Greatest Player by Birthyear

[RuthMayBond]

I'd say Lasting Milledge so far is the best player born in 1985,

Asdrubal Cabrera, Saltalamacchia, Delmon Young, Chamberlain, Litsch, Fabio Castro still have a shot

<Felix Hernandez being the best player born in 1986,>

Billy Butler has a shot

<and Justin Upton the best player born in 1987.>

It ain't like he's had a lot of competition

http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/ML_1987_birth.shtml

[ElHalo]

I'd say Lasting Milledge so far is the best player born in 1985.

Does Joba Chamberlain get a vote?

[Ubiquitous]

He will when he pitches more then 24 innings.

[jjpm74]

Here we have the oldest documented baseball player in the National Association's 1st season born in 1831 making his debut at 40 years old:

http://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/Nate_Berkenstock

[ElHalo]

He will when he pitches more then 24 innings.

I'd take those 24 innings over the 109 games from Milledge.