This might make for some interesting debate. Here's what I got. Definitely some really tough choices, so feel free to disagree and put in your own lists. My second team players are in parentheses following the first team guy.
AL EAST
C: Jason Varitek, (Jorge Posada)
1B: Jason Giambi, (Lyle Overbay)
2B: Brian Roberts, (Jorge Cantu)
SS: Miguel Tejada, (Derek Jeter)
3B: Alex Rodriguez, (Troy Glaus)
LF: Manny Ramirez, (Hideki Matsui)
CF: Vernon Wells, (Johnny Damon)
RF: Gary Sheffield, (Jay Gibbons)
DH: David Ortiz, (Aubrey Huff)
SP: Roy Halladay, (Scott Kazmir)
SP: Randy Johnson, (Mike Mussina)
SP: Curt Schilling, (Gustavo Chacin)
SP: Josh Beckett, (Erik Bedard)
SP: A.J. Burnett, (Shawn Chacon)
CL: Mariano Rivera, (B.J. Ryan)
AL CENTRAL
C: Victor Martinez, (Joe Mauer)
1B: Paul Konerko, (Justin Morneau)
2B: Ronnie Belliard, (Luis Castillo)
SS: Jhonny Peralta, (Carlos Guillen)
3B: Joe Crede, (Brandon Inge)
LF: Scott Podsednik, (Reggie Sanders)
CF: Grady Sizemore, (Torii Hunter)
RF: Jermaine Dye, (Magglio Ordonez)
DH: Travis Hafner, (Mike Sweeney)
SP: Johan Santana, (Jeremy Bonderman)
SP: Mark Buehrle, (Cliff Lee)
SP: Jon Garland, (Zack Greinke)
SP: Brad Radke, (Jose Contreras)
SP: C.C. Sabathia, (Kenny Rogers)
CL: Joe Nathan, (Bob Wickman)
AL WEST
C: Jason Kendall, (Jose Molina)
1B: Mark Teixeira, (Richie Sexson)
2B: Adam Kennedy, (Mark Ellis)
SS: Michael Young, (Bobby Crosby)
3B: Eric Chavez, (Hank Blalock)
LF: Garret Anderson, (Kevin Mench)
CF: Mark Kotsay, (Gary Matthews Jr)
RF: Vladimir Guerrero, (Ichiro Suzuki)
DH: Frank Thomas, (Carl Everett)
SP: Bartolo Colon, (Adam Eaton)
SP: Rich Harden, (Danny Haren)
SP: Barry Zito, (Jarrod Washburn)
SP: Kevin Millwood, (Jeff Weaver)
SP: Jamie Moyer, (Felix Hernandez)
CL: Francisco Rodriguez, (Huston Street)
ALL AL
C: Victor Martinez, (Joe Mauer)
1B: Mark Teixeira, (Richie Sexson)
2B: Brian Roberts, (Ronnie Belliard)
SS: Miguel Tejada, (Derek Jeter)
3B: Alex Rodriguez, (Eric Chavez)
LF: Manny Ramirez, (Hideki Matsui)
CF: Vernon Wells, (Grady Sizemore)
RF: Vladimir Guerrero, (Ichiro Suzuki)
DH: David Ortiz, (Travis Hafner)
SP: Johan Santana, (Mark Buehrle)
SP: Roy Halladay, (Barry Zito)
SP: Bartolo Colon, (Kevin Millwood)
SP: Rich Harden, (Curt Schilling)
SP: Randy Johnson, (Josh Beckett)
CL: Mariano Rivera, (Francisco Rodriguez)
NL East
C: Paul Lo Duca, (Brian McCann)
1B: Carlos Delgado, (Ryan Howard)
2B: Alfonso Soriano, (Chause Utley)
SS: Jimmy Rollins, (Edgar Renteria)
3B: Miguel Cabrera, (David Wright)
LF: Pat Burrell, (Cliff Floyd)
CF: Andruw Jones, (Carlos Beltran)
RF: Bobby Abreu, (Jose Guillen)
Ex: Chipper Jones, (Nick Johnson)
SP: Pedro Martinez, (Mike Hampton)
SP: Dontrelle Willis, (Brett Myers)
SP: Tim Hudson, (Randy Wolf)
SP: John Smoltz, (Tom Glavine)
SP: Livan Hernandez, (Jon Lieber)
CL: Billy Wagner, (Chad Cordero)
NL Central
C: Michael Barrett, (Brad Ausmus)
1B: Albert Pujols, (Derrek Lee)
2B: Craig Biggio, (Rickie Weeks)
SS: Felipe Lopez, (David Eckstein)
3B: Scott Rolen, (Aramis Ramirez)
LF: Jason Bay, (Carlos Lee)
CF: Jim Edmonds, (Ken Griffey Jr)
RF: Jeromy Burnitz, (Jacque Jones)
EX: Adam Dunn, (Lance Berkman)
SP: Chris Carpenter, (Ben Sheets)
SP: Carlos Zambrano, (Mark Mulder)
SP: Roy Oswalt, (Zach Duke)
SP: Andy Pettitte, (Chris Capuano)
SP: Mark Prior, (Oliver Perez)
CL: Brad Lidge, (Jason Isringhausen)
NL West
C: Mike Piazza, (Johnny Estrada)
1B: Todd Helton, (Nomar Garciaparra)
2B: Jeff Kent, (Orlando Hudson)
SS: Rafael Furcal, (Omar Vizquel)
3B: Bill Mueller, (Pedro Feliz)
LF: Barry Bonds, (Matt Holliday)
CF: Mike Cameron, (Randy Winn)
RF: Brian Giles, (Moises Alou)
Ex: Luis Gonzalez, (Shawn Green)
SP: Jake Peavy, (Brad Penny)
SP: Jason Schmidt, (Woody Williams)
SP: Matt Morris, (Jason Jennings)
SP: Brandon Webb, (Odalis Perez)
SP: Derek Lowe, (Orlando Hernandez)
CL: Eric Gagne, (Trevor Hoffman)
All NL
C: Paul Lo Duca, (Mike Piazza)
1B: Albert Pujols, (Derrek Lee)
2B: Alfonso Soriano, (Chase Utley)
SS: Jimmy Rollins, (Rafael Furcal)
3B: Miguel Cabrera, (David Wright)
LF: Barry Bonds, (Jason Bay)
CF: Andruw Jones, (Jim Edmonds)
RF: Bobby Abreu, (Brian Giles)
Ex: Carlos Delgado, (Adam Dunn)
SP: Pedro Martinez, (Jake Peavy)
SP: Dontrelle Willis, (Andy Pettitte)
SP: Chris Carpeter, (Tim Hudson)
SP: Roy Oswalt, (Mark Prior)
SP: Carlos Zambrano, (John Smoltz)
CL: Billy Wagner, (Brad Lidge)
AL EAST
C: Jason Varitek, (Jorge Posada)
1B: Jason Giambi, (Lyle Overbay)
2B: Brian Roberts, (Jorge Cantu)
SS: Miguel Tejada, (Derek Jeter)
3B: Alex Rodriguez, (Troy Glaus)
LF: Manny Ramirez, (Hideki Matsui)
CF: Vernon Wells, (Johnny Damon)
RF: Gary Sheffield, (Jay Gibbons)
DH: David Ortiz, (Aubrey Huff)
SP: Roy Halladay, (Scott Kazmir)
SP: Randy Johnson, (Mike Mussina)
SP: Curt Schilling, (Gustavo Chacin)
SP: Josh Beckett, (Erik Bedard)
SP: A.J. Burnett, (Shawn Chacon)
CL: Mariano Rivera, (B.J. Ryan)
AL CENTRAL
C: Victor Martinez, (Joe Mauer)
1B: Paul Konerko, (Justin Morneau)
2B: Ronnie Belliard, (Luis Castillo)
SS: Jhonny Peralta, (Carlos Guillen)
3B: Joe Crede, (Brandon Inge)
LF: Scott Podsednik, (Reggie Sanders)
CF: Grady Sizemore, (Torii Hunter)
RF: Jermaine Dye, (Magglio Ordonez)
DH: Travis Hafner, (Mike Sweeney)
SP: Johan Santana, (Jeremy Bonderman)
SP: Mark Buehrle, (Cliff Lee)
SP: Jon Garland, (Zack Greinke)
SP: Brad Radke, (Jose Contreras)
SP: C.C. Sabathia, (Kenny Rogers)
CL: Joe Nathan, (Bob Wickman)
AL WEST
C: Jason Kendall, (Jose Molina)
1B: Mark Teixeira, (Richie Sexson)
2B: Adam Kennedy, (Mark Ellis)
SS: Michael Young, (Bobby Crosby)
3B: Eric Chavez, (Hank Blalock)
LF: Garret Anderson, (Kevin Mench)
CF: Mark Kotsay, (Gary Matthews Jr)
RF: Vladimir Guerrero, (Ichiro Suzuki)
DH: Frank Thomas, (Carl Everett)
SP: Bartolo Colon, (Adam Eaton)
SP: Rich Harden, (Danny Haren)
SP: Barry Zito, (Jarrod Washburn)
SP: Kevin Millwood, (Jeff Weaver)
SP: Jamie Moyer, (Felix Hernandez)
CL: Francisco Rodriguez, (Huston Street)
ALL AL
C: Victor Martinez, (Joe Mauer)
1B: Mark Teixeira, (Richie Sexson)
2B: Brian Roberts, (Ronnie Belliard)
SS: Miguel Tejada, (Derek Jeter)
3B: Alex Rodriguez, (Eric Chavez)
LF: Manny Ramirez, (Hideki Matsui)
CF: Vernon Wells, (Grady Sizemore)
RF: Vladimir Guerrero, (Ichiro Suzuki)
DH: David Ortiz, (Travis Hafner)
SP: Johan Santana, (Mark Buehrle)
SP: Roy Halladay, (Barry Zito)
SP: Bartolo Colon, (Kevin Millwood)
SP: Rich Harden, (Curt Schilling)
SP: Randy Johnson, (Josh Beckett)
CL: Mariano Rivera, (Francisco Rodriguez)
NL East
C: Paul Lo Duca, (Brian McCann)
1B: Carlos Delgado, (Ryan Howard)
2B: Alfonso Soriano, (Chause Utley)
SS: Jimmy Rollins, (Edgar Renteria)
3B: Miguel Cabrera, (David Wright)
LF: Pat Burrell, (Cliff Floyd)
CF: Andruw Jones, (Carlos Beltran)
RF: Bobby Abreu, (Jose Guillen)
Ex: Chipper Jones, (Nick Johnson)
SP: Pedro Martinez, (Mike Hampton)
SP: Dontrelle Willis, (Brett Myers)
SP: Tim Hudson, (Randy Wolf)
SP: John Smoltz, (Tom Glavine)
SP: Livan Hernandez, (Jon Lieber)
CL: Billy Wagner, (Chad Cordero)
NL Central
C: Michael Barrett, (Brad Ausmus)
1B: Albert Pujols, (Derrek Lee)
2B: Craig Biggio, (Rickie Weeks)
SS: Felipe Lopez, (David Eckstein)
3B: Scott Rolen, (Aramis Ramirez)
LF: Jason Bay, (Carlos Lee)
CF: Jim Edmonds, (Ken Griffey Jr)
RF: Jeromy Burnitz, (Jacque Jones)
EX: Adam Dunn, (Lance Berkman)
SP: Chris Carpenter, (Ben Sheets)
SP: Carlos Zambrano, (Mark Mulder)
SP: Roy Oswalt, (Zach Duke)
SP: Andy Pettitte, (Chris Capuano)
SP: Mark Prior, (Oliver Perez)
CL: Brad Lidge, (Jason Isringhausen)
NL West
C: Mike Piazza, (Johnny Estrada)
1B: Todd Helton, (Nomar Garciaparra)
2B: Jeff Kent, (Orlando Hudson)
SS: Rafael Furcal, (Omar Vizquel)
3B: Bill Mueller, (Pedro Feliz)
LF: Barry Bonds, (Matt Holliday)
CF: Mike Cameron, (Randy Winn)
RF: Brian Giles, (Moises Alou)
Ex: Luis Gonzalez, (Shawn Green)
SP: Jake Peavy, (Brad Penny)
SP: Jason Schmidt, (Woody Williams)
SP: Matt Morris, (Jason Jennings)
SP: Brandon Webb, (Odalis Perez)
SP: Derek Lowe, (Orlando Hernandez)
CL: Eric Gagne, (Trevor Hoffman)
All NL
C: Paul Lo Duca, (Mike Piazza)
1B: Albert Pujols, (Derrek Lee)
2B: Alfonso Soriano, (Chase Utley)
SS: Jimmy Rollins, (Rafael Furcal)
3B: Miguel Cabrera, (David Wright)
LF: Barry Bonds, (Jason Bay)
CF: Andruw Jones, (Jim Edmonds)
RF: Bobby Abreu, (Brian Giles)
Ex: Carlos Delgado, (Adam Dunn)
SP: Pedro Martinez, (Jake Peavy)
SP: Dontrelle Willis, (Andy Pettitte)
SP: Chris Carpeter, (Tim Hudson)
SP: Roy Oswalt, (Mark Prior)
SP: Carlos Zambrano, (John Smoltz)
CL: Billy Wagner, (Brad Lidge)
Comment