No announcement yet.

What hat should Sutter wear?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What hat should Sutter wear?

    Easy one. What hat should the newest member wear into the hall?

    Cubs 5 Seasons - 300 Games - 133 SV
    Cardinals 4 Seasons - 249 Games - 127 SV
    Braves 3 Seasons - 112 Games - 40 SV
    Last edited by Dizzy; 01-10-2006, 12:47 PM.
    Behold My Annoyingly Long Signature

    St. Louis Cardinals
    American Association Champions
    National League Champions
    World Champions

  • #2
    Tough one between Cubs and Cards. I always think of him as a Card, and that is where he won his WS, so I'd give it the nod over the one extra season (and corresponding extra games and saves).

    He also had his best save year in St.L, and led the league three of the four years he was there. He did win a Cy in Chicago, although he was arguably better in 1984 than 1979.

    Close one, but nod to Cards
    Last edited by Brooklyn; 01-10-2006, 01:03 PM.


    • #3
      I voted "Cubs", but any of the choices but Atlanta is okay with me.
      Buck O'Neil: The Monarch of Baseball


      • #4
        I voted for the Cubs. He had his best years there.

        133 saves, around a 170 ERA+, plus he had his great '77 season, and his '79 season where he won the Cy Yound Award.


        • #5
          That's one of the toughest cap-calls I've ever seen! I ultimately went with the Cards because:

          - He indeed won his lone WS with the Cards
          - He had his single best year with the Cards ('84)
          - Though he won his Cy with the Cubs, 3 out of 4 years with the Cards he finished Top 5 in Cy Young voting

          Ultimately I agree that either one is fine and Atlanta is out.


          • #6
            His legend is with the Cubs, by my recollection. Most games. Cy.

            Best argument for the Cards is the WS win.

            I'm not sure his best season wasn't 1977.


            • #7
              I think of him as a Cardinal, but he should wear a Yankee hat and remind everyone that he's taking up Gossage's spot.


              • #8
                Struck out Gorman Thomas,9th inning Game 7, 82 WS, wearing the Cardinal hat.

                I will agree that Bruce was at his best during the Cub years.
                It Might Be? It Could Be?? It Is!


                • #9
                  As a Cub because that is where he became "revolutionary"


                  • #10
                    Sutter to wear Cards cap on Hall plaque

                    01/11/2006 3:40 PM ET
                    By Barry M. Bloom /

                    NEW YORK -- Bruce Sutter will enter the National Baseball Hall of Fame on July 30 with the interlocking S, T and L of the St. Louis Cardinals on his cap, an official of the shrine in Cooperstown, N.Y., said on Wednesday.
                    Sutter made history on Tuesday when he became the first pure reliever elected among the 196 players in the Hall, 103 by members of the Baseball Writers Association of America, who voted him in as this year's only inductee.

                    Sutter becomes the eighth member of the Cardinals and first since Ozzie Smith in 2002 to go into the Hall representing the Redbirds. Smith also was the lone inductee at the time. The others are Lou Brock, Dizzy Dean, Bob Gibson, Stan Musial, Red Schoendienst and Enos Slaughter. The Cardinals list 37 players, 14 of them pitchers, who played at least a portion of their careers in St. Louis and are enshrined in the Hall.

                    "My sons remember me most as a Cardinal," Sutter said. "My one son is 26 years old and I don't think he's ever seen me without a beard. It's not as black as it used to be, but it's still there."

                    Sutter came up with the Cubs and finished with the Braves during the course of his 13-year career that ended in 1988. He played five years each in Chicago and St. Louis before grinding out the last four in Atlanta, where he experienced severe shoulder problems from the repetition of using the split-finger fastball as his out pitch. Incidentally, Ryne Sandberg, who played his entire career in Chicago, went in last year as a Cub.

                    Sutter's career hit its zenith, though, when he helped the Cardinals defeat the Brewers in Game 7 of the 1982 World Series. Sutter pitched two hitless, shutout innings to earn his second save of the series and punched out Brewers center fielder Gorman Thomas to give the Cardinals their last World Series title.

                    "My family identifies with me throwing that last pitch to Gorman Thomas," Sutter said. "I'm certainly thankful for what the Cubs did for me. I respect their organization. It's the same way with the Atlanta Braves, an awfully fine organization. I respect everybody who's down there and that's still where I live today. But the Cardinals represent the best years of my career."

                    No matter, it wasn't his choice. And on Wednesday, Sutter appeared at a press conference in Manhattan and was asked to don a dark blue cap with a Hall of Fame insignia above the brim and a white jersey with Hall of Fame embossed in script across the chest. A photo placard of Sutter to the right of the dais showed the bearded right-hander throwing off the mound in Cardinals garb juxtaposed to a black and white photo of a young clean-shaven Sutter wearing his Cubs uniform.

                    The cap issue wasn't even addressed on Wednesday until it was broached by a member of the media.

                    "It's the Hall of Fame's call now," said Dale Petroskey, the Hall's long-time president. "Because Bruce played with three great organizations, we agonized about what logo we'd place on the cap on his plaque. But in the end, I think he and we thought the Cardinals were the most appropriate choice, recognizing that he had some great years in Chicago and finished in Atlanta. But all that will be documented on his plaque."

                    Hall officials took over the process of designating the team that is represented on a player's plaque after Kirby Puckett and Dave Winfield were inducted in 2001. Puckett, of course, played his entire career for the Twins.

                    The Hall's decision came amidst reports that Winfield had shopped his Hall of Fame affiliation before determining to go in as a member of the Padres, the team that drafted him and gave him his start in the Major Leagues. Winfield played 22 seasons with six teams, including his first eight with the Padres and his next eight with the Yankees.

                    Since then, the Hall has had some tough decisions, opting to have Gary Carter go in as the only member of the Montreal Expos in 2003 rather than his glory days with the 1986 champion Mets, and designating Wade Boggs as a member of the Red Sox last year, even though he won his only World Series with the Yankees and collected his 3,000th hit with Tampa Bay.

                    Sutter, who received 76.9 percent of the vote -- only 1.9 percent more than the necessary 75 percent to gain election -- was an equally tough decision for Hall officials.

                    He was signed with the Cubs in 1971 and made his way up through their Minor League system, where he developed his trademark pitch. After a decade in that organization he was traded to the Cardinals on Dec. 9, 1980, in the deal that sent Leon Durham and Ken Reitz to Chicago.

                    "The Cubs gave me a chance to play," Sutter said. "They signed me as a free agent and brought me to the Major Leagues. The first day I walked into Wrigley Field was one of the best days of my life. And I owe them an awful lot."

                    Then, after saving a career-high 45 games for the Cardinals in 1984, Sutter signed a four-year, $6.5 million deal with the Braves, a contract that might pale in comparison to the four-year, $43 million pact left-handed closer Billy Wagner recently signed with the Mets, but was one of the most lucrative at the time.

                    Sutter, though, blew out his shoulder and was never a factor in Atlanta. He pitched the 1985 season hurt, had surgery that offseason, rushed back and tore his labrum, sat out the entire 1987 season and wound up making only 112 appearances and saving 40 games for the Braves.

                    "I hurt my shoulder down there and if I had one regret, its that I could never pitch," Sutter said. "But if I hadn't thrown the split-finger, I would've never have made the Major Leagues. I would've been at best a Double-A player. So if they told me it was going to hurt my arm I'd do it all over again."

                    Barry M. Bloom is a national reporter for This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.
                    Behold My Annoyingly Long Signature

                    St. Louis Cardinals
                    American Association Champions
                    National League Champions
                    World Champions


                    • #11
                      I thought he should have gone as a Cub but now that I think of it, when Ryne Sandburg jacked two homers off him in that NBC game in 1984, it's more fitting that he go as a Cardinal.
                      "Batting slumps? I never had one. When a guy hits .358, he doesn't have slumps."

                      Rogers Hornsby, 1961


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by DoubleX
                        I think of him as a Cardinal, but he should wear a Yankee hat and remind everyone that he's taking up Gossage's spot.
                        The heart bleeds at the Yankee pity party.
                        Dave Bill Tom George Mark Bob Ernie Soupy Dick Alex Sparky
                        Joe Gary MCA Emanuel Sonny Dave Earl Stan
                        Jonathan Neil Roger Anthony Ray Thomas Art Don
                        Gates Philip John Warrior Rik Casey Tony Horace
                        Robin Bill Ernie JEDI


                        • #13
                          I don't know. What do you think Los Bravos ?


                          • #14
                            They should make split hats like when parents have those half-n-half jerseys when two kids are on different teams.

                            Missed opportunity.


                            • #15
                              This came up on a Met forum a few months ago actually. I then went through a Google search rabbit hole to see if there was any sort of bad blood between Sutter and the Cub organization.

                              But, though it may have to do with the regency bias of Google’s algorithms, but all I could find doing quickie searches for “Sutter Cubs” or “Sutter Wrigley” was articles and images looking back at either his Cub playing days, or The Sandberg Game in 1984.

                              Not a thing about him and the organization post retirement/post HOF induction. No recent images of him on the field at Wrigley or about to lead the crowd in Take Me Out The Ball Game.

                              So, is there something going on between him and the organization still going some 40 years later?
                              NY Sports Day Independent Gotham Sports Coverage
                              Mets360 Mets Past, Present and Future
                              Talking Mets Baseball. A baseball blog with a Mets bias


                              Ad Widget