Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

BBF Ranking Game - Ultimate Results Thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • BBF Ranking Game - Ultimate Results Thread

    Lists are maintained herein for the convenience of both participants and observers.


    Overall Ranking
    1 to 100 (Babe Ruth to Fergie Jenkins)
    101 to 200 (Carl Hubbell to Bret Saberhagen)
    201 to 300 (Minnie Minoso to Orel Hershiser)
    301 to 400 (George Gore to Bus Clarkson)
    401 to 500 (Charley Jones to Schoolboy Rowe)
    501 to 600 (Hanley Ramirez to Augie Galan)
    601 to 700 (Red Schoendienst to Kris Bryant)
    701 to 800 (Bill White to Jason Schmidt)
    801 to 900 (Bob Rush to Preacher Roe)
    901 to 1,000 (Ted Kluszewski to Doyle Alexander)
    1,001 to 1,100 (Adam Dunn to Johnny Allen)
    1,101 to 1,200 (Bump Hadley to Woody Williams)
    1,201 to 1,300 (Buck Freeman to ?????)
    1,301 to 1,400 (????? to ?????)
    1,401 to 1,500 (????? to ?????)


    Ranking by Primary Position
    Pitchers
    Catchers
    First Basemen
    Second Basemen
    Third Basemen
    Shortstops
    Left Fielders
    Center Fielders
    Right Fielders


    Unranked Hall of Famers
    Tommy McCarthy
    Lloyd Waner
    Last edited by Chadwick; 05-20-2022, 04:03 PM.
    "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
    "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
    "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
    "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

  • #2
    Overall Ranking

    1 to 100 (Babe Ruth to Fergie Jenkins)
    101 to 200 (Carl Hubbell to Bret Saberhagen)
    201 to 300 (Minnie Minoso to Orel Hershiser)
    301 to 400 (George Gore to Bus Clarkson)
    401 to 500 (Charley Jones to Schoolboy Rowe)
    501 to 600 (Hanley Ramirez to Augie Galan)
    601 to 700 (Red Schoendienst to Kris Bryant)
    701 to 800 (Bill White to Jason Schmidt)
    801 to 900 (Bob Rush to Preacher Roe)
    901 to 1,000 (Ted Kluszewski to Doyle Alexander)
    1,001 to 1,100 (Adam Dunn to Johnny Allen)
    1,101 to 1,200 (Bump Hadley to Woody Williams)
    1,201 to 1,300 (Buck Freeman to ?????)
    1,301 to 1,400 (????? to ?????)
    1,401 to 1,500 (????? to ?????)
    Last edited by Chadwick; 05-20-2022, 03:24 PM.
    "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
    "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
    "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
    "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

    Comment


    • #3
      Pitchers

      1. (7) Walter Johnson, SP (1907-1927), Washington Senators
      2. (10) Roger Clemens, SP (1984-2007), Boston Red Sox
      3. (11) Cy Young, SP (1890-1911), Cleveland Spiders
      4. (17) Lefty Grove, SP (1925-1941), Philadelphia Athletics
      5. (18) Greg Maddux, SP (1986-2008), Atlanta Braves

      6. (26) Pete Alexander, SP (1911-1930), Philadelphia Phillies
      7. (30) Tom Seaver, SP (1967-1986), New York Mets
      8. (34) Randy Johnson, SP (1988-2009), Arizona Diamondbacks
      9. (36) Christy Mathewson, SP (1900-1916), New York Giants
      10. (37) Satchel Paige, SP (1927-1965), Pittsburgh Crawfords
      11. (41) Kid Nichols, SP (1890-1906), Boston Beaneaters
      12. (43) Warren Spahn, SP (1942-1965), Milwaukee Brewers
      13. (44) Pedro Martinez, SP (1992-2009), Boston Red Sox

      14. (52) Bob Gibson, SP (1959-1975), St. Louis Cardinals
      15. (60) Smoky Joe Williams, SP (1909-1932), New York Lincoln Giants
      16. (64) Steve Carlton, SP (1965-1988), Philadelphia Phillies
      17. (65) Bob Feller, SP (1936-1956), Cleveland Indians

      18. (67) Clayton Kershaw, SP (2008-Present), Los Angeles Dodgers
      19. (76) Gaylord Perry, SP (1962-1983), Cleveland Indians
      20. (77) Martin Dihigo, SP/SS/RF (1923-1945), Philadelphia Hilldale Giants
      21. (79) Phil Niekro, SP (1964-1987), Atlanta Braves
      22. (80) Eddie Plank, SP (1901-1917), Philadelphia Athletics

      23. (83) Bert Blyleven, SP (1970-1992), Minnesota Twins
      24. (85) Curt Schilling, SP (1988-2007), Philadelphia Phillies
      25. (90) Robin Roberts, SP (1948-1966), Philadelphia Phillies
      26. (92) Mike Mussina, SP (1991-2008), Baltimore Orioles
      27. (99) John Clarkson, SP (1882-1894), Boston Beaneaters
      28. (100) Fergie Jenkins, SP (1965-1983), Chicago Cubs

      29. (101) Carl Hubbell, SP (1928-1943), New York Giants
      30. (105) Bullet Rogan, SP/CF (1920-1938), Kansas City Monarchs
      31. (108) Mariano Rivera, RP (1995-2013), New York Yankees
      32. (110) Tom Glavine, SP (1987-2008), Atlanta Braves

      33. (114) Sandy Koufax, SP (1955-1966), Los Angeles Dodgers
      34. (117) Juan Marichal, SP (1960-1975), San Francisco Giants
      35. (118) Jim Palmer, SP (1965-1984), Baltimore Orioles

      36. (121) Justin Verlander, SP (2005-Present), Detroit Tigers
      37. (122) Tim Keefe, SP (1880-1893), New York Giants
      38. (124) Roy Halladay, SP (1998-2013), Toronto Blue Jays

      39. (126) Ed Walsh, SP (1904-1917), Chicago White Sox
      40. (127) Nolan Ryan, SP (1966-1993), California Angels

      41. (136) John Smoltz, SP (1988-2009), Atlanta Braves
      42. (143) Max Scherzer, SP (2008-Present), Washington Nationals
      43. (147) Zack Greinke, SP (2004-Present), Kansas City Royals
      44. (149) Whitey Ford, SP (1950-1967), New York Yankees
      45. (160) Kevin Brown, SP (1986-2005), Los Angeles Dodgers
      46. (162) Hal Newhouser, SP (1939-1955), Detroit Tigers
      47. (166) Mordecai Brown, SP (1903-1916), Chicago Cubs
      48. (167) Dazzy Vance, SP (1915-1935), Brooklyn Robins

      49. (179) Stan Coveleski, SP (1912-1928), Cleveland Indians
      50. (185) Dennis Eckersley, SP/RP (1975-1998), Boston Red Sox
      51. (186) David Cone, SP (1986-2003), New York Yankees
      52. (187) Jim Bunning, SP (1955-1971), Philadelphia Phillies
      53. (188) Dick Redding SP (1911-1936), Atlantic City Bacharach Giants
      54. (194) Wes Ferrell, SP (1927-1941), Cleveland Indians
      55. (198) Luis Tiant, SP (1964-1982), Boston Red Sox
      56. (200) Bret Saberhagen, SP (1984-2001), Kansas City Royals
      57. (206) Amos Rusie, SP (1889-1901), New York Giants
      58. (208) Ted Lyons, SP (1923-1946), Chicago White Sox
      59. (209) Rube Waddell, SP (1897-1910), Philadelphia Athletics

      60. (212) Joe McGinnity, SP (1899-1908), New York Giants
      61. (215) Johan Santana, SP (2000-2012), Minnesota Twins
      62. (220) Don Drysdale, SP (1956-1969), Los Angeles Dodgers
      63. (221) Urban Shocker, SP (1916-1928), St. Louis Browns
      64. (222) A.G. Spalding, SP (1870-1878), Boston Red Stockings
      65. (224) Old Hoss Radbourn, SP (1880-1891), Providence Grays
      66. (227) Hoyt Wilhelm, RP (1952-1972), Baltimore Orioles
      67. (228) Jose Mendez, SP (1908-1924), Almendares
      68. (229) Red Ruffing, SP (1924-1947), New York Yankees

      69. (234) Vic Willis, SP (1898-1910), Boston Beaneaters
      70. (238) CC Sabathia, SP (2001-2019), New York Yankees
      71. (239) Rick Reuschel, SP (1972-1991), Chicago Cubs
      72. (243) Dave Stieb, SP (1979-1998), Toronto Blue Jays
      73. (250) Goose Gossage, RP (1972-1994), New York Yankees
      74. (252) Don Sutton, SP (1966-1988), Los Angeles Dodgers
      75. (258) Ray Brown, SP (1931-1945), Homestead Grays
      76. (270) Early Wynn, SP (1939-1963), Cleveland Indians
      77. (274) Andy Pettitte, SP (1995-2013), New York Yankees
      78. (278) Tim Hudson, SP (1999-2015), Oakland Athletics
      79. (283) Dizzy Dean, SP (1930-1947), St. Louis Cardinals
      80. (284) Clark Griffith, SP (1891-1914), Chicago Colts

      81. (286) Eddie Cicotte, SP (1905-1920), Chicago White Sox
      82. (287) Cole Hamels, SP (2006-Present), Philadelphia Phillies
      83. (290) Billy Pierce, SP (1945-1964), Chicago White Sox
      84. (291) Red Faber, SP (1914-1933), Chicago White Sox
      85. (292) Bob Lemon, SP (1941-1958), Cleveland Indians

      86. (294) Bill Foster, SP (1923-1937), Chicago American Giants
      87. (300) Orel Hershiser, SP (1983-2000), Los Angeles Dodgers
      88/302 – Roy Oswalt
      89/304 – Kevin Appier
      90/307 – Jim McCormick
      91/309 – Tommy John
      92/313 – Babe Adams
      93/314 – Dolf Luque
      94/316 – Bob Caruthers
      95/321 – Chris Sale
      96/322 – Addie Joss
      97/328 – Hilton Smith

      98/332 – Don Newcombe
      99/334 – Pud Galvin
      100/340 – Dwight Gooden
      101/343 – Mark Buehrle
      102/346 – Billy Wagner
      103/352 – Tommy Bond
      104/355 – Tommy Bridges
      105/359 – Jack Quinn
      106/363 – Chuck Finley
      107/366 – Bucky Walters
      108/368 – Tony Mullane
      109/369 – Cliff Lee
      110/375 – Felix Hernandez
      111/376 – Eppa Rixey
      112/384 – Wilbur Cooper
      113/389 – Burleigh Grimes
      114/395 – Ron Guidry
      115/397 – Jimmy Key
      116/404 – Jerry Koosman
      117/405 – Noodles Hahn
      118/408 – Carl Mays
      119/410 – Charlie Buffinton
      120/412 – George Uhle
      121/422 – Jacob deGrom
      122/426 – Chief Bender
      123/427 – Wilbur Wood
      124/433 – Eddie Rommel
      125/435 – Hippo Vaughn
      126/436 – Waite Hoyt
      127/438 – Mickey Welch

      128/440 – Dutch Leonard
      129/444 – Nap Rucker
      130/446 – Frank Tanana
      131/447 – William Bell
      132/449 – David Wells
      133/453 – Jon Lester
      134/454 – Frank Viola
      135/456 – Mark Langston
      136/459 – Adam Wainwright
      137/461 – Jim Kaat
      138/463 – Trevor Hoffman
      139/464 – Larry Jackson
      140/468 – Dizzy Trout
      141/470 – Mickey Lolich
      142/471 – Harry Brecheen
      143/472 – Carlos Zambrano
      144/478 – Lon Warneke
      145/482 – Steve Rogers
      146/487 – Dennis Martinez
      147/489 – Sam McDowell
      148/492 – Vida Blue
      149/495 – Mel Harder
      150/496 – Webster McDonald
      151/500 – Schoolboy Rowe
      152/508 – Jesse Tannehill
      153/511 – Lefty Gomez
      154/513 – Stephen Strasburg
      155/515 – Jack Morris
      156/519 – Yu Darvish
      157/520 – Rube Foster
      158/524 – Brandon Webb
      159/526 – Connie Marrero
      160/529 – Leon Day
      161/531 – Claude Passeau
      162/535 – Javier Vazquez
      163/537 – Sam Leever
      164/538 – Brad Radke
      165/541 – Herb Pennock
      166/542 – David Price
      167/543 – Lee Smith
      168/546 – Bill Byrd
      169/556 – Andy Messersmith
      170/558 – Ted Breitenstein
      171/563 – Jose Rijo
      172/567 – Bobo Newsom
      173/569 – Bartolo Colon
      174/571 – Virgil Trucks
      175/572 – Camilo Pascual
      176/573 – Smoky Joe Wood
      177/576 – Corey Kluber
      178/578 – Bob Friend
      179/580 – Bobby Mathews
      180/583 – Madison Bumgarner
      181/588 – Mel Stottlemyre
      182/589 – Jake Peavy
      183/592 – Kenny Rogers
      184/593 – Bill Holland
      185/594 – Joe Nathan
      186/597 – Fernando Valenzuela
      187/602 – John Candelaria
      188/603 – Jamie Moyer
      189/606 – Curt Simmons
      190/607 – Dan Quisenberry
      191/609 – Silver King
      192/611 – Larry French
      193/612 – Bob Shawkey
      194/617 – Catfish Hunter
      195/618 – Jon Matlack
      196/621 – Al Leiter
      197/623 – Deacon Phillippe
      198/624 – Milt Pappas
      199/626 – Ned Garver
      200/628 – Doc White
      201/631 – Jim Whitney
      202/634 – Jack Chesbro
      203/639 – Jim Maloney
      204/640 – Red Lucas
      205/641 – Jack Powell
      206/642 – Sal Maglie
      207/645 – Tom Henke
      208/649 – John Hiller
      209/656 – Rollie Fingers
      210/658 – Bruce Sutter

      211/660 – Josh Beckett
      212/662 – Craig Kimbrel
      213/663 – John Tudor
      214/666 – Bob Welch
      215/667 – Al Orth
      216/669 – Juan Padron
      217/675 – Tom Candiotti
      218/682 – Gerrit Cole
      219/687 – Jonathan Papelbon
      220/689 – Bobby Shantz
      221/690 – Chris Carpenter
      222/692 – Murry Dickson
      223/693 – Paul Derringer
      224/694 – Dave Barnhill
      225/697 – Johnny Cueto
      226/698 – Jered Weaver
      227/699 – Teddy Higuera
      228/706 – Francisco Rodriguez
      229/716 – Ed Reulbach
      230/720 – Stu Miller
      231/721 – George Stovey
      232/726 – Jack Stivetts
      233/728 – Johnny Sain
      234/729 – Mel Parnell
      235/730 – Howie Pollet
      236/731 – Ellis Kinder
      237/733 – Charlie Root
      238/738 – Dan Haren
      239/741 – Jim Perry
      240/742 – Johnny Antonelli
      241/745 – Mark Gubicza
      242/754 – John Lackey
      243/755 – Ewell Blackwell
      244/761 – Sid Fernandez
      245/762 – Mike Garcia
      246/766 – Dean Chance
      247/767 – Tom Gordon
      248/772 – Firpo Marberry
      249/773 – Curt Davis
      250/777 – Max Lanier
      251/778 – Burt Hooton
      252/780 – Derek Lowe
      253/782 – Kent Tekulve
      254/786 – John Franco
      255/787 – Jeff Pfeffer
      256/798 – Harvey Haddix
      257/800 – Jason Schmidt
      258/801 – Bob Rush
      259/802 – George Mullin
      260/803 – Mort Cooper
      261/804 – Dave Foutz
      262/810 – Lance Lynn
      263/829 – Claude Osteen
      264/830 – Aroldis Chapman
      265/834 – Matt Cain
      266/835 – Bill Donovan
      267/836 – Sadie McMahon
      268/840 – Candy Cummings
      269/845 – Pat Hentgen
      270/846 – Freddy Garcia
      271/847 – Van Mungo
      272/849 – Kenley Jansen
      273/851 – Nig Cuppy
      274/852 – Frank Dwyer
      275/856 – Dutch Leonard
      276/860 – Jerry Reuss
      277/861 – Sad Sam Jones
      278/862 – Keith Foulke
      279/871 – Hooks Dauss
      280/875 – Frank Lary
      281/880 – Ramon Bragana
      282/882 – Andy Benes
      283/884 – Rube Marquard
      284/885 – Howard Ehmke
      285/889 – Rick Sutcliffe
      286/890 – Russ Ford
      287/891 – Kerry Wood
      288/892 – Tex Hughson
      289/894 – Fred Hutchison
      290/897 – Sparky Lyle
      291/900 – Preacher Roe
      292/902 – Tug McGraw
      293/908 – Danny Darwin
      294/910 – Charlie Ferguson
      295/912 – Bruce Hurst
      296/913 – Pink Hawley
      297/916 – Josh Johnson
      298/917 – Ed Lopat
      299/919 – Charlie Liebrandt
      300/920 – Bill Dinneen
      301/922 – Freddie Fitzsimmons

      302/927 – J.R. Richard
      303/936 – Thornton Lee
      304/944 – Barry Zito
      305/947 – Sonny Siebert
      306/948 – Kid Gleason
      307/950 – Ray Caldwell

      308/951 – Slim Sallee
      309/952 – Rube Walberg
      310/955 – Rick Rhoden
      311/956 – Greg Swindell
      312/965 – Rick Wise
      313/966 – Andy Cooper
      314/967 – John Wetteland
      315/970 – Charlie Hough
      316/972 – Doug Jones
      317/974 – Orlando Hernandez
      318/978 – Jose Munoz
      319/979 – Alex Fernandez
      320/981 – Tom Zachary
      321/984 – Aaron Nola
      Last edited by Chadwick; 03-04-2022, 12:41 PM.
      "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
      "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
      "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
      "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

      Comment


      • #4
        Catchers

        1/33 – Josh Gibson

        2/38 – Johnny Bench
        3/59 – Yogi Berra
        4/63 – Mike Piazza
        5/69 – Gary Carter
        6/89 – Carlton Fisk
        7/96 – Bill Dickey
        8/103 – Roy Campanella
        9/112 – Mickey Cochrane
        10/119 – Gabby Hartnett
        11/128 – Louis Santop
        12/137 – Ivan Rodriguez
        13/163 – Buck Ewing
        14/170 – Biz Mackey
        15/181 – Deacon White
        16/184 – Joe Mauer
        17/196 – Ted Simmons
        18/217 – Buster Posey
        19/219 – Thurman Munson
        20/230 – Joe Torre
        21/251 – Yadier Molina
        22/253 – Charlie Bennett
        23/254 – Quincy Trouppe
        24/263 – Wally Schang
        25/275 – Roger Bresnahan
        26/282 – Bill Freehan
        27/297 – Cal McVey
        28/315 – Russell Martin
        29/354 – Gene Tenace
        30/390 – Ernie Lombardi
        31/403 – Brian McCann
        32/407 – Elston Howard
        33/415 – Jorge Posada
        34/425 – Jim Sundberg
        35/441 – Darrell Porter
        36/458 – Jason Kendall
        37/483 – Lance Parrish
        38/502 – Regino Garcia
        39/553 – Ray Schalk
        40/575 – Johnny Kling
        41/577 – Javy Lopez
        42/590 – Smoky Burgess
        43/604 – Chief Meyers
        44/615 – Jack Clements
        45/633 – Sherm Lollar
        46/647 – Duke Farrell
        47/650 – Rick Ferrell
        48/665 – Tom Haller
        49/707 – Tony Pena
        50/719 – Chief Zimmer
        51/736 – Walker Cooper
        52/764 – Mike Scioscia
        53/765 – Johnny Bassler
        54/768 – Salvador Perez
        55/783 – Mickey Tettleton
        56/785 – Del Crandall
        57/796 – J.T. Realmuto
        58/813 – Yasmani Grandal

        59/815 – Manny Sanguillen
        60/865 – Darren Daulton
        61/877 – Chris Hoiles
        62/893 – Hank Gowdy
        63/899 – Tim McCarver
        64/928 – Bob Boone
        65/929 – Victor Martinez

        66/941 – Ed Bailey
        67/945 – Terry Steinbach
        68/949 – Butch Wynegar

        69/983 – Fred Carroll
        Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:31 AM.
        "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
        "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
        "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
        "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

        Comment


        • #5
          First Basemen

          1/12 – Lou Gehrig
          2/21 – Albert Pujols
          3/31 – Jimmie Foxx
          4/35 – Cap Anson
          5/46 – Dan Brouthers
          6/49 – Johnny Mize
          7/54 – Roger Connor
          8/56 – Jeff Bagwell
          9/68 – Miguel Cabrera
          10/72 – Hank Greenberg
          11/73 – Frank Thomas
          12/84 – Jim Thome
          13/97 – Willie McCovey
          14/113 – Mark McGwire
          15/131 – Eddie Murray
          16/132 – Harmon Killebrew
          17/150 – Rafael Palmeiro
          18/155 – Dick Allen
          19/176 – Joey Votto
          20/189 – Buck Leonard
          21/197 – George Sisler
          22/203 – Mule Suttles
          23/211 – Bill Terry
          24/214 – Keith Hernandez
          25/216 – Joe Start
          26/231 – Todd Helton
          27/256 – Will Clark
          28/260 – David Ortiz
          29/277 – Jake Beckley
          30/280 – John Olerud
          31/285 – Fred McGriff
          32/310 – Jason Giambi
          33/325 – Orlando Cepeda
          34/339 – Paul Goldschmidt
          35/351 – Ben Taylor
          36/353 – Tony Perez
          37/365 – Carlos Delgado
          38/373 – Mark Teixeira
          39/378 – Frank Chance
          40/383 – Norm Cash
          41/387 – Gil Hodges
          42/394 – Dolph Camilli
          43/398 – Don Mattingly
          44/450 – Jack Fournier
          45/455 – Freddie Freeman
          46/457 – Adrian Gonzalez
          47/491 – Luke Easter
          48/552 – Anthony Rizzo
          49/559 – Ed Konetchy
          50/566 – Steve Garvey
          51/568 – Mark Grace
          52/587 – Boog Powell
          53/608 – Jim Bottomley
          54/614 – Fred Tenney
          55/625 – Julian Castillo
          56/657 – Dave Orr
          57/659 – Bill Pettus
          58/673 – Cecil Cooper
          59/676 – Kent Hrbek
          60/701 – Bill White
          61/713 – Jose Abreu
          62/727 – Joe Judge
          63/749 – Kevin Youkilis
          64/750 – Elbie Fletcher
          65/759 – Jake Daubert
          66/784 – Mickey Vernon
          67/816 – Bill Pierce
          68/822 – Rudy York
          69/825 – Derrek Lee
          70/826 – Frank McCormick
          71/855 – Hal Trosky
          72/859 – Andres Galarraga
          73/863 – Dan McGann
          74/867 – Harry Davis
          75/878 – Prince Fielder
          76/887 – George Scott
          77/898 – Lu Blue
          78/901 – Ted Kluszewski
          79/932 – Paul Konerko
          80/935 – Phil Cavarretta

          81/957 – Ron Fairly
          82/971 – Wally Joyner
          83/980 – Earl Torgeson
          84/982 – Brandon Belt
          Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:32 AM.
          "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
          "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
          "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
          "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

          Comment


          • #6
            Second Basemen

            1/13 – Rogers Hornsby
            2/22 – Eddie Collins
            3/28 – Joe Morgan
            4/29 – Nap Lajoie
            5/45 – Jackie Robinson
            6/55 – Charlie Gehringer
            7/78 – Rod Carew
            8/109 – Frankie Frisch
            9/123 – Joe Gordon
            10/140 – Robinson Cano
            11/142 – Ross Barnes
            12/145 – Lou Whitaker
            13/146 – Bobby Grich
            14/148 – Craig Biggio
            15/151 – Roberto Alomar
            16/159 – Ryne Sandberg
            17/164 – Chase Utley
            18/233 – Willie Randolph
            19/240 – Billy Herman
            20/241 – Jeff Kent
            21/259 – Bobby Doerr
            22/288 – Bid McPhee
            23/318 – Frank Grant
            24/341 – Dustin Pedroia
            25/344 – Nellie Fox
            26/345 – Cupid Childs
            27/358 – Hardy Richardson
            28/370 – Johnny Evers
            29/372 – Ian Kinsler
            30/380 – Newt Allen
            31/402 – Tony Lazzeri
            32/416 – Marvin Williams
            33/429 – Tubby Scales
            34/442 – Lonny Frey
            35/451 – Ben Zobrist
            36/460 – Chuck Knoblauch
            37/467 – Larry Doyle
            38/469 – Gil McDougald
            39/474 – Fred Dunlap
            40/476 – Buddy Myer
            41/480 – Jose Altuve
            42/494 – Jim Gilliam
            43/498 – Eddie Stanky
            44/521 – Del Pratt
            45/548 – Davey Lopes
            46/551 – Bobby Avila
            47/601 – Red Schoendienst
            48/636 – Rev Cannady
            49/643 – Dick McAuliffe
            50/661 – Julio Franco
            51/702 – Max Bishop
            52/718 – Bill Mazeroski
            53/725 – Placido Polanco
            54/734 – Robby Thompson
            55/753 – Jimmy Williams
            56/771 – Danny Murphy
            57/818 – Alfonso Soriano
            58/832 – Howie Kendrick
            59/838 – Bill Doran
            60/839 – George Grantham
            61/848 – Ray Durham
            62/850 – Bonnie Serrell
            63/872 – Claude Ritchey
            64/883 – Miller Huggins
            64/895 – DJ LeMahieu
            65/907 – Ron Hunt
            66/914 – Orlando Hudson
            67/915 – Mark Ellis
            68/918 – Frank White
            69/946 – Phil Garner

            70/954 – Tony Cuccinello
            71/962 – Brandon Phillips
            72/964 – Davey Johnson
            73/976 – Brian Roberts
            Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:33 AM.
            "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
            "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
            "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
            "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

            Comment


            • #7
              Third Basemen

              1/20 – Mike Schmidt
              2/32 – Eddie Mathews
              3/40 – George Brett
              4/58 – Wade Boggs
              5/62 – Chipper Jones
              6/87 – Adrian Beltre
              7/129 – Paul Molitor
              8/138 – Home Run Baker
              9/139 – Brooks Robinson
              10/144 – Ron Santo
              11/152 – Edgar Martinez
              12/153 – Jud Wilson
              13/156 – Scott Rolen
              14/213 – Ken Boyer
              15/225 – Graig Nettles
              16/246 – Jimmy Collins
              17/248 – Sal Bando
              18/255 – Buddy Bell
              19/267 – John McGraw
              20/269 – Darrell Evans
              21/279 – Stan Hack
              22/306 – Evan Longoria
              23/308 – Ron Cey
              24/317 – David Wright
              25/335 – Robin Ventura
              26/342 – Josh Donaldson
              27/356 – Bob Elliott
              28/362 – Heinie Groh
              29/367 – Carlos Moran
              30/414 – Nolan Arenado
              31/420 – Al Rosen
              32/423 – Matt Williams
              33/437 – Manny Machado
              34/439 – Pie Traynor
              35/448 – Toby Harrah
              36/473 – Ezra Sutton
              37/497 – Ned Williamson
              38/505 – Ray Dandridge
              39/514 – Anthony Rendon
              40/517 – Larry Gardner
              41/540 – Lave Cross
              42/562 – Doug DeCinces
              43/570 – Harlond Clift
              44/591 – Denny Lyons
              45/613 – Troy Glaus
              46/627 – Ryan Zimmerman
              47/629 – Eric Chavez
              48/652 – Bill Madlock
              49/670 – Bill Bradley
              50/671 – Art Devlin
              51/677 – George Kell
              52/678 – Justin Turner
              53/685 – Hank Thompson
              54/686 – Jose Ramirez
              55/700 – Kris Bryant
              56/709 – Aramis Ramirez
              57/710 – Ken Caminiti
              58/722 – Carney Lansford
              59/743 – Tim Wallach
              60/748 – Kyle Seager
              61/757 – Bill Joyce
              62/760 – Edwin Encarnacion
              63/769 – Eddie Yost
              64/788 – Heinie Zimmerman
              65/793 – Gary Gaetti
              66/794 – Buddy Lewis
              67/795 – Edgardo Alfonzo
              68/823 – Ken Keltner
              69/833 – Bobby Bonilla
              70/842 – Billy Nash
              71/844 – Alex Bregman
              72/854 – Jeff Cirillo
              73/866 – Levi Meyerle
              74/873 – Matt Carpenter
              75/874 – Richie Hebner
              76/903 – Matt Chapman
              77/909 – Don Money
              78/921 – Ken McMullen
              79/925 – Arlie Latham
              80/938 – Travis Fryman

              81/940 – Jim Ray Hart
              82/961 – Judy Johnson
              83/977 – Bob Horner
              Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:34 AM.
              "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
              "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
              "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
              "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

              Comment


              • #8
                Shortstops

                1/8 – Honus Wagner
                2/14 – Alex Rodriguez
                3/39 – Cal Ripken
                4/53 – Pop Lloyd
                5/71 – Arky Vaughan
                6/82 – Willie Wells
                7/91 – George Davis
                8/93 – Luke Appling
                9/98 – Robin Yount
                10/102 – Barry Larkin
                11/104 – Ernie Banks
                12/111 – Derek Jeter
                13/116 – Pee Wee Reese
                14/125 – Bill Dahlen
                15/130 – Ozzie Smith
                16/133 – Alan Trammell
                17/171 – Jack Glasscock
                18/174 – Lou Boudreau
                19/175 – Joe Cronin
                20/178 – Bobby Wallace
                21/182 – Dobie Moore
                22/195 – George Wright
                23/226 – John Montgomery Ward
                24/235 – Home Run Johnson
                25/261 – Hughie Jennings
                26/272 – Dick Lundy
                27/289 – Joe Tinker
                28/305 – Phil Rizzuto
                29/319 – Nomar Garciaparra
                30/323 – Dave Bancroft
                31/326 – Joe Sewell
                32/333 – Bert Campaneris
                33/347 – Art Fletcher
                34/349 – John Beckwith
                35/357 – Vern Stephens
                36/360 – Perucho Cepeda
                37/385 – Luis Aparicio
                38/396 – Jim Fregosi
                39/399 – Johnny Pesky
                40/400 – Bus Clarkson
                41/411 – Miguel Tejada
                42/413 – Troy Tulowitzki
                43/443 – Sam Bankhead
                44/481 – Tony Fernandez
                45/485 – Travis Jackson
                46/488 – Jimmy Rollins
                47/501 – Hanley Ramirez
                48/527 – Silvio Garcia
                49/536 – Cecil Travis
                50/547 – Dave Concepcion
                51/549 – Maury Wills
                52/550 – Dickey Pearce
                53/620 – Andrelton Simmons
                54/637 – Al Dark
                55/644 – Jose Reyes
                56/646 – Rico Petrocelli
                57/651 – Ed McKean
                58/653 – Roger Peckinpaugh
                59/654 – Rabbit Maranville
                60/672 – Francisco Lindor
                61/688 – Carlos Correa
                62/696 – Rafael Furcal
                63/704 – Mark Belanger
                64/708 – Herman Long
                65/711 – Dick Bartell
                66/724 – Jack Rowe
                67/732 – Jay Bell
                68/739 – Donie Bush
                69/740 – Omar Vizquel
                70/747 – Dick Groat
                71/752 – Xander Bogaert
                72/763 – Freddy Parent
                73/775 – John Valentin
                74/790 – Trevor Story
                75/809 – Eddie Joost
                76/811 – Kid Elberfeld
                77/843 – Trea Turner
                78/876 – Corey Seager
                79/896 – Marcus Semien
                80/926 – Terry Turner
                81/930 – Jose Valentin
                82/931 – Edgar Renteria
                83/933 – Javier Baez
                84/942 – Ray Chapman

                85/975 – Marty Marion
                Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:34 AM.
                "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                Comment


                • #9
                  Left Fielders

                  1/3 – Barry Bonds
                  2/5 – Ted Williams
                  3/9 – Stan Musial
                  4/24 – Rickey Henderson
                  5/42 – Carl Yastrzemski
                  6/61 – Ed Delahanty
                  7/70 – Pete Rose
                  8/81 – Manny Ramirez
                  9/106 – Al Simmons
                  10/141 – Tim Raines
                  11/154 – Fred Clarke
                  12/161 – Jesse Burkett
                  13/165 – Billy Williams
                  14/168 – Goose Goslin
                  15/172 – Willie Stargell
                  16/199 – Charlie Keller
                  17/201 – Minnie Minoso
                  18/205 – Jim O’Rourke
                  19/218 – Ralph Kiner
                  20/232 – Zack Wheat
                  21/237 – Sherry Magee
                  22/242 – Lance Berkman
                  23/245 – Joe Medwick
                  24/264 – Albert Belle
                  25/268 – Bob Johnson
                  26/273 – Harry Stovey
                  27/296 – Bobby Veach
                  28/303 – Jose Cruz
                  29/327 – Joe Kelley
                  30/329 – Jimmy Sheckard
                  31/336 – Jim Rice
                  32/391 – Lou Brock
                  33/392 – Tony Phillips
                  34/401 – Charley Jones
                  35/406 – Roy White
                  36/418 – Ryan Braun
                  37/434 – George Foster
                  38/452 – Luis Gonzalez
                  39/462 – Heinie Manush
                  40/466 – Matt Holliday
                  41/486 – Brian Downing
                  42/493 – Ken Williams
                  43/507 – Frank Howard
                  44/516 – Hideki Matsui
                  45/523 – George Burns
                  46/525 – Pedro Guerrero
                  47/565 – Christian Yelich
                  48/595 – Pancho Coimbre
                  49/596 – Mike Smith
                  50/600 – Augie Galan
                  51/605 – Kirk Gibson
                  52/619 – Tip O’Neill
                  53/630 – Moises Alou
                  54/632 – Sid Gordon
                  55/635 – Brett Gardner
                  56/681 – Don Buford
                  57/691 – Carl Crawford
                  58/705 – Lonnie Smith
                  59/712 – Jeff Heath
                  60/737 – Starling Marte
                  61/758 – Dusty Baker
                  62/770 – Kip Selbach
                  63/779 – Kevin Mitchell
                  64/791 – Chick Hafey
                  65/799 – Alex Gordon
                  66/806 – George Stone
                  67/807 – Riggs Stephenson
                  68/808 – Rico Carty
                  69/812 – Fats Jenkins
                  70/814 – Gene Woodling
                  71/817 – Michael Brantley
                  72/819 – Lefty O'Doul
                  73/828 – Yoenis Cespedes
                  74/841 – Ron Gant
                  75/870 – Justin Upton
                  76/879 – Del Ennis
                  77/888 – Kevin McReynolds
                  78/906 – Topsy Hartsel
                  79/924 – Greg Luzinski
                  80/939 – Greg Vaughn

                  Last edited by Chadwick; 01-09-2022, 05:06 AM.
                  "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                  "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                  "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                  "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Center Fielders

                    1/22 – Willie Mays
                    2/4 – Ty Cobb
                    3/15 – Mickey Mantle
                    4/16 – Tris Speaker
                    5/19 – Joe DiMaggio
                    6/23 – Oscar Charleston
                    7/47 – Ken Griffey Jr.
                    8/51 – Mike Trout
                    9/88 – Duke Snider
                    10/95 – Turkey Stearnes
                    11/115 – Cristobal Torriente
                    12/134 – Carlos Beltran
                    13/135 – Billy Hamilton
                    14/157 – Jim Edmonds
                    15/177 – Andruw Jones
                    16/180 – Monte Irvin
                    17/191 – Andre Dawson
                    18/192 – Larry Doby
                    19/193 – Pete Hill
                    20/204 – Paul Hines
                    21/210 – Kenny Lofton
                    22/223 – Richie Ashburn
                    23/247 – Earl Averill
                    24/249 – Max Carey
                    25/257 – Jimmy Wynn
                    26/265 – Kirby Puckett
                    27/281 – Willard Brown
                    28/293 – Dale Murphy
                    29/295 – Cesar Cedeno
                    30/301 – George Gore
                    31/311 – Willie Davis
                    32/312 – Cool Papa Bell
                    33/324 – Tommy Leach
                    34/331 – Lazaro Salazar
                    35/337 – Edd Roush
                    36/338 – Bernie Williams
                    37/350 – Pete Browning
                    38/379 – Vada Pinson
                    39/386 – Fred Lynn
                    40/388 – Chet Lemon
                    41/409 – Wally Berger
                    42/417 – Alejandro Oms
                    43/424 – Lip Pike
                    44/430 – Andrew McCutchen
                    45/431 – Hugh Duffy
                    46/432 – Hack Wilson
                    47/445 – Johnny Damon
                    48/465 – Brett Butler
                    49/475 – Willie Wilson
                    50/477 – Ellis Burks
                    51/484 – Amos Otis
                    52/499 – Jimmy Ryan
                    53/503 – Earle Combs
                    54/506 – Curtis Granderson
                    55/509 – Mike Cameron
                    56/518 – Eric Davis
                    57/528 – Lenny Dykstra
                    58/534 – George Van Haltren
                    59/539 – Al Oliver
                    60/544 – Dom DiMaggio
                    61/554 – Andy Van Slyke
                    62/557 – Torii Hunter
                    63/560 – Mike Griffin
                    64/561 – Curt Flood
                    65/564 – Devon White
                    66/574 – Cy Seymour
                    67/582 – Sam Jethroe
                    68/584 – Roy Thomas
                    69/610 – Steve Finley
                    70/616 – Fielder Jones
                    71/668 – Ray Lankford
                    72/674 – Bobby Murcer
                    73/679 – Lorenzo Cain
                    74/683 – Pete Reiser
                    75/715 – Cy Williams
                    76/717 – Paul Blair
                    77/735 – Ben Chapman
                    78/751 – Dwayne Murphy
                    79/792 – Josh Hamilton
                    80/797 – Benny Kauff
                    81/805 – Clyde Milan
                    82/821 – Spotswood Poles
                    83/824 – Garry Maddox
                    84/827 – Shane Victorino
                    85/831 – Chili Davis
                    86/853 – Andy Pafko
                    87/864 – Grady Sizemore
                    88/868 – Mickey Rivers
                    89/869 – Chick Stahl
                    90/881 – Jacoby Ellsbury
                    91/904 – Rick Monday
                    92/905 – Bill Lange
                    93/911 – Kevin Kiermaier
                    94/934 – Ginger Beaumont
                    95/953 – Hunter Pence
                    96/963 – Lance Johnson
                    97/968 – Bobby Thomson
                    98/969 – Willie McGee
                    99/973 – Brady Anderson
                    Last edited by Chadwick; 01-28-2022, 04:33 AM.
                    "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                    "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                    "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                    "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Right Fielders

                      1/1 – Babe Ruth
                      2/6 – Hank Aaron
                      3/25 – Frank Robinson
                      4/27 – Mel Ott
                      5/48 – Roberto Clemente
                      6/50 – Al Kaline
                      7/57 – Reggie Jackson
                      8/66 – Shoeless Joe Jackson
                      9/74 – Paul Waner
                      10/75 – Sam Crawford
                      11/86 – Ichiro Suzuki
                      12/94 – Harry Heilmann
                      13/ 107 – Tony Gwynn
                      14/120 – Larry Walker
                      15/158 – Gary Sheffield
                      16/169 – Vladimir Guerrero
                      17/173 – Dave Winfield
                      18/183 – Reggie Smith
                      19/190 – Enos Slaughter
                      20/202 – King Kelly
                      21/207 – Dwight Evans
                      22/236 – Sammy Sosa
                      23/244 – Elmer Flick
                      24/262 – Bobby Abreu
                      25/266 – Bobby Bonds
                      26/271 – Willie Keeler
                      27/276 – Mookie Betts
                      28/298 – Hurley McNair
                      29/299 – Sam Thompson
                      30/320 – Brian Giles
                      31/330 – Sam Rice
                      32/348 – Harry Hooper
                      33/361 – Kiki Cuyler
                      34/364 – Chuck Klein
                      35/371 – Tony Oliva
                      36/374 – Dave Parker
                      37/377 – Chino Smith
                      38/381 – Jack Clark
                      39/382 – Heavy Johnson
                      40/393 – Rocky Colavito
                      41/419 – Darryl Strawberry
                      42/421 – Tommy Henrich
                      43/428 – Gavvy Cravath
                      44/479 – Mike Tiernan
                      45/490 – Giancarlo Stanton
                      46/504 – Wild Bill Wright
                      47/510 – Jesse Barfield
                      48/512 – Rusty Staub
                      49/522 – Ken Singleton
                      50/530 – Bryce Harper
                      51/532 – Roger Maris
                      52/533 – Bill Nicholson
                      53/545 – J.D. Drew
                      54/555 – Jose Canseco
                      55/579 – Jose Bautista
                      56/581 – David Justice
                      57/585 – Nelson Cruz
                      58/586 – Babe Herman
                      59/598 – Tim Salmon
                      60/599 – Dixie Walker
                      61/622 – Paul O’Neill
                      62/638 – Juan Gonzalez
                      63/648 – Mike Donlin
                      64/655 – Buzz Arlett
                      65/664 – Felipe Alou
                      66/680 – Harold Baines
                      67/684 – Bob Allison
                      68/695 – Jason Heyward
                      69/703 – Reggie Sander
                      70/714 – Johnny Callison
                      71/723 – George Springer
                      72/744 – Magglio Ordonez
                      73/746 – Carl Furillo
                      74/756 – Ross Youngs
                      75/774 – Roy Cullenbine
                      76/776 – Rap Dixon
                      77/781 – Shin-Soo Choo
                      78/789 – Tommy Holmes
                      79/820 – Aaron Judge
                      80/837 –Shawn Green
                      81/857 – Ken Griffey
                      82/858 – Brian Jordan
                      83/886 – Raul Mondesi
                      84/923 – J.D. Martinez
                      85/937 – John Titus

                      86/943 – Jayson Werth
                      87/958 – Ted Strong
                      88/959 – Hank Sauer
                      89/960 – Von Hayes
                      Last edited by Chadwick; 01-22-2022, 06:45 PM.
                      "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                      "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                      "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                      "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Updated through election #87
                        "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                        "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                        "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                        "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Yessir! It is!
                          "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                          "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                          "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                          "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Updated thru election #88
                            "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                            "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                            "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                            "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Updated through election #90
                              "It is a simple matter to erect a Hall of Fame, but difficult to select the tenants." -- Ken Smith
                              "I am led to suspect that some of the electorate is very dumb." -- Henry P. Edwards
                              "You have a Hall of Fame to put people in, not keep people out." -- Brian Kenny
                              "There's no such thing as a perfect ballot." -- Jay Jaffe

                              Comment

                              Ad Widget

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X