Which Hat Should They Wear?

[DoubleX]

Among players eligible and future HOF'ers, that had several teams (not players that we do know which team they'll go in the Hall for):

-Bert Blyleven: Minnesotta Twins
-Goose Gossage: New York Yankees
-Andre Dawson: Montreal Expos
-Tommy John: New York Yankees
-Dave Parker: Pittsburgh Pirates
-Lee Smith: Chicago Cubs
-Harold Baines: Chicago White Sox
-Tim Raines: Montreal Expos (The Greatest Player on the Franchise)
-Rickey Henderson: Oakland Athletics
-Matt Williams: San Francisco Giants
-Roberto Alomar: Toronto Blue Jays
-Roger Clemens: Boston Red Sox
-Mike Piazza: New York Mets
-Randy Johnson: Arizona Diamondbacks

- Blyleven: Might get in (and should get in)
- Gossage: Likely getting in.
- Dawson: Might get in.
- John: Likely not getting in.
- Parker: Likely not getting in.
- Smith: Might get in.
- Baines: Likely not getting in.
- Raines: Should get in, but I shudder when I think of how he'll likely be treated by the writers.
- Henderson: First balloter.
- Williams: Likely one and done.
- Alomar: Likely getting in within first few years of eligibility.
- Clemens: First balloter.
- Piazza: Likely first balloter.
- Johnson: First balloter.

[redban]

Also,Piazza has said himself,that'd he like to go in as a Met...

http://newyork.mets.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/news/article.jsp?ymd=20060420&content_id=1410435&vkey=news_nym&fext=.jsp&c_id=nym

So to some of you guys who believes the player should decide themselves...there ya go.

[Yankillaz]

Among players eligible and future HOF'ers, that had several teams (not players that we do know which team they'll go in the Hall for):

-Bert Blyleven: Minnesotta Twins
-Goose Gossage: New York Yankees
-Andre Dawson: Montreal Expos
-Tommy John: New York Yankees
-Dave Parker: Pittsburgh Pirates
-Lee Smith: Chicago Cubs
-Harold Baines: Chicago White Sox
-Tim Raines: Montreal Expos (The Greatest Player on the Franchise)
-Rickey Henderson: Oakland Athletics
-Matt Williams: San Francisco Giants
-Roberto Alomar: Toronto Blue Jays
-Roger Clemens: Boston Red Sox
-Mike Piazza: New York Mets
-Randy Johnson: Arizona Diamondbacks

[runningshoes]

Like I said. I'm a Yankee fan but I think Roger should have a Red Sox cap on his plaque.

I know you think that but there are those out there who are delusional.

[Yankillaz]

Piaza should go in as a Met and Alomar as a Blue Jay, if he goes in at all.

I think the same as you.

[soberdennis]

Out of interest, is your avatar A's because they SWEPT you? :gt

Yes, as my version of a suggestion someone made a few weeks ago, I am putting the avatar of the winner of the last Yankee game. I even Had the RedSox avatar last Thursday. (That was painful.)
My sig is the lineup of the final game of various WS the Yanks have won. It will change every time the Yanks win.
If they win tonight, I'll revert to a Yankee avatar and the 1941 lineup. If they lose, I'll put an Indian avatar up.

[Outta Here]

Like I said. I'm a Yankee fan but I think Roger should have a Red Sox cap on his plaque.

Out of interest, is your avatar A's because they SWEPT you? :gt

[soberdennis]

Like I said. I'm a Yankee fan but I think Roger should have a Red Sox cap on his plaque.

[runningshoes]

ESPN on the day he won his 300th game had a poll on what should be on Roger's cap. This Yankee fan did not flinch a bit when he said the Red Sox, because there is where he had his greatest years

Any who thinks Clemens will go in with anything other than a Red Sox cap on his head, is delusional.

[starkeeper]

Maddux-Braves
Johnson-Diamondbacks
Piazza-Mets
Alomar-Blue Jays
Girffey-Mariners

[ivylover]

Maddux-Cubs!
Johnson-Diamondbacks
Piazza-Mets
Alomar-Blue Jays
Girffey-Mariners

[soberdennis]

Dawson-Expos
Piazza-Dodgers
Alomar-Blue Jays
---------------
Clemens-Red Sox
Johnson-Diamondacks
Maddux-Braves
Gossage-Yankees
Blyleven-Twins

I agree with all of the above.
Dawson will probably go down in history as the Expos greatest player. Even though he won the MVP with the Cubs. Montreal should get this one last honor.
Piazza, to me will always be a Dodger, even now that he is playing here in San Diego.where we hate the Dodgers.
ESPN on the day he won his 300th game had a poll on what should be on Roger's cap. This Yankee fan did not flinch a bit when he said the Red Sox, because there is where he had his greatest years and played the longest
Blyleven is a Twin.
Goose had his best years wearing pinstripes.
Alomar is the toughest. But I'll go with Toronto.
Johnson is a toss up between Seattle and Arizona.
How about McGwire? Cards or A's

[thecoach]

I can not believe no one has talked about Jeff Kent. He must go as a Giant because of the great years he had there and the MVP he won when he was a Giant. He also has the best Power numbers of any 2b. in ML history, at least in the modern era.

[Outta Here]

I disagree, Piazza goes with Dodgers. Simply because of that amazing hairstyle & moustache he had while there!

Lgendary

[JohnGelnarFan]

I agree with these. They made their mark with these clubs.

Dawson-Expos
Piazza-Dodgers
Alomar-Blue Jays
---------------
Clemens-Red Sox
Johnson-Diamondacks
Maddux-Braves
Gossage-Yankees
Blyleven-Twins