Best season of the following

[Blackout]

taking a break from the position polls. I'll finish up that later though.


Carlos Pena 2007: .282/.411/.627 46 HR 121 RBI 99 runs 172 OPS+


Ty Cobb 1908: .324/.367/.475 36 doubles, 20 triples, 108 RBI, 39 SB 169 OPS+


Sam Crawford 1911: .378/.438/.526 36 doubles 14 triples 115 RBI 163 OPS+


Michael Young 2005: .331/.385/.513 40 doubles 114 runs 131 OPS+


Roger Maris 1960: .283/.371/.581 39 HR 112 RBI 161 OPS+ MVP


Tony Lazzeri 1929: .354/.429/.561 37 doubles 18 HR 106 RBI 160 OPS+


Ichiro Suzuki 2001: .350/.381/.456 242 hits 56 SB's 126 OPS+ MVP



Which of these season's was the best ladies and gentlemen?

[Murderers Row]

I'm going with Marris because of his 5.2 batting wins. But it is real close. Cobb, Crawford, Pena all had 5.1

[Blackout]

so you don't care that Michael Young had to play SS? just being devil's advocate.

[soberdennis]

Looking at the overall numbers Pena had the best year of those listed. But they obviously were not the best years for some of those players.

[Murderers Row]

so you don't care that Michael Young had to play SS? just being devil's advocate.

I thought we were just talking offensively... Even if we take PADJ into account, that's still not enough.

[Blackout]

what about Lazzeri