I've seen 1000s of comments on other sites. Almost unanimously people condemned this settlement. I actually found it grotesque that there was so little compassion for the boy's parents. The comments all steered toward villainizing them. I get that there's disdain for lawsuits that seem to unjustly toss blame around until it sticks somewhere, but for Pete's sake to make personal attacks against them? My son pitches. I've encouraged him. Our entire family has given him praise and showered him with approval. I fully understand that plays some role in why he pitches. I'm pretty sure that I'd never smile again if it were my kid this happened to. These parents are living their worst nightmare.
There's plenty of information for the uninformed simpleton to jump to conclusions in this story, but I think there's likely some evidence that gives the case merit which isn't disclosed. Are there, or were there bats approved for LL play that met batted ball exit speed standards when brand new, but exceeded them with use? If so then to me that knowingly circumvents safety initiatives. Every time I hear about this, whether it be cheating on pitcher availability where pitch counts are in effect or ignoring signs of injury in favor of wins and meaningless statistical accomplishments, it sickens me. If this bat was one of those bats then I think there is merit to their case. If it's a case of it just being a "metal bat" and it out performs wood, then I first and foremost sympathize with the family. However, I think their case lacks merit.
Any bat can and has caused serious injury due to balls hit harder than reaction time can handle. That's not the issue. If it were a case where safety rules were circumvented for profit, for meaningless performance increases, for fueling the insane parts of youth sports, then this kid is a victim. I almost feel like many of us share in the blame. How much have you valued your kid's performance? I'm guilty as sin. I've spent money on camps and instruction and top notch equipment. I've spent 1000s of hours practicing with my kids in hope that they compete favorably. I've been without question the target market for a hot bat.
Comment