Tweet
Here are the totals. We have moved HOF selection on this informal rating to a 3.75 average. Thank you to everyone who is participating. 25 more to come.
Greg Maddux 5.00
Derek Jeter 5.00
Randy Johnson 5.00
Pedro Martinez 4.93
Chipper Jones 4.92
Tom Glavine 4.89
Jeff Bagwell 4.84
Frank Thomas 4.83
Jim Thome 4.79
Ivan Rodriquez 4.70
Craig Biggio 4.63
John Smoltz 4.59
Barry Bonds 4.56
Alex Rodriquez 4.56
Vladimir Guerrero 4.55
Roger Clemens 4.50
Alan Trammel 4.48
Curt Schilling 4.47
Mike Mussina 4.34
Tim Raines 4.32
Dick Allen 4.31
Manny Ramirez 4.30
Bill Dahlen 4.29
Lou Whitaker 4.29
Jeff Kent 4.18
Bob Caruthers 4.07
Bobby Grich 4.03
Sherry Magee 4.00
Larry Walker 3.89
Edgar Martinez 3.79
Gary Sheffield 3.76
Tony Oliva 3.73
Stan Hack 3.71
Jim Edmonds 3.68
Minnie Minnoso 3.67
Ted Simmons 3.60
Rafael Palmeiro 3.57
Todd Helton 3.55
Andruw Jones 3.54
Mark McGwire 3.50
Joe Torre 3.47
Fred McGriff 3.44
Dwight Evans 3.39
Dale Murphy 3.38
Tony Mullane 3.36
Ken Boyer 3.35
Carlos Beltran 3.31
Carlos Delgado 3.30
Graig Nettles 3.30
Kenny Lofton 3.29
Jack Glasscock 3.29
Keilth Henandez 3.25
Jim McCormick 3.21
Urban Shocker 3.21
Scott Rolen 3.21
Will Clark 3.19
Albert Belle 3.16
Bobby Bonds 3.15
Bob Johnson 3.14
Sammy Sosa 3.11
Pete Browning 3.07
Andruw Jones 3.05
Louis Tiant 3.05
Darrell Evans 3.05
Bernie Williams 3.05
Lee Smith 3.00
Bill Freehan 3.00
Heinie Groh 3.00
Willie Randolph 3.00
Al Oliver 3.00
Vern Stephens 2.96
Gil Hodges 2.96
Kenny Lofton 2.94
Hardy Richardson 2.93
Bobby Abreu 2.92
Dave Parker 2.91
Kevin Brown 2.89
Dave Stieb 2.88
Jim Wynn 2.88
David Cone 2.85
Billy Pierce 2.85
Cesar Cedeno 2.85
Ron Guidry 2.81
Jim Kaat 2.74
Rick Reuschel 2.71
Dave Concepcion 2.69
Bucky Walters 2.69
Tommy John 2.68
Bobby Abreau 2.65
John McGraw 2.65
Steve Garvey 2.62
Vada Pinson 2.61
Jack Morris 2.58
Norm Cash 2.58
Sal Bando 2.57
Andres Galarraga 2.54
John Franco 2.53
Lonnie Warneke 2.50
Jimmy Ryan 2.47
Johnny Damon 2.45
Buddy Bell 2.40
Maury Wills 2.40
Allie Reynolds 2.38
Bert Campaneris 2.38
Brett Saberhagen 2.37
Babe Adams 2.36
Tommy Leach 2.35
Omar Visquel 2.32
David Ortiz 2.31
Dolph Camilli 2.31
Jack Clark 2.30
Willie Davis 2.29
Orel Hershiser 2.28
Mickey Vernon 2.28
Vida Blue 2.27
Jake Daubert 2.25
Jack Quinn 2.25
Mickey Lolich 2.24
Rusty Staub 2.22
Dwight Gooden 2.20
Jose Cruz 2.18
Harold Baines 2.18
Roger Maris 2.17
Bill Madlock 2.15
Dom Dimaggio 2.08
Jose Canseco 2.00
Gene Tenace 2.00
Kevin Appier 2.00
Chris Carpenter 2.00
Darryl Strawberry 2.00
Chet Lemon 1.93
Charlie Keller 1.88
Chuck Finley 1.86
Dennis Martinez 1.85
Babe Herman 1.85
Mike Donlin 1.82
Frank White 1.80
Art Fletcher 1.77
Mel Harder 1.73
Dave McNally 1.69
Sam McDowell 1.65
Milt Pappas 1.65
Ben Chapman 1.62
Dave Stewart 1.55
Bobo Newsom 1.54
Clyde Milan 1.54
Marty Marion 1.53
Adam Dunn 1.46
Dave Kingman 1.46
Greg Maddux 5.00
Derek Jeter 5.00
Randy Johnson 5.00
Pedro Martinez 4.93
Chipper Jones 4.92
Tom Glavine 4.89
Jeff Bagwell 4.84
Frank Thomas 4.83
Jim Thome 4.79
Ivan Rodriquez 4.70
Craig Biggio 4.63
John Smoltz 4.59
Barry Bonds 4.56
Alex Rodriquez 4.56
Vladimir Guerrero 4.55
Roger Clemens 4.50
Alan Trammel 4.48
Curt Schilling 4.47
Mike Mussina 4.34
Tim Raines 4.32
Dick Allen 4.31
Manny Ramirez 4.30
Bill Dahlen 4.29
Lou Whitaker 4.29
Jeff Kent 4.18
Bob Caruthers 4.07
Bobby Grich 4.03
Sherry Magee 4.00
Larry Walker 3.89
Edgar Martinez 3.79
Gary Sheffield 3.76
Tony Oliva 3.73
Stan Hack 3.71
Jim Edmonds 3.68
Minnie Minnoso 3.67
Ted Simmons 3.60
Rafael Palmeiro 3.57
Todd Helton 3.55
Andruw Jones 3.54
Mark McGwire 3.50
Joe Torre 3.47
Fred McGriff 3.44
Dwight Evans 3.39
Dale Murphy 3.38
Tony Mullane 3.36
Ken Boyer 3.35
Carlos Beltran 3.31
Carlos Delgado 3.30
Graig Nettles 3.30
Kenny Lofton 3.29
Jack Glasscock 3.29
Keilth Henandez 3.25
Jim McCormick 3.21
Urban Shocker 3.21
Scott Rolen 3.21
Will Clark 3.19
Albert Belle 3.16
Bobby Bonds 3.15
Bob Johnson 3.14
Sammy Sosa 3.11
Pete Browning 3.07
Andruw Jones 3.05
Louis Tiant 3.05
Darrell Evans 3.05
Bernie Williams 3.05
Lee Smith 3.00
Bill Freehan 3.00
Heinie Groh 3.00
Willie Randolph 3.00
Al Oliver 3.00
Vern Stephens 2.96
Gil Hodges 2.96
Kenny Lofton 2.94
Hardy Richardson 2.93
Bobby Abreu 2.92
Dave Parker 2.91
Kevin Brown 2.89
Dave Stieb 2.88
Jim Wynn 2.88
David Cone 2.85
Billy Pierce 2.85
Cesar Cedeno 2.85
Ron Guidry 2.81
Jim Kaat 2.74
Rick Reuschel 2.71
Dave Concepcion 2.69
Bucky Walters 2.69
Tommy John 2.68
Bobby Abreau 2.65
John McGraw 2.65
Steve Garvey 2.62
Vada Pinson 2.61
Jack Morris 2.58
Norm Cash 2.58
Sal Bando 2.57
Andres Galarraga 2.54
John Franco 2.53
Lonnie Warneke 2.50
Jimmy Ryan 2.47
Johnny Damon 2.45
Buddy Bell 2.40
Maury Wills 2.40
Allie Reynolds 2.38
Bert Campaneris 2.38
Brett Saberhagen 2.37
Babe Adams 2.36
Tommy Leach 2.35
Omar Visquel 2.32
David Ortiz 2.31
Dolph Camilli 2.31
Jack Clark 2.30
Willie Davis 2.29
Orel Hershiser 2.28
Mickey Vernon 2.28
Vida Blue 2.27
Jake Daubert 2.25
Jack Quinn 2.25
Mickey Lolich 2.24
Rusty Staub 2.22
Dwight Gooden 2.20
Jose Cruz 2.18
Harold Baines 2.18
Roger Maris 2.17
Bill Madlock 2.15
Dom Dimaggio 2.08
Jose Canseco 2.00
Gene Tenace 2.00
Kevin Appier 2.00
Chris Carpenter 2.00
Darryl Strawberry 2.00
Chet Lemon 1.93
Charlie Keller 1.88
Chuck Finley 1.86
Dennis Martinez 1.85
Babe Herman 1.85
Mike Donlin 1.82
Frank White 1.80
Art Fletcher 1.77
Mel Harder 1.73
Dave McNally 1.69
Sam McDowell 1.65
Milt Pappas 1.65
Ben Chapman 1.62
Dave Stewart 1.55
Bobo Newsom 1.54
Clyde Milan 1.54
Marty Marion 1.53
Adam Dunn 1.46
Dave Kingman 1.46