A vote-off game for the greatest pitchers at least before the dead-ball era. Everyone gets two votes per round or every ten ballots.

Old Hoss Radbourne 5
Mordecai Brown 5
Addie Joss 6
Tim Keefe 5
Pud Galvin 5
Rube Waddell 5
Al Spalding 5
Ed Ruelbach 5
Kid Nichols 5
Guy Hecker 4