Starting Pitcher Vote-Off Game

[Lucifer]

Up to 2 -'s and 2 +'s for every vote.. You know how it works. For the record, I took this list from today's top ERA leaders, figured it was a pretty good measure for starters this year

Dan Haren OAK 5
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 5
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 5
Justin Verlander DET 5
Kelvim Escobar LAA 5
Johan Santana MIN 5
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 5
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 5
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 5
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 5

[Lucifer]

Dan Haren OAK 5
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 6 +
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 5
Justin Verlander DET 5
Kelvim Escobar LAA 5
Johan Santana MIN 5
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 5
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 4 -
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 4 -
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 6 +

[oaklandman666]

Dan Haren OAK 7 ++
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 6
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4 -
Justin Verlander DET 5
Kelvim Escobar LAA 5
Johan Santana MIN 5
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 5
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3 -
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 6

[Colorado Express]

Dan Haren OAK 7
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 7+
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 5
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4-
Johan Santana MIN 6+
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 5
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 5-

[rdonahue]

Dan Haren OAK 7
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 7
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7++
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 6
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 5
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3--

[oaklandman666]

Dan Haren OAK 9 ++
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 7
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 6
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3--
Josh Beckett BOS 5
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 5
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 5
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 5
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

[Lucifer]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 7
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 6
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 4 -
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6 +
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 6 + Good game last night
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 4 -
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

I just added Dice-K.. felt like we need him in here

[Charger567]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 7
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 6
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 6++
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 5
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 5
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 4--
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 4
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

[Colorado Express]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8+
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 7+
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 6
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 4-
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 4-
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 4
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 5
Mark Buehrle CHW 4
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

[Charger567]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 7
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 8++
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 5
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 4
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 4
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 3-
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4-
Mark Buehrle CHW 4
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

[otis89]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 8+
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 8
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 6+
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 4
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 4
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 3
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4
Mark Buehrle CHW 3-
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 2-

[oaklandman666]

Dan Haren OAK 9 ++
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 8
John Maine NYM 5
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 8
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 6
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 4
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 2-- The A's of all teams beat him up last night.
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 3
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4
Mark Buehrle CHW 3
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 2

[Lucifer]

This is clearly getting ruined by haters of some teams. ^The A's of all teams? The A's are a good ballclub this year with a good shot at the WC, so you don't make much sense.

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 8
John Maine NYM 4 -
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 7 -
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 6
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 4
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 2
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 4 +
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4
Mark Buehrle CHW 3
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3 +

Not sure why this is getting ruined. People like Pettitte/Wang getting negative votes in the last month, there's not even a reason for that.

[Colorado Express]

Dan Haren OAK 9
Brad Penny LAD 5
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 10++
John Maine NYM 4
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 7
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 6
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 3-
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 3
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 1-
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 4
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4
Mark Buehrle CHW 3
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3

[baseballchamp14]

Dan Haren OAK 10+
Brad Penny LAD 4-
Chris Young SDG 5
Jake Peavy SDG 8
Jeremy Guthrie BAL 4
Justin Verlander DET 7
Kelvim Escobar LAA 4
Johan Santana MIN 10
John Maine NYM 4
Ian Snell PIT 5
John Lackey LAA 3
Josh Beckett BOS 8+
Ben Sheets MIL 4
Tom Gorzelanny PIT 5
Dice-K Matsuzaka 5
Rich Hill CHC 6
John Smoltz ATL 5
Chad Gaudin OAK 3
Derek Lowe LAD 5
Oliver Perez NYM 2-
Joe Blanton OAK 5
Fausto Carmona CLE 1
Gil Meche KAN 5
C.C. Sabathia CLE 6
Brandon Webb ARI 5
Andy Pettitte NYY 4
Tim Hudson ATL 5
Matt Morris SFO 4
Mark Buehrle CHW 3
Matt Cain SFO 5
Jason Marquis CHC 5
Chien-Ming Wang NYY 3