Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

the first 80 The rankings

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • the first 80 The rankings

    Thanks to everyone who has responded to my HOF ranking threads I appreciate the great insight too.

    once again, here is the grading scale. The final 20 is next;

    5-Why is he not in? (if he was eligible)
    4- Has a good case
    3- marginal, has some merit
    2-comes up short
    1-are you kidding me?


    the rankings:

    Jeff Bagwell 4.84
    Jim Thome 4.79
    Ivan Rodriquez 4.67
    Manny Ramirez 4.67
    Craig Biggio 4.63
    John Smoltz 4.59
    Vladimir Guerrero 4.55
    Alan Trammel 4.48
    Curt Schilling 4.47
    Mike Mussina 4.34
    Tim Raines 4.32
    Dick Allen 4.31
    Bill Dahlen 4.29
    Lou Whitaker 4.29
    Jeff Kent 4.18
    Bobby Grich 4.03
    Larry Walker 3.89
    Edgar Martinez 3.79
    Gary Sheffield 3.76
    Tony Oliva 3.73
    Todd Helton 3.72
    Jim Edmonds 3.68
    Ted Simmons 3.67
    Joe Torre 3.47
    Dwight Evans 3.39
    Keilth Henandez 3.39
    Dale Murphy 3.38
    Ken Boyer 3.35
    Carlos Delgado 3.33
    Kenny Lofton 3.29
    Graig Nettles 3.22
    Scott Rolen 3.21
    Will Clark 3.19
    Albert Belle 3.16
    Darrell Evans 3.06
    Bernie Williams 3.06
    Andruw Jones 3.05
    Louis Tiant 3.05
    Lee Smith 3.00
    Gil Hodges 2.96
    Dave Parker 2.91
    Kevin Brown 2.89
    Dave Stieb 2.88
    Jim Wynn 2.88
    David Cone 2.85
    Billy Pierce 2.85
    Ron Guidry 2.81
    Jim Kaat 2.74
    Dave Concepcion 2.69
    Tommy John 2.68
    Bobby Abreau 2.65
    John McGraw 2.65
    Steve Garvey 2.62
    Jack Morris 2.58
    Norm Cash 2.58
    Lonnie Warneke 2.56
    John Franco 2.53
    Jimmy Ryan 2.47
    Maury Wills 2.44
    Johnny Damon 2.39
    Brett Saberhagen 2.37
    Tommy Leach 2.35
    Dwight Gooden 2.33
    Buddy Bell 2.33
    Omar Visquel 2.32
    Jack Clark 2.28
    Jake Daubert 2.28
    Vida Blue 2.27
    Mickey Lolich 2.24
    Jose Cruz 2.18
    Harold Baines 2.18
    Dennis Martinez 1.94
    Charlie Keller 1.88
    Mike Donlin 1.82
    Frank White 1.78
    Mel Harder 1.73
    Sam McDowell 1.72
    Milt Pappas 1.65
    Dave Stewart 1.61
    Marty Marion 1.53
    This week's Giant

    #5 in games played as a Giant with 1721 , Bill Terry

Ad Widget

Collapse
Working...
X