Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Your Favorite Team Hall of Fame

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • NJRob65
    replied
    Minnesota Twins/Washington Senators

    C- Joe Mauer
    1B(3B)- Harmon Killebrew
    2B(1B)- Rod Carew
    3B(RF)- Buddy Lewis
    SS- Joe Cronin
    LF- Goose Goslin
    CF(RF)- Kirby Puckett
    RF- Tony Oliva
    SP- Walter Johnson
    SP- Bert Blyleven
    SP- Johan Santana
    SP- Brad Radke
    SP- Camilo Pascual
    SP- Jim Perry
    SP- Jim Kaat
    RP/SP- Firpo Marberry
    RP- Rick Aguilera
    RP- Joe Nathan

    Reserves:

    2B- Chuck Knoblauch
    RF- Sam Rice
    2B/3B- Buddy Myer
    RF/LF- Bob Allison
    1B- Kent Hrbek
    1B- Joe Judge
    SS/3B- Cecil Travis
    CF/LF/3B/2B/RF/SS- Cesar Tovar

    MGR-Tom Kelly & Ron Gardenhire, flip a coin.
    GM- Andy MacPhail
    Owner- Carl Pohlad
    Last edited by NJRob65; 03-27-2020, 11:42 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    San Diego Padres

    C(1B)- Gene Teance
    1B- Adrain Gonzalez
    2B- Roberto Alomar
    3B- Ken Caminiti
    SS- Ozzie Smith
    LF- Gene Richards
    CF- Kevin McReynolds
    RF- Tony Gwynn
    SP- Jake Peavy
    SP- Andy Ashby
    SP- Andy Benes
    SP- Joey Hamilton
    SP- Bruce Hurst
    SP- Kevin Brown
    RP/Sp- Greg W. Harris
    RP- Heath Bell
    RP- Mark Davis
    RP- Trevor Hoffman

    Reserves;

    RF/CF- Dave Winfield
    3B/1B- Phil Nevin
    RF- Brian Giles
    3B- Chase Headley
    1B/LF- Ryan Klesko
    2B- Mark Loretta
    C-Terry Kennedy
    1B- Nate Colbert

    MGR- Dick Williams
    GM- Jack McKeon
    Owner- Ray Kroc

    Note: Garry Templeton(SS) has a -6.7bWAA and wasn't included.
    Last edited by NJRob65; 03-26-2020, 08:59 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    Los Angeles Angeles(Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, Anaheim Angels, California Angels)


    C(1B)- Mke Napoli
    1B(LF)- Darin Erstad
    2B- Bobby Grich
    3B- Troy Glaus
    SS-JIm Fregosi
    LF- Brian Downing
    CF- Mike Trout
    RF- Tim Salmon
    SP- Chuck Finley
    SP- Nolan Ryan
    SP- Frank Tanana
    SP- Jerred Weaver
    SP- Mark Langston
    SP- Dean Chance
    SP- John Lackey
    RP- Bryan Harvey
    RP- Troy Percival
    RP- Francisco Rodriguez

    Reserves:

    SS- Andrelton Simmons
    2B- Howie Kendrick
    CF- Jim Edmonds
    RF- Vladimir Guerrero
    CF/RF- Torii Hunter
    3B- Doug DeCInces
    3B/2BCF- Chone Figgins
    1B- Rod Carew

    MGR- Mike Scioscia
    GM- Buzzie Bavasi
    Owner- Gene Autry

    Note: Garret Anderson(LF)- Has a -1.7bWAA. and is not included.

    Leave a comment:


  • bluesky5
    replied
    St. James Friars

    Lineup:

    C - Terry Kennedy
    1B - Nate Colbert
    2B - Mark Loretta
    SS - Garry Templeton
    3B - Ken Caminiti
    LF - Adrian Gonzalez
    CF - Dave Winfield
    RF - Tony Gwynn
    SP - Jake Peavy

    Bench:

    Brian Giles - OF
    Ryan Klesko - 1B/COF
    Gene Richards - 1B/OF

    Khalil Green - MIF
    Phil Nevin - CIF/COF
    Chase Headley - 3B
    Gene Tenace - 1B/C

    Benito Santiago - C

    Starting pitchers:

    Andy Ashby
    Andy Benes
    Randy Jones
    Eric Show
    Ed Whitson

    Bullpen:

    Mark Davis - LHS
    Heath Bell - MR
    Trevor Hoffman - CL

    Leave a comment:


  • SamtheBravesFan
    replied
    Originally posted by Los Bravos View Post

    That's pretty much what I did, especially for relievers.

    I really don't think anyone would mind if you did your own Braves list. I think a few teams have multiple people choosing them.
    No problem. I'll see if I have a different opinion. I don't think we'll differ on the rotation much!

    Leave a comment:


  • Los Bravos
    replied
    Originally posted by SamtheBravesFan View Post

    I figured it wasn't against the rules, so I included the Hall of Famers that spent even a little time with them.
    That's pretty much what I did, especially for relievers.

    I really don't think anyone would mind if you did your own Braves list. I think a few teams have multiple people choosing them.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    Oakland/Kansas City/ Philadelphia Athletics:


    C- Mickey Cochrane
    1B- Jimmie Foxx
    2B- Eddie Collins
    3B- Frank "Home Run" Baker
    SS- Bert Campaneris
    LF- Rickey Henderson
    CF/LF- Al Simmons
    RF- Reggie Jackson
    SP- Lefty Grove
    SP- Eddie Plank
    SP- Rube Waddell
    SP- Eddie Rommel
    SP- Tim Hudson
    SP- Chief Bender
    SP- Barry Zito
    RP/SP- Bobby Shantz
    RP- Rollie Fingers
    RP- Dennis Eckersley

    Reserves:

    3B- Sal Bando
    1B- Mark McGwire
    LF- Indian Bob Johnson
    CF- Dwayne Murphy
    3B- Eric Chavez
    2B- Max Bishop
    SS- Eddie Jost
    C/1B- Gene Tenace

    Catfish Hunter was not accidentally omitted, one could include him and exclude Bobby Shantz or include both and drop Gene Tenace.
    Last edited by NJRob65; 03-25-2020, 09:31 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Cougar
    replied
    I'm totally good with that; it's a free country.

    Leave a comment:


  • SamtheBravesFan
    replied
    Originally posted by Cougar View Post

    That's a more formidable roster than I would have guessed, given the Rangers' less than imposing historical profile.

    Part of the explanation for that: Among the pitchers, most of those guys didn't spend much of their careers, nor had their best seasons, in Texas.

    Lastly, I hate to nitpick, but maybe Kevin Brown ought to be included?
    I figured it wasn't against the rules, so I included the Hall of Famers that spent even a little time with them.

    And yeah, maybe he can be on there instead of Jamie Moyer. I don't really want to squeeze Jeff Russell out.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    Originally posted by PVNICK View Post
    The Tigers bench is crazy good.
    True, especially right field.

    Leave a comment:


  • PVNICK
    replied
    The Tigers bench is crazy good.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    Detroit Tigers:

    C- Bill Freehan
    1B- Hank Greenberg
    2B- Charlie Gehringer
    3B/1B- Miguel Cabrera
    SS- Alan Trammell
    LF- Bobby Veach
    CF- Ty Cobb
    RF- Al Kaline
    SP- Hal Newhouser
    SP- Justin Verlander
    SP- Tommy Bridges
    SP- Dizzy Trout
    SP- Mickey Lolich
    SP- Bill Donovan
    SP- Jim Bunning
    SP- Jack Morris
    RP- Mike Henneman
    RP- John Hiller

    Reserves:

    2B- Lou Whitaker
    RF- Harry Heilmann
    RF/CF- Sam Crawford
    1B- Norm Cash
    CF- Chet Lemon
    C- Lance Parrish
    2B/3B- Dick McAuliffe
    3B- George Kell

    Note: Jack Morris & George Kell were only included because they are HoFers. Frank Lary & Toy Phillips(2B/3B/LF/Rf) would have been included. Mickey Cochrane wasn't included because he didn't play well enough and I felt including him was too much of a stretch.

    MGR- Jim Leyland
    GM- Dave Dombroski

    Last edited by NJRob65; 03-25-2020, 01:45 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • NJRob65
    replied
    Originally posted by Cougar View Post

    That's a more formidable roster than I would have guessed, given the Rangers' less than imposing historical profile.

    Part of the explanation for that: Among the pitchers, most of those guys didn't spend much of their careers, nor had their best seasons, in Texas.

    Lastly, I hate to nitpick, but maybe Kevin Brown ought to be included?
    I had previously compiled a Ranger/Senator team on post #17. A few of these HoF players, Vladimir Guerrero, Harold Baines & Goose Gossage, don't belong. The originator of this project, jpm74, is a Met fan and to his credit, did not include Richie Ashburn, Duke Snider, Warren Spahn or Willie Mays on his team.

    Kevin Brown only had a 108OPS+ a 17.7bWAR & a 5.0bWAA. I agree with SamtheBravesFan omission of him.

    Leave a comment:


  • Cougar
    replied
    Originally posted by SamtheBravesFan View Post
    Since Los Bravos did the Braves, I'll do the Rangers, my second-favorite team!

    C - Ivan Rodriguez
    1B - Rafael Palmiero
    2B - Michael Young
    SS - Alex Rodriguez
    3B - Adrian Beltre
    LF - Frank Howard
    CF - Josh Hamilton
    RF - Juan Gonzalez
    DH - Vladimir Guerrero

    BN - Ian Kinsler
    BN - Hank Blalock
    BN - Harold Baines
    BN - Jim Sundberg
    BN - Elvis Andrus

    SP - Nolan Ryan
    SP - Fergie Jenkins

    SP - Gaylord Perry
    SP - Bert Blyleven
    SP - Yu Darvish

    SW - Charlie Hough
    SW - Jamie Moyer
    SW - Kenny Rogers
    RP - Rich Gossage
    RP - Tom Henke
    RP - Jeff Russell
    CL - John Wetteland (Yeah yeah, I know. Him being a garbage human doesn't mean he's off the list)
    That's a more formidable roster than I would have guessed, given the Rangers' less than imposing historical profile.

    Part of the explanation for that: Among the pitchers, most of those guys didn't spend much of their careers, nor had their best seasons, in Texas.

    Lastly, I hate to nitpick, but maybe Kevin Brown ought to be included?
    Last edited by Cougar; 03-25-2020, 11:52 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • SamtheBravesFan
    replied
    Since Los Bravos did the Braves, I'll do the Rangers, my second-favorite team!

    C - Ivan Rodriguez
    1B - Rafael Palmiero
    2B - Michael Young
    SS - Alex Rodriguez
    3B - Adrian Beltre
    LF - Frank Howard
    CF - Josh Hamilton
    RF - Juan Gonzalez
    DH - Vladimir Guerrero

    BN - Ian Kinsler
    BN - Hank Blalock
    BN - Harold Baines
    BN - Jim Sundberg
    BN - Elvis Andrus

    SP - Nolan Ryan
    SP - Fergie Jenkins

    SP - Gaylord Perry
    SP - Bert Blyleven
    SP - Yu Darvish

    SW - Charlie Hough
    SW - Jamie Moyer
    SW - Kenny Rogers
    RP - Rich Gossage
    RP - Tom Henke
    RP - Jeff Russell
    CL - John Wetteland (Yeah yeah, I know. Him being a garbage human doesn't mean he's off the list)

    Leave a comment:

Ad Widget

Collapse
Working...
X