Top Pitchers of All Time Poll-#18

[Myankee4life]

1.Marichal
2.Koufax
3.Roberts
4.Ford
5.Hubbel
6.Brown
7.Plank
8.Walsh
9.Ryan
10. Palmer

[abacab]

Rank in this poll....name.....rank in last poll....difference

1... Walter Johnson......1.......0
2....Roger Clemens.......5......+3
3....Lefty Grove.........2......-1
4....Cy Young............4.......0
5....Pete Alexander......6......+1
6....Christy Mathewson...3......-3
7....Greg Maddux.........7.......0
8....Tom Seaver.........10......+2
9....Warren Spahn........8......-1
10...Satchel Paige.......9......-1
11...Randy Johnson......11.......0
12...Bob Feller.........13......+1
13...Kid Nichols........14......+1
14...Bob Gibson.........15......+1
15...Steve Carlton......16(T)...+1
16...Pedro Martinez.....18......+2
17...Joe Williams.......25......+8

[Edgartohof]

1. Sandy Koufax
2. Nolan Ryan
3. Juan Marichal
4. Robin Roberts
5. Carl Hubbell
6. Mordecai Brown
7. Jim Palmer
8. Dazzy Vance
9. Whitey Ford
10. Ed Walsh

[christian gentleman]

next 10 (koufax should be in already)

I can't believe that koufax isn't on this list already.

1. sandy koufax
2. whitey ford
3. nolan ryan
4. amos rusie
5. addie joss
6. mordecai brown
7. juan marichal
8. rube waddell
9. dazzy vance
10. jim palmer

[KCGHOST]

1. Clarkson
2. Keefe
3. Rusie
4. Hubbell
5. Ford
6. Newhouser
7. M. Brown
8. Marichal
9. Koufax
10. Palmer

[iPod]

I usually won't vote on these but I can't believe that Marichal is actually threatening to finish above Koufax. So...

1) Marichal
2) Hubbell
3) Roberts
4) Ryan
5) Kaneda
6) Bullet Joe Rogan
7) Fingers
8) Quisenberry
9) Ford
10) Koufax

[yanks0714]

I usually won't vote on these but I can't believe that Marichal is actually threatening to finish above Koufax. So...

1) Marichal
2) Hubbell
3) Roberts
4) Ryan
5) Kaneda
6) Bullet Joe Rogan
7) Fingers
8) Quisenberry
9) Ford
10) Koufax

The ONLY way Koufax should ever finish ahead of Marichal is when ramking the players by 'peak' only. Even then Sandy isn't as far ahead of Juan as you might think.

[iPod]

The ONLY way Koufax should ever finish ahead of Marichal is when ramking the players by 'peak' only. Even then Sandy isn't as far ahead of Juan as you might think.

(Shhhh. I know.)

[RuthMayBond]

This is the 18th installment of the pitcher polls. The rules are simple, submit your top 10 pitcher list (minus already elected pitchers, which I"ll get to in a minute). Lists must be clearly numbered 1-10 and please make it easy to identify who you're voting for. 12 points will be awarded to your #1 selection, 9 to #2, 8 to #3, 7 to #4, and so on. The pitcher with the most points will win the poll. In the event of a tie, the pitcher with the most first place votes will win. In the event that they have the same amount of first place votes as well, we'll have a runoff poll that lasts two days between the two tied pitchers. Also, if you make any really strange decisions, you'll be asked to justify them. If you don't justify them, then your ballot won't be counted. So far we have elected these 10 pitchers:

1.Walter Johnson
2.Roger Clemens
3.Lefty Grove
4.Cy Young
5.Pete Alexander
6.Christy Mathewson
7.Greg Maddux
8.Tom Seaver
9.Warren Spahn
10.Satchel Paige
11.Randy Johnson
12.Bob Feller
13.Kid Nichols
14.Bob Gibson
15.Steve Carlton
16.Pedro Martinez
17.Smokey Joe Williams

I'll take
1.Hubbell
2.Walsh
3.Keefe
4.Clarkson
5.GaPerry
6.Plank
7.Blyleven
8.PNiekro
9.Rusie
10.Waddell
Burgess, myankee4life, Christian gentleman, waddup with HUBBELL?

[Bill Burgess]

Burgess, myankee4life, Christian gentleman, waddup with HUBBELL?

Patience, my good man. His day is coming. He's in the queue. Somewhere.

BB

[RuthMayBond]

Patience, my good man. His day is coming. He's in the queue. Somewhere.

BB

He's already overdue, and the sad thing is he probably won't be elected until AFTER Koufax :grouchy

[Bill Burgess]

He's already overdue, and the sad thing is he probably won't be elected until AFTER Koufax :grouchy

"There, there. Let Daddy kiss the boo boo."

[RuthMayBond]

"There, there. Let Daddy kiss the boo boo."

You wanna kiss the guys that are voting for Koufax?

[Bill Burgess]

You wanna kiss the guys that are voting for Koufax?

I don't think so, Jeff. Gotta draw the line. Now if perhaps they have girlfriends . . . we might have important matters to discuss.

Bill Burgess

[RuthMayBond]

Now if perhaps they have girlfriends . . . we might have important matters to discuss.

Bill Burgess

Bill, you are ALWAYS thinking