Each Team's All-Time Roster

[Francoeurstein]

I know many years ago it was fairly common that people would post threads regarding "all-time" teams. Recently, I haven't seen much of that and instead of posting 30 different threads for each team, I figured we could all post ones in here.

I forgot to mention... The real reason I'm doing this is for ideas. I'm running a project on Baseball Mogul 2013 where I create every single teams all-time roster and I can't do it by myself! So when creating teams, keep in mind that a certain player can have more than one option. For example, Randy Johnson could pitch for both the Mariners and DBacks all-time teams, but he'd probably be a better fit for Arizona because that's where he had his monster peak years, and they have less quality options than Seattle.

With that being said, feel free to post away!

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Can I use outfielders in any outfield spot?

Chicago Whitesox Alltime team.

C1. Carlton Fisk
1B. Paul Konerko
2B. Eddie Collins
SS. Luke Appling
3B. Robin Ventura
LF. Joe Jackson
CF. Chet Lemon...I would put Minnie Minoso here if theres no game restrictions.
RF. Harold Baines
DH. Frank Thomas

SP1. Ed Walsh
SP2. Ted Lyons
SP3. Billy Pierce
SP4. Red Faber
SP5. Mark Buehrle

CLR. Hoyt Wilhelm

[chicagowhitesox1173]

New York Yankees Alltime Team

C1. Yogi Berra
1B. Lou Gehrig
2B. Tony Lazzeri
SS. Derek Jeter
3B. Alex Rodriguez
LF. Charlie Keller?? maybe Roy White or Matsui.
CF. Mickey Mantle
RF. Babe Ruth
DH. Joe DiMaggio

SP1. Whitey Ford
SP2. Lefty Gomez
SP3. Ron Guidry
SP4. Red Ruffing
SP5. Herb Pennock

CLR. Mariano Rivera

[Francoeurstein]

Can I use outfielders in any outfield spot?

I'd prefer a position they had a good amount of playing time in... Doesn't have to be exclusive. For instance, Pete Rose could be 1st, 2nd, 3rd, or the corners.

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Philadelphia/Oakland Athletic Alltime Team.

C1. Mickey Cochrane
1B. Jimmy Foxx
2B. Eddie Collins
SS. Bert Campaneris
3B. Frank Baker
LF. Rickey Henderson
CF. Al Simmons
RF. Reggie Jackson
DH.Mark McGwire

SP1. Lefty Grove
SP2. Eddie Plank
SP3. Rube Waddell
SP4. Chief Bender
SP5. Catfish Hunter

CLR. Dennis Eckersley

[chicagowhitesox1173]

I'd prefer a position they had a good amount of playing time in... Doesn't have to be exclusive. For instance, Pete Rose could be 1st, 2nd, 3rd, or the corners.

So Dimaggio is out for a left fielder? is dh a position? I was using dh as a spot for players only after 1973.

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Philadelphia Phillies Alltime Roster

C1. Darren Daulton
1B Ryan Howard
2B. Chase Utley
SS. Jimmy Rollins
3B. Mike Schmidt
LF. Ed Delahanty
CF. Richie Ashburn
RF. Chuck Klein

SP1. Steve Carlton
SP2. Pete Alexander
SP3. Robin Roberts
SP4. Curt Schilling
SP5. Jim Bunning

CLR. Tug McGraw

[chicagowhitesox1173]

St. Louis Cardinals Alltime Team

C1. Ted Simmons
1B. Albert Pujols
2B. Roger Hornsby
SS. Ozzie Smith
3B. Ken Boyer
LF. Stan Musial
CF. Curt Flood
RF. Enos Slaughter

SP1. Bob Gibson
SP2. Jesse Haines
SP3. Dizzy Dean
SP4. Mort Cooper
SP5. Chris Carpenter

CLR. Bruce Sutter

[chicagowhitesox1173]

New York/San Francisco Giants Alltime Team

C1. Buster Posey..Probably a little early
1B. Willie McCovey
2B. Frankie Frisch
SS. Travis Jackson
3B. Matt Williams
LF. Barry Bonds
CF. Willie Mays
RF. Mel Ott

SP1. Christy Mathewson
SP2. Carl Hubbell
SP3. Juan Marichal
SP4. Gaylord Perry
SP5. Matt Cain

CLR. Rod Beck

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Detroit Tigers Alltime Team

C1. Bill Freehan
1B. Hank Greenberg
2B. Charlie Gehringer
SS. Alan Trammell
3B. Goerge Kell
LF. Willie Horton
CF. Ty Cobb
RF. Sam Crawford
DH. Al Kaline

SP1. Hal Newhouser
SP2. Justin Verlander
SP3. Jack Morris
SP4. Mickey Lolich
SP5. Tommy Bridges

CLR. John Hiller

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Boston RedSox Alltime Team.

C1. Carlton Fisk
1B. Jimmy Foxx
2B. Bobby Doerr
SS. Nomar Garciaparra
3B. Wade Boggs
LF. Ted Williams
CF. Tris Speaker
RF. Dwight Evans
DH. David Ortiz

SP1. Cy Young
SP2. Roger Clemens
SP3. Pedro Martinez
SP4. Luis Tiant
SP5. Joe Wood

CLR. Keith Foulke

[toomanyhatz]

Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers All time Roster

C. Mike Piazza (close call over Campanella)
1B Gil Hodges
2B Jackie Robinson
SS Maury Wills
3B Ron Cey
LF Zack Wheat
CF Duke Snider
RF Shawn Green (but Mondesi, Furillo and Ethier all extremely close. If Ethier isn't traded and has another couple of good seasons he'll move into the lead.)

SP1 Sandy Koufax
SP2 Dazzy Vance
SP3 Don Drysdale
SP4 Don Sutton
SP5 DonNewcombe

CLR Eric Gagne

[Francoeurstein]

So Dimaggio is out for a left fielder? is dh a position? I was using dh as a spot for players only after 1973.

Right. And yes, DH is a position for AL teams regardless of year.

[bluesky5]

Philadelphia Phillies All-Time Team

Manager - Dallas Green [Harry Wright]

1. CF - Billy Hamilton [Richie Ashburn]
2. 2B - Chase Utley [Kid Gleason]
3. LF - Ed Delahanty [Luzinski]
4. 3B - Mike Schmidt [Dick Allen]
5. RF - Big Sam Thompson [Chuck Klein]
6. 1B - Ryan Howard
7. SS - Jimmy Rollins [Dave Bancroft]
8. C - Bob Boone [Mike Lieberthal]

1. Pete Alexander
2. Steve Carlton
3. Robin Roberts
4. Curt Schilling
5. Jim Bunning
[Charlie Ferguson, Curt Simmons, Cole Hamels, Chris Short]

Bullpen - Jim Konstanty, Ron Reed, Mitch Williams [Rheal Cormier, Turk Farrell]
CL - Tug McGraw

[]-HM
*I didn't select the players to fit a desired batting order. I arranged them after picking the best by position.

[bluesky5]

I bet the Phillies end up with the most active players currently with the team in their all-time lineup than any other [3].