How would you handle A-Rod right now?

[quagmire]

He hit some decently tonight, but got some bad luck.

[YankeeMan]

Gotta' bench him. Next year might be different... But right now, it's not happening for him.

[White Knight]

Me personally, there is no way I'd be starting him against righties the rest of this postseason. I don't care how unconventional it may be or what the fans think. It's win or go home, and he is just all kinds of fail right now.

The fans are all in agreement to bench him. The only Yankee fans that still defend him are posters here.

[Joltin' Joe]

Albeit a very very small sample size, he does have an OPS of over 1.200 against the Tigers this year.

[ipitch]

Me personally, there is no way I'd be starting him against righties the rest of this postseason. I don't care how unconventional it may be or what the fans think. It's win or go home, and he is just all kinds of fail right now.

I think he's in a slump that he could bust out of at any time. He hit righty starters quite well this year (.293).

[Joltin' Joe]

Go A-Rod! :gt

[NJYankeeFan]

Me personally, there is no way I'd be starting him against righties the rest of this postseason. I don't care how unconventional it may be or what the fans think. It's win or go home, and he is just all kinds of fail right now.

Would you play Granderson, Cano or Swisher? All of whom have been just about the same level as A Rod.

Granted Yanks have a better option for replacing A Rod but they need to get their big bats going.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I997 using Tapatalk 2

[RubeBaker]

Me personally, there is no way I'd be starting him against righties the rest of this postseason. I don't care how unconventional it may be or what the fans think. It's win or go home, and he is just all kinds of fail right now.