber, Scutaro and Clancy for Fred McGriff, Roger Clemens and George Bell. Bell starts in LF, Joey Bats in RF, Eddie E at DH. (I also start White, not Wells, in center.) Everything else is the same.

    Pitted against other all-time teams, this could arguably be the best of any expansion franchise. It's easily the best of any of the six post-1969 expansion franchises. (Can you believe it's been 20 years now for the Rays and Dbacks?)

    The only change to this in the next couple years would (presumably) be replacing Downs with Roberto Osuna.

    Great job, Sockeye.

    Leave a comment:


  • Chicoutimi CP
    replied
    Great list, Sockeye... Here are a few suggestions:

    - Scratch Clancy for Clemens. Rocket won 2 Cy Youngs in 2 years as a Jay. Can't leave him off.
    - John Olerud for the second spot at first base, move Edwin to a new DH slot since he played most of his games there for the Jays.
    - I'd scratch Scutaro because he played only 2 seasons in Toronto, even if he was excellent. (He did not dominate at his position like Clemens did.)
    - Put George Bell in LF, move Bautista as first RF and Barfield as second RF.
    - Cito Gaston as manager!!

    The rest is perfect IMHO...
    Last edited by Chicoutimi CP; 02-03-2018, 11:24 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Steve Jeltz
    replied
    Why isn't George Bell on this list?

    Leave a comment:


  • augustabound
    replied
    Holy WAR for Hill.

    In my defense, WAR wasn't invented in Garcia's day.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sockeye
    replied
    Originally posted by augustabound View Post
    I'd have Damaso Garcia ahead of Aaron Hill.

    Seeing the name Scott Downs makes me cringe, still. But having looked at his numbers on baseball-reference, he wasn't all that bad during his time in Toronto. It may be nothing more than he played during a time when this team inspired absolutely no confidence at any time. Except Roy Halladay of course.
    Damaso Garcia: 902 games, 453 runs, 1028 hits, 172 doubles, 26 triples, 32 home runs, 296 RBI, 194 steals, 110 walks, 284 strikeouts, 1348 total bases, .288 AVG, .312 OBP, .377 SLG, 86 OPS+, 8.5 WAR

    Aaron Hill: 875 games, 436 runs, 881 hits, 188 doubles, 9 triples, 96 home runs, 409 RBI, 39 steals, 239 walks, 476 strikeouts, 1375 total bases, .265 AVG, .318 OBP, .413 SLG, 92 OPS+, 17.2 WAR

    Close be certainly a small edge for Aaron Hill don't you think?
    Last edited by Sockeye; 10-28-2016, 10:58 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • augustabound
    replied
    I'd have Damaso Garcia ahead of Aaron Hill.

    Seeing the name Scott Downs makes me cringe, still. But having looked at his numbers on baseball-reference, he wasn't all that bad during his time in Toronto. It may be nothing more than he played during a time when this team inspired absolutely no confidence at any time. Except Roy Halladay of course.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sockeye
    started a topic Blue Jays all time 25 man roster

    Blue Jays all time 25 man roster

    C: Ernie Whitt, Gregg Zaun
    1B: Carlos Delgado, Edwin Encarnacion
    2B: Roberto Alomar, Aaron Hill
    3B: Josh Donaldson, Kelly Gruber
    SS: Tony Fernandez, Marco Scutaro
    LF: Jose Bautista
    CF: Vernon Wells, Lloyd Moseby, Devon White
    RF: Jesse Barfield
    SP: Dave Stieb, Roy Halladay, Jimmy Key, Pat Hentgen, Jim Clancy
    RP: Tom Henke, Mark Eichhorn, Paul Quantrill, Duane Ward, Scott Downs

    How many games would this team win against 2016 competition if all of these Blue Jays players were together in their Blue Jays prime?

    The way I see it is the starting pitching would be among the best is baseball as would the bullpen. The hitting would be easily the strongest as would the bench. Spectacular defensive infield!! All that said 100 wins would be probable.
    Last edited by Sockeye; 10-27-2016, 06:18 PM.

Ad Widget

Collapse
Working...
X