Announcement

**Nerdlinger** · 02-18-2010, 06:26 PM

1901 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #1
Tuesday, July 9, 1901
NL Manager: Ned Hanlon, Brooklyn
AL Manager: Charlie Comiskey, Chicago

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1901 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Christy Mathewson, New York
C: Heinie Peitz, Cincinnati
1B: Ed Delahanty, Philadelphia
2B: Tom Daly, Brooklyn
3B: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis
OF: Jesse Burkett, St. Louis
OF: Sam Crawford, Cincinnati
OF: Elmer Flick, Philadelphia

NL Reserve Players

P: Jack Chesbro, Pittsburgh
P: Bill Donovan, Brooklyn
P: Noodles Hahn, Cincinnati
P: Al Orth, Philadelphia
P: Deacon Phillippe, Pittsburgh
P: Vic Willis, Boston
C: Deacon McGuire, Brooklyn
1B: Jake Beckley, Cincinnati
3B: Tommy Leach, Pittsburgh
SS: George Davis, New York
OF: Ginger Beaumont, Pittsburgh
OF: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh
OF: Topsy Hartsel, Chicago
OF: Emmet Heidrick, St. Louis
OF: Jimmy Sheckard, Brooklyn
OF: Roy Thomas, Philadelphia

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1901 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Cy Young, Boston
C: Boileryard Clarke, Washington
1B: Buck Freeman, Boston
2B: Nap Lajoie, Philadelphia
3B: Jimmy Collins, Boston
SS: Kid Elberfeld, Detroit
OF: Socks Seybold, Philadelphia
OF: Dummy Hoy, Chicago
OF: Mike Donlin, Baltimore

AL Reserve Players

P: Jimmy (not "Nixey") Callahan, Chicago
P: Clark Griffith, Chicago
P: Joe McGinnity, Baltimore
P: Roscoe Miller, Detroit
P: Earl Moore, Cleveland
P: Eddie Plank, Philadelphia
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Boston
C: Bob Wood, Cleveland
1B: John Anderson, Milwaukee
2B: Jimmy Williams, Baltimore
3B: Lave Cross, Philadelphia
3B: John McGraw, Baltimore
SS: Bill Keister, Baltimore
SS: Freddy Parent, Boston
OF: Fielder Jones, Chicago
OF: Chick Stahl, Boston

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

**Nerdlinger** · 02-18-2010, 06:28 PM

1901 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A grand total of 6 ballots were submitted.

Eighteen players were unanimously elected: in the NL (9), Jesse Burkett, Sam Crawford, Tom Daly, Ed Delahanty, Elmer Flick, Christy Mathewson, Deacon Phillippe, Bobby Wallace, and Honus Wagner; and in the AL (9), Jimmy Collins, Buck Freeman, Clark Griffith, Dummy Hoy, Nap Lajoie, Roscoe Miller, Socks Seybold, Jimmy Williams, and Cy Young. Of those players, four were unanimously elected as starters: Tom Daly (NL-2B), Buck Freeman (AL-1B), Nap Lajoie (AL-2B), and Cy Young (AL-P).

All teams in both leagues are represented by at least one player on the final rosters. The NL is stacked with outfielders, with six reserve outfielders compared to the AL's two. Mike Donlin and Fielder Jones tied for the third starting outfielder position on the AL team, with both players receiving 5 total votes, of which 3 were starter votes. Donlin was given the starting spot over Jones because Donlin received his final starter vote earlier in the election than Jones.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1901 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Christy Mathewson**  New York       9   6   3   3
Noodles Hahn*        Cincinnati     6   4   2   2
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     6   6   0   6
Vic Willis*          Boston         5   4   1   3
Jack Chesbro*        Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5
Bill Donovan*        Brooklyn       5   5   0   5
Al Orth*             Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Jesse Tannehill      Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3
Kid Nichols          Boston         2   2   0   2
Bill Duggleby        Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Jack Harper          St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Rube Waddell         Chicago        1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Heinie Peitz**       Cincinnati     6   3   3   0
Deacon McGuire*      Brooklyn       4   3   1   2
Duke Farrell         Brooklyn       2   1   1   0
Ed McFarland         Philadelphia   2   1   1   0
Malachi Kittridge    Boston         1   1   0   1
Johnny Kling         Chicago        1   1   0   1

NL FIRST BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ed Delahanty**       Philadelphia   8   4   4   0
Jake Beckley*        Cincinnati     6   4   2   2
Kitty Bransfield     Pittsburgh     2   2   0   2

NL SECOND BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Tom Daly**           Brooklyn      12   6   6   0
Claude Ritchey       Pittsburgh     2   2   0   2

NL THIRD BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh     6   3   3   0
Tommy Leach*         Pittsburgh     6   4   2   2
Sammy Strang         New York       3   2   1   1
Willie Keeler        Brooklyn       1   1   0   1

NL SHORTSTOPS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Bobby Wallace**      St. Louis     11   6   5   1
Honus Wagner         Pittsburgh     4   3   1   2
George Davis*        New York       4   4   0   4

NL OUTFIELDERS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jesse Burkett**      St. Louis     10   6   4   2
Sam Crawford**       Cincinnati     9   6   3   3
Elmer Flick**        Philadelphia   9   6   3   3
Jimmy Sheckard*      Brooklyn       8   5   3   2
Topsy Hartsel*       Chicago        6   5   1   4
Emmet Heidrick*      St. Louis      4   2   2   0
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   4   3   1   2
Fred Clarke*         Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4
Ginger Beaumont*     Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3
Ed Delahanty         Philadelphia   3   2   1   1
Danny Green          Chicago        1   1   0   1
Willie Keeler        Brooklyn       1   1   0   1
George Van Haltren   New York       1   1   0   1

1901 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Tom Daly**           Brooklyn      12   6   6   0  2B
Ed Delahanty**       Philadelphia  11   6   5   1  1B-OF
Bobby Wallace**      St. Louis     11   6   5   1  SS
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh    10   6   4   2  3B-SS
Jesse Burkett**      St. Louis     10   6   4   2  OF
Christy Mathewson**  New York       9   6   3   3  P
Sam Crawford**       Cincinnati     9   6   3   3  OF
Elmer Flick**        Philadelphia   9   6   3   3  OF
Jimmy Sheckard*      Brooklyn       8   5   3   2  OF
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     6   6   0   6  P
Topsy Hartsel*       Chicago        6   5   1   4  OF
Noodles Hahn*        Cincinnati     6   4   2   2  P
Jake Beckley*        Cincinnati     6   4   2   2  1B
Tommy Leach*         Pittsburgh     6   4   2   2  3B
Heinie Peitz**       Cincinnati     6   3   3   0  C
Jack Chesbro*        Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5  P
Bill Donovan*        Brooklyn       5   5   0   5  P
Vic Willis*          Boston         5   4   1   3  P
Al Orth*             Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  P
George Davis*        New York       4   4   0   4  SS
Fred Clarke*         Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4  OF
Deacon McGuire*      Brooklyn       4   3   1   2  C
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   4   3   1   2  OF
Emmet Heidrick*      St. Louis      4   2   2   0  OF
Ginger Beaumont*     Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3  OF
Jesse Tannehill      Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3  P
Sammy Strang         New York       3   2   1   1  3B
Kid Nichols          Boston         2   2   0   2  P
Kitty Bransfield     Pittsburgh     2   2   0   2  1B
Claude Ritchey       Pittsburgh     2   2   0   2  2B
Willie Keeler        Brooklyn       2   2   0   2  OF-3B
Duke Farrell         Brooklyn       2   1   1   0  C
Ed McFarland         Philadelphia   2   1   1   0  C
Bill Duggleby        Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Jack Harper          St. Louis      1   1   0   1  P
Rube Waddell         Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
Malachi Kittridge    Boston         1   1   0   1  C
Johnny Kling         Chicago        1   1   0   1  C
Danny Green          Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF
George Van Haltren   New York       1   1   0   1  OF

1901 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R
Cy Young**            Boston        12   6   6   0
Clark Griffith*       Chicago        6   6   0   6
Roscoe Miller*        Detroit        6   6   0   6
Nixey Callahan*       Chicago        5   5   0   5
Joe McGinnity*        Baltimore      5   5   0   5
Earl Moore*           Cleveland      5   5   0   5
Eddie Plank*          Philadelphia   3   3   0   3
George Winter         Boston         2   2   0   2
Chick Fraser          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Joe Yeager            Detroit        1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R
Boileryard Clarke**   Washington     7   4   3   1
Ossee Schreckengost*  Boston         6   4   2   2
Bob Wood*             Cleveland      3   2   1   1

AL FIRST BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Buck Freeman**        Boston        12   6   6   0
John Anderson*        Milwaukee      5   5   0   5

AL SECOND BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**          Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Jimmy Williams*       Baltimore      6   6   0   6

AL THIRD BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jimmy Collins**       Boston        11   6   5   1
Lave Cross*           Philadelphia   5   5   0   5
John McGraw*          Baltimore      4   3   1   2
Bill Bradley          Cleveland      1   1   0   1
Fred Hartman          Chicago        1   1   0   1

AL SHORTSTOPS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Kid Elberfeld**       Detroit        8   5   3   2
Bill Keister*         Baltimore      7   4   3   1
Freddy Parent*        Boston         4   4   0   4

AL OUTFIELDERS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Socks Seybold**       Philadelphia  11   6   5   1
Dummy Hoy**           Chicago        9   6   3   3
Mike Donlin**         Baltimore      8   5   3   2
Fielder Jones*        Chicago        8   5   3   2
Chick Stahl*          Boston         7   4   3   1
Dave Fultz            Philadelphia   2   1   1   0
Cy Seymour            Baltimore      2   2   0   2
Jimmy Barrett         Detroit        1   1   0   1
Sam Dungan            Washington     1   1   0   1
Ollie Pickering       Cleveland      1   1   0   1

1901 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Cy Young**            Boston        12   6   6   0  P
Buck Freeman**        Boston        12   6   6   0  1B
Nap Lajoie**          Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  2B
Jimmy Collins**       Boston        11   6   5   1  3B
Socks Seybold**       Philadelphia  11   6   5   1  OF
Dummy Hoy**           Chicago        9   6   3   3  OF
Clark Griffith*       Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Roscoe Miller*        Detroit        6   6   0   6  P
Jimmy Williams*       Baltimore      6   6   0   6  2B
Kid Elberfeld**       Detroit        8   5   3   2  SS
Mike Donlin**         Baltimore      8   5   3   2  OF
Fielder Jones*        Chicago        8   5   3   2  OF
Nixey Callahan*       Chicago        5   5   0   5  P
Joe McGinnity*        Baltimore      5   5   0   5  P
Earl Moore*           Cleveland      5   5   0   5  P
John Anderson*        Milwaukee      5   5   0   5  1B
Lave Cross*           Philadelphia   5   5   0   5  3B
Boileryard Clarke**   Washington     7   4   3   1  C
Bill Keister*         Baltimore      7   4   3   1  SS
Chick Stahl*          Boston         7   4   3   1  OF
Ossee Schreckengost*  Boston         6   4   2   2  C
Freddy Parent*        Boston         4   4   0   4  SS
John McGraw*          Baltimore      4   3   1   2  3B
Eddie Plank*          Philadelphia   3   3   0   3  P
Bob Wood*             Cleveland      3   2   1   1  C
George Winter         Boston         2   2   0   2  P
Cy Seymour            Baltimore      2   2   0   2  OF
Dave Fultz            Philadelphia   2   1   1   0  OF
Chick Fraser          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Joe Yeager            Detroit        1   1   0   1  P
Bill Bradley          Cleveland      1   1   0   1  3B
Fred Hartman          Chicago        1   1   0   1  3B
Jimmy Barrett         Detroit        1   1   0   1  OF
Sam Dungan            Washington     1   1   0   1  OF
Ollie Pickering       Cleveland      1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
Pittsburgh    6  1  5   |   Boston        6  3  3
Cincinnati    4  2  2   |   Baltimore     5  1  4
Philadelphia  4  2  2   |   Philadelphia  4  2  2
Brooklyn      4  1  3   |   Chicago       4  1  3
St. Louis     3  2  1   |   Detroit       2  1  1
New York      2  1  1   |   Cleveland     2  0  2
Boston        1  0  1   |   Washington    1  1  0
Chicago       1  0  1   |   Milwaukee     1  0  1

**Nerdlinger** · 02-21-2010, 09:14 PM

1902 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #2
Tuesday, July 8, 1902
NL Manager: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh
AL Manager: Clark Griffith, Chicago

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1902 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Jack Taylor, Chicago
C: Johnny Kling, Chicago
1B: Jake Beckley, Cincinnati (2)
2B: Claude Ritchey, Pittsburgh
3B: Tommy Leach, Pittsburgh (2)
SS: Bill Dahlen, Brooklyn
OF: Ginger Beaumont, Pittsburgh (2)
OF: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh (2)
OF: Sam Crawford, Cincinnati (2)

NL Reserve Players

P: Jack Chesbro, Pittsburgh (2)
P: Noodles Hahn, Cincinnati (2)
P: Christy Mathewson, New York (2)
P: Deacon Phillippe, Pittsburgh (2)
P: Togie Pittinger, Boston
P: Jesse Tannehill, Pittsburgh
P: Vic Willis, Boston (2)
C: Frank Bowerman, New York
1B: Fred Tenney, Boston
2B: Heinie Peitz, Cincinnati (2)
3B: Harry Steinfeldt, Cincinnati
OF: Patsy Donovan, St. Louis
OF: Willie Keeler, Brooklyn
OF: Jimmy Sheckard, Brooklyn (2)
OF: Roy Thomas, Philadelphia (2)
OF: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (2)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1902 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Cy Young, Boston (2)
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Philadelphia (2)
1B: Charlie Hickman, Cleveland
2B: Nap Lajoie, Cleveland (2)
3B: Bill Bradley, Cleveland
SS: George Davis, Chicago (2)
OF: Ed Delahanty, Washington (2)
OF: Socks Seybold, Philadelphia (2)
OF: Buck Freeman, Boston (2)

AL Reserve Players

P: Bill Bernhard, Cleveland
P: Bill Dinneen, Boston
P: Red Donahue, St. Louis
P: Ned Garvin, Chicago
P: Joe McGinnity, Baltimore (2)
P: Rube Waddell, Philadelphia
C: Harry Bemis, Cleveland
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia
2B: Jimmy Williams, Baltimore (2)
3B: Jimmy Collins, Boston (2)
3B: Lave Cross, Philadelphia (2)
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis (2)
OF: Jesse Burkett, St. Louis (2)
OF: Topsy Hartsel, Philadelphia (2)
OF: Fielder Jones, Chicago (2)
OF: Jimmy Ryan, Washington

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 02-21-2010, 10:00 PM

1902 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A record total of 7 ballots were submitted.

Twenty-four players were unanimously elected: in the NL (15), Ginger Beaumont, Jake Beckley, Jack Chesbro, Sam Crawford, Bill Dahlen, Noodles Hahn, Willie Keeler, Johnny Kling, Tommy Leach, Heinie Peitz, Claude Ritchey, Jesse Tannehill, Jack Taylor, Fred Tenney, and Honus Wagner; and in the AL (9), Bill Bernhard, Bill Bradley, George Davis, Ed Delahanty, Charlie Hickman, Socks Seybold, Rube Waddell, Jimmy Williams, and Cy Young. Of those players, five were unanimously elected as starters: Ginger Beaumont (NL-OF), George Davis (AL-SS), Ed Delahanty (AL-OF), Johnny Kling (NL-C), and Tommy Leach (NL-3B).

All NL teams were represented by at least one player; in the AL, only Detroit lacked a representative on the final roster. Once again, the NL roster was flush with outfielders. There was a 3-way tie for the final two AL pitcher slots between Ned Garvin, Addie Joss, and Joe McGinnity, all with 3 total votes, of which 0 were starter votes. Garvin and McGinnity made the preliminary roster over Joss because Joss's final vote came last in the election. Joss missed the final cut as well, with the final two spots going to 1B Harry Davis and OF Topsy Hartsel.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1902 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jack Taylor**       Chicago       11   7   4   3
Jack Chesbro*       Pittsburgh     8   7   1   6
Noodles Hahn*       Cincinnati     8   7   1   6
Vic Willis*         Boston         7   6   1   5
Jesse Tannehill*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7
Deacon Phillippe*   Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5
Christy Mathewson*  New York       4   4   0   4
Togie Pittinger*    Boston         4   4   0   4
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Doc White           Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Johnny Kling**      Chicago       14   7   7   0
Frank Bowerman*     New York       2   2   0   2
Roger Bresnahan     New York       1   1   0   1
Frank Chance        Chicago        1   1   0   1
Heinie Peitz        Cincinnati     1   1   0   1

NL FIRST BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jake Beckley**      Cincinnati    12   7   5   2
Fred Tenney*        Boston         9   7   2   5
Kitty Bransfield    Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Frank Chance        Chicago        1   1   0   1

NL SECOND BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Claude Ritchey**    Pittsburgh    12   7   5   2
Heinie Peitz*       Cincinnati     8   6   2   4

NL THIRD BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Tommy Leach**       Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0
Harry Steinfeldt*   Cincinnati     3   3   0   3
Charlie Irwin       Brooklyn       1   1   0   1

NL SHORTSTOPS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Bill Dahlen**       Brooklyn      12   7   5   2
Honus Wagner        Pittsburgh     4   2   2   0
Joe Tinker          Chicago        2   2   0   2

NL OUTFIELDERS      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ginger Beaumont**   Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0
Sam Crawford**      Cincinnati    13   7   6   1
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh    11   6   5   1
Honus Wagner*       Pittsburgh     8   5   3   2
Willie Keeler*      Brooklyn       7   7   0   7
Jimmy Sheckard*     Brooklyn       4   4   0   4
Roy Thomas*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Patsy Donovan*      St. Louis      3   3   0   3
Jimmy Slagle        Chicago        3   3   0   3
Roger Bresnahan     New York       1   1   0   1
Cy Seymour          Cincinnati     1   1   0   1
Homer Smoot         St. Louis      1   1   0   1

1902 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Johnny Kling**      Chicago       14   7   7   0  C
Tommy Leach**       Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0  3B
Ginger Beaumont**   Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0  OF
Sam Crawford**      Cincinnati    13   7   6   1  OF
Jake Beckley**      Cincinnati    12   7   5   2  1B
Claude Ritchey**    Pittsburgh    12   7   5   2  2B
Bill Dahlen**       Brooklyn      12   7   5   2  SS
Honus Wagner*       Pittsburgh    12   7   5   2  OF-SS
Jack Taylor**       Chicago       11   7   4   3  P
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh    11   6   5   1  OF
Fred Tenney*        Boston         9   7   2   5  1B
Heinie Peitz*       Cincinnati     9   7   2   5  2B-C
Jack Chesbro*       Pittsburgh     8   7   1   6  P
Noodles Hahn*       Cincinnati     8   7   1   6  P
Jesse Tannehill*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7  P
Willie Keeler*      Brooklyn       7   7   0   7  OF
Vic Willis*         Boston         7   6   1   5  P
Deacon Phillippe*   Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5  P
Christy Mathewson*  New York       4   4   0   4  P
Togie Pittinger*    Boston         4   4   0   4  P
Jimmy Sheckard*     Brooklyn       4   4   0   4  OF
Roy Thomas*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  OF
Harry Steinfeldt*   Cincinnati     3   3   0   3  3B
Patsy Donovan*      St. Louis      3   3   0   3  OF
Jimmy Slagle        Chicago        3   3   0   3  OF
Frank Bowerman*     New York       2   2   0   2  C
Frank Chance        Chicago        2   2   0   2  1B-C
Joe Tinker          Chicago        2   2   0   2  SS
Roger Bresnahan     New York       2   2   0   2  C-OF
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Doc White           Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Kitty Bransfield    Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  1B
Charlie Irwin       Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  3B
Homer Smoot         St. Louis      1   1   0   1  OF
Cy Seymour          Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  OF

1902 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Cy Young**             Boston        13   7   6   1
Rube Waddell*          Philadelphia   8   7   1   6
Bill Bernhard*         Cleveland      7   7   0   7
Bill Dinneen*          Boston         6   6   0   6
Red Donahue*           St. Louis      5   5   0   5
Ned Garvin*            Chicago        3   3   0   3
Joe McGinnity*         Baltimore      3   3   0   3
Addie Joss             Cleveland      3   3   0   3
Win Mercer             Detroit        2   2   0   2
Jack Powell            St. Louis      2   2   0   2
Earl Moore             Cleveland      1   1   0   1
Roy Patterson          Chicago        1   1   0   1
Eddie Plank            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Ed Siever              Detroit        1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      7   6   1   5

AL FIRST BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Charlie Hickman**      Cleveland     13   7   6   1
Harry Davis*           Philadelphia   4   3   1   2

AL SECOND BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     12   6   6   0
Jimmy Williams*        Baltimore      8   7   1   6

AL THIRD BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Bill Bradley**         Cleveland     13   7   6   1
Jimmy Collins*         Boston         7   6   1   5
Lave Cross*            Philadelphia   5   5   0   5
Sammy Strang           Chicago        1   1   0   1

AL SHORTSTOPS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
George Davis**         Chicago       14   7   7   0
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6

AL OUTFIELDERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ed Delahanty**         Washington    14   7   7   0
Socks Seybold**        Philadelphia  13   7   6   1
Buck Freeman**         Boston        10   6   4   2
Fielder Jones*         Chicago        6   4   2   2
Jesse Burkett*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6
Topsy Hartsel*         Philadelphia   4   3   1   2
Jimmy Ryan*            Washington     4   4   0   4
Joe Kelley             Baltimore      2   1   1   0
Patsy Dougherty        Boston         2   2   0   2
Jimmy Barrett          Detroit        1   1   0   1
Elmer Flick            Cleveland      1   1   0   1
Danny Green            Chicago        1   1   0   1
Charlie Hemphill       St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Chick Stahl            Boston         1   1   0   1

1902 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS             TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
George Davis**         Chicago       14   7   7   0  SS
Ed Delahanty**         Washington    14   7   7   0  OF
Cy Young**             Boston        13   7   6   1  P
Charlie Hickman**      Cleveland     13   7   6   1  1B
Bill Bradley**         Cleveland     13   7   6   1  3B
Socks Seybold**        Philadelphia  13   7   6   1  OF
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  C
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     12   6   6   0  2B
Buck Freeman**         Boston        10   6   4   2  OF
Rube Waddell*          Philadelphia   8   7   1   6  P
Jimmy Williams*        Baltimore      8   7   1   6  2B
Bill Bernhard*         Cleveland      7   7   0   7  P
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      7   6   1   5  C
Jimmy Collins*         Boston         7   6   1   5  3B
Bill Dinneen*          Boston         6   6   0   6  P
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6  SS
Jesse Burkett*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6  OF
Fielder Jones*         Chicago        6   4   2   2  OF
Red Donahue*           St. Louis      5   5   0   5  P
Lave Cross*            Philadelphia   5   5   0   5  3B
Jimmy Ryan*            Washington     4   4   0   4  OF
Harry Davis*           Philadelphia   4   3   1   2  1B
Topsy Hartsel*         Philadelphia   4   3   1   2  OF
Ned Garvin*            Chicago        3   3   0   3  P
Joe McGinnity*         Baltimore      3   3   0   3  P
Addie Joss             Cleveland      3   3   0   3  P
Win Mercer             Detroit        2   2   0   2  P
Jack Powell            St. Louis      2   2   0   2  P
Patsy Dougherty        Boston         2   2   0   2  OF
Joe Kelley             Baltimore      2   1   1   0  OF
Earl Moore             Cleveland      1   1   0   1  P
Roy Patterson          Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
Eddie Plank            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Ed Siever              Detroit        1   1   0   1  P
Sammy Strang           Chicago        1   1   0   1  3B
Jimmy Barrett          Detroit        1   1   0   1  OF
Elmer Flick            Cleveland      1   1   0   1  OF
Danny Green            Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF
Charlie Hemphill       St. Louis      1   1   0   1  OF
Chick Stahl            Boston         1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
Pittsburgh    8  4  4   |   Philadelphia  6  2  4
Cincinnati    5  2  3   |   Cleveland     5  3  2
Brooklyn      3  1  2   |   Boston        4  2  2
Boston        3  0  3   |   Chicago       3  1  2
Chicago       2  2  0   |   St. Louis     3  0  3
New York      2  0  2   |   Washington    2  1  1
Philadelphia  1  0  1   |   Baltimore     2  0  2
St. Louis     1  0  1   |   Detroit       0  0  0

**Nerdlinger** · 02-28-2010, 09:06 PM

1903 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #3
Tuesday, July 14, 1903
NL Manager: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh
AL Manager: Connie Mack, Philadelphia

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1903 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Christy Mathewson, New York (3)
C: Johnny Kling, Chicago (2)
1B: Frank Chance, Chicago
2B: Claude Ritchey, Pittsburgh (2)
3B: Harry Steinfeldt, Cincinnati (2)
SS: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (3)
OF: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh (3)
OF: Mike Donlin, Cincinnati (2)
OF: Jimmy Sheckard, Brooklyn (3)

NL Reserve Players

P: Noodles Hahn, Cincinnati (3)
P: Sam Leever, Pittsburgh
P: Joe McGinnity, New York (3)
P: Deacon Phillippe, Pittsburgh (3)
P: Jack Taylor, Chicago (2)
P: Jake Weimer, Chicago
C: Pat Moran, Boston
1B: Jake Beckley, Cincinnati (3)
1B: Fred Tenney, Boston (2)
2B: Johnny Evers, Chicago
3B: Tommy Leach, Pittsburgh (3)
SS: Joe Tinker, Chicago
OF: Ginger Beaumont, Pittsburgh (3)
OF: Roger Bresnahan, New York
OF: Cy Seymour, Cincinnati
OF: Roy Thomas, Philadelphia (3)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1903 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Cy Young, Boston (3)
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Philadelphia (3)
1B: Charlie Hickman, Cleveland (2)
2B: Nap Lajoie, Cleveland (3)
3B: Bill Bradley, Cleveland (2)
SS: Freddy Parent, Boston (2)
OF: Sam Crawford, Detroit (3)
OF: Patsy Dougherty, Boston
OF: Buck Freeman, Boston (3)

AL Reserve Players

P: Bill Dinneen, Boston (2)
P: Addie Joss, Cleveland
P: Earl Moore, Cleveland (2)
P: George Mullin, Detroit
P: Eddie Plank, Philadelphia (2)
P: Willie Sudhoff, St. Louis
P: Rube Waddell, Philadelphia (2)
P: Doc White, Chicago
C: Harry Bemis, Cleveland (2)
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia (2)
3B: Jimmy Collins, Boston (3)
SS: Kid Elberfeld, New York (2)
OF: Jimmy Barrett, Detroit
OF: Elmer Flick, Cleveland (2)
OF: Danny Green, Chicago
OF: Socks Seybold, Philadelphia (3)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 02-28-2010, 09:07 PM

1903 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A total of 7 ballots were submitted, tying the record set in 1902.

Twenty-six players were unanimously elected for the roster. Of these, 6 received all their votes as starting players: in the NL (1), SS Honus Wagner; and in the AL (5), 1B Charlie Hickman, 2B Nap Lajoie, 3B Bill Bradley, SS Freddy Parent, and OF Sam Crawford.

In each league, one team was unrepresented on the final roster: St. Louis (NL) and Washington (AL). The AL roster sported 9 pitchers, a record number. In the AL, Cy Young was selected as starting pitcher for the third consecutive year. There was a tie for the final NL reserve spot between 1B Jake Beckley and SS Bill Dahlen, each with 3 points and 3 total votes. The spot went to Beckley because his final vote came earlier than Dahlen's in the election.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1903 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Christy Mathewson**  New York      12   7   5   2
Joe McGinnity*       New York       9   7   2   5
Noodles Hahn*        Cincinnati     7   7   0   7
Sam Leever*          Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7
Jake Weimer*         Chicago        6   6   0   6
Jack Taylor*         Chicago        5   5   0   5
Mordecai Brown       St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Oscar Jones          Brooklyn       1   1   0   1
Bob Wicker           Chicago        1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Johnny Kling**       Chicago       13   7   6   1
Pat Moran*           Boston         4   4   0   4
Roger Bresnahan      New York       2   1   1   0

NL FIRST BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank Chance**       Chicago       13   7   6   1
Fred Tenney*         Boston         5   5   0   5
Jack Doyle           Brooklyn       3   2   1   1
Jake Beckley*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3

NL SECOND BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Claude Ritchey**     Pittsburgh    12   7   5   2
Johnny Evers*        Chicago        4   2   2   0
John Farrell         St. Louis      1   1   0   1

NL THIRD BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Steinfeldt**   Cincinnati    11   7   4   3
Tommy Leach*         Pittsburgh     9   6   3   3

NL SHORTSTOPS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0
Joe Tinker*          Chicago        4   4   0   4
Bill Dahlen          Brooklyn       3   3   0   3

NL OUTFIELDERS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Mike Donlin**        Cincinnati    13   7   6   1
Jimmy Sheckard**     Brooklyn      12   7   5   2
Fred Clarke**        Pittsburgh    10   7   3   4
Ginger Beaumont*     Pittsburgh     9   7   2   5
Cy Seymour*          Cincinnati     8   6   2   4
Roger Bresnahan*     New York       7   6   1   5
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   4   3   1   2
Bill Keister         Philadelphia   2   1   1   0
Sam Mertes           New York       2   2   0   2

1903 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0  SS
Johnny Kling**       Chicago       13   7   6   1  C
Frank Chance**       Chicago       13   7   6   1  1B
Mike Donlin**        Cincinnati    13   7   6   1  OF
Christy Mathewson**  New York      12   7   5   2  P
Claude Ritchey**     Pittsburgh    12   7   5   2  2B
Jimmy Sheckard**     Brooklyn      12   7   5   2  OF
Harry Steinfeldt**   Cincinnati    11   7   4   3  3B
Fred Clarke**        Pittsburgh    10   7   3   4  OF
Joe McGinnity*       New York       9   7   2   5  P
Roger Bresnahan*     New York       9   7   2   5  OF-C
Ginger Beaumont*     Pittsburgh     9   7   2   5  OF
Tommy Leach*         Pittsburgh     9   6   3   3  3B
Cy Seymour*          Cincinnati     8   6   2   4  OF
Noodles Hahn*        Cincinnati     7   7   0   7  P
Sam Leever*          Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7  P
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7  P
Jake Weimer*         Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Jack Taylor*         Chicago        5   5   0   5  P
Fred Tenney*         Boston         5   5   0   5  1B
Pat Moran*           Boston         4   4   0   4  C
Joe Tinker*          Chicago        4   4   0   4  SS
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   4   3   1   2  OF
Johnny Evers*        Chicago        4   2   2   0  2B
Jake Beckley*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3  1B
Bill Dahlen          Brooklyn       3   3   0   3  SS
Jack Doyle           Brooklyn       3   2   1   1  1B
Sam Mertes           New York       2   2   0   2  OF
Bill Keister         Philadelphia   2   1   1   0  OF
Mordecai Brown       St. Louis      1   1   0   1  P
Oscar Jones          Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  P
Bob Wicker           Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
John Farrell         St. Louis      1   1   0   1  2B

1903 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Cy Young**             Boston        13   7   6   1
Bill Dinneen*          Boston         7   7   0   7
Rube Waddell*          Philadelphia   6   5   1   4
Eddie Plank*           Philadelphia   6   6   0   6
Earl Moore*            Cleveland      4   4   0   4
George Mullin*         Detroit        4   4   0   4
Doc White*             Chicago        4   4   0   4
Addie Joss*            Cleveland      3   3   0   3
Willie Sudhoff*        St. Louis      3   3   0   3
Jack Chesbro           New York       2   2   0   2
Bill Donovan           Detroit        2   2   0   2
Tom Hughes             Boston         2   2   0   2

AL CATCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      6   5   1   4
Deacon McGuire         Detroit        1   1   0   1

AL FIRST BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Charlie Hickman**      Cleveland     14   7   7   0
Harry Davis*           Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
John Anderson          St. Louis      1   1   0   1

AL SECOND BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     14   7   7   0
Danny Murphy           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Jimmy Williams         New York       2   2   0   2
Hobe Ferris            Boston         1   1   0   1

AL THIRD BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Bill Bradley**         Cleveland     14   7   7   0
Jimmy Collins*         Boston         7   7   0   7

AL SHORTSTOPS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Freddy Parent**        Boston        14   7   7   0
Kid Elberfeld*         New York       7   7   0   7

AL OUTFIELDERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       14   7   7   0
Patsy Dougherty**      Boston        12   7   5   2
Buck Freeman**         Boston        11   7   4   3
Jimmy Barrett*         Detroit        8   6   2   4
Danny Green*           Chicago        6   5   1   4
Socks Seybold*         Philadelphia   6   5   1   4
Elmer Flick*           Cleveland      4   4   0   4
Willie Keeler          New York       3   2   1   1
Harry Bay              Cleveland      1   1   0   1
Jesse Burkett          St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Ed Delahanty           Washington     1   1   0   1
Topsy Hartsel          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Billy Lush             Detroit        1   1   0   1

1903 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS             TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Charlie Hickman**      Cleveland     14   7   7   0  1B
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     14   7   7   0  2B
Bill Bradley**         Cleveland     14   7   7   0  3B
Freddy Parent**        Boston        14   7   7   0  SS
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       14   7   7   0  OF
Cy Young**             Boston        13   7   6   1  P
Patsy Dougherty**      Boston        12   7   5   2  OF
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  C
Buck Freeman**         Boston        11   7   4   3  OF
Jimmy Barrett*         Detroit        8   6   2   4  OF
Bill Dinneen*          Boston         7   7   0   7  P
Jimmy Collins*         Boston         7   7   0   7  3B
Kid Elberfeld*         New York       7   7   0   7  SS
Eddie Plank*           Philadelphia   6   6   0   6  P
Rube Waddell*          Philadelphia   6   5   1   4  P
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      6   5   1   4  C
Danny Green*           Chicago        6   5   1   4  OF
Socks Seybold*         Philadelphia   6   5   1   4  OF
Earl Moore*            Cleveland      4   4   0   4  P
George Mullin*         Detroit        4   4   0   4  P
Doc White*             Chicago        4   4   0   4  P
Harry Davis*           Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  1B
Elmer Flick*           Cleveland      4   4   0   4  OF
Addie Joss*            Cleveland      3   3   0   3  P
Willie Sudhoff*        St. Louis      3   3   0   3  P
Willie Keeler          New York       3   2   1   1  OF
Jack Chesbro           New York       2   2   0   2  P
Bill Donovan           Detroit        2   2   0   2  P
Tom Hughes             Boston         2   2   0   2  P
Danny Murphy           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  2B
Jimmy Williams         New York       2   2   0   2  2B
Deacon McGuire         Detroit        1   1   0   1  C
John Anderson          St. Louis      1   1   0   1  1B
Hobe Ferris            Boston         1   1   0   1  2B
Harry Bay              Cleveland      1   1   0   1  OF
Jesse Burkett          St. Louis      1   1   0   1  OF
Ed Delahanty           Washington     1   1   0   1  OF
Topsy Hartsel          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  OF
Billy Lush             Detroit        1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
Pittsburgh    7  3  4   |   Cleveland     7  3  4
Chicago       6  2  4   |   Boston        6  4  2
Cincinnati    5  2  3   |   Philadelphia  5  1  4
New York      3  1  2   |   Detroit       3  1  2
Boston        2  0  2   |   Chicago       2  0  2
Brooklyn      1  1  0   |   New York      1  0  1
Philadelphia  1  0  1   |   St. Louis     1  0  1
St. Louis     0  0  0   |   Washington    0  0  0

**Nerdlinger** · 03-15-2010, 10:14 AM

1904 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #4
Tuesday, July 12, 1904
NL Manager: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh
AL Manager: Jimmy Collins, Boston

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1904 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Joe McGinnity, New York (4)
C: Mike Grady, St. Louis
1B: Frank Chance, Chicago (2)
2B: Claude Ritchey, Pittsburgh (3)
3B: Art Devlin, New York
SS: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (4)
OF: Harry Lumley, Brooklyn
OF: Cy Seymour, Cincinnati (2)
OF: Roy Thomas, Philadelphia (4)

NL Reserve Players

P: Patsy Flaherty, Pittsburgh
P: Noodles Hahn, Cincinnati (4)
P: Jack Harper, Cincinnati
P: Christy Mathewson, New York (4)
P: Kid Nichols, St. Louis
P: Jack Taylor, St. Louis (3)
P: Jake Weimer, Chicago (2)
C: Johnny Kling, Chicago (3)
1B: Jake Beckley, St. Louis (4)
2B: Miller Huggins, Cincinnati
3B: Jim Delahanty, Boston
SS: Bill Dahlen, New York (2)
OF: Ginger Beaumont, Pittsburgh (4)
OF: Roger Bresnahan, New York (2)
OF: Mike Donlin, Cincinnati (3)
OF: Sam Mertes, New York

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1904 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Jack Chesbro, New York (3)
C: Lew Drill, Washington
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia (3)
2B: Nap Lajoie, Cleveland (4)
3B: Bill Bradley, Cleveland (3)
SS: Freddy Parent, Boston (3)
OF: Elmer Flick, Cleveland (3)
OF: Willie Keeler, New York (2)
OF: Chick Stahl, Boston (2)

AL Reserve Players

P: Bill Dinneen, Boston (3)
P: Frank Owen, Chicago
P: Eddie Plank, Philadelphia (3)
P: Jesse Tannehill, Boston (2)
P: Rube Waddell, Philadelphia (3)
P: Cy Young, Boston (4)
C: Joe Sugden, St. Louis
C: Billy Sullivan, Chicago
2B: Danny Murphy, Philadelphia
3B: Lave Cross, Philadelphia (3)
SS: George Davis, Chicago (3)
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis (3)
OF: Jimmy Barrett, Detroit (2)
OF: Jesse Burkett, St. Louis (3)
OF: Buck Freeman, Boston (4)
OF: Danny Green, Chicago (2)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 03-15-2010, 10:24 AM

1904 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A new record total of 8 ballots were submitted.

Thirteen players were unanimously elected for the roster. Of these, 4 received all their votes as starting players: in the NL (1), SS Honus Wagner; and in the AL (3), 2B Nap Lajoie, 3B Bill Bradley, and OF Elmer Flick.

In each league, every team was represented by at least one player on the final roster. A tie in points for the third starting NL OF spot between Harry Lumley and Sam Mertes was broken in favor of Lumley, as he had 4 starter votes to Mertes's 3. Another tie, between Jimmy Barrett and Jake Stahl for the final spot on the AL roster, was broken in favor of Barrett, as Detroit was lacking a representative and Barrett fit the bill.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1904 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Joe McGinnity**     New York      15   8   7   1
Christy Mathewson*  New York       9   8   1   7
Kid Nichols*        St. Louis      6   6   0   6
Jake Weimer*        Chicago        6   6   0   6
Patsy Flaherty*     Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5
Noodles Hahn*       Cincinnati     5   5   0   5
Jack Harper*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3
Jack Taylor*        St. Louis      3   3   0   3
Mordecai Brown      Chicago        3   3   0   3
Buttons Briggs      Chicago        2   2   0   2
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Chappie McFarland   St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Dummy Taylor        New York       1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Mike Grady**        St. Louis     14   8   6   2
Johnny Kling*       Chicago        2   1   1   0
Red Dooin           Philadelphia   2   1   1   0

NL FIRST BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank Chance**      Chicago       15   8   7   1
Jake Beckley*       St. Louis      8   7   1   6
Dan McGann          New York       3   3   0   3
Joe Kelley          Cincinnati     1   1   0   1

NL SECOND BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Claude Ritchey**    Pittsburgh     9   5   4   1
Miller Huggins*     Cincinnati     7   5   2   3
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0
Billy Gilbert       New York       2   1   1   0
Kid Gleason         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2

NL THIRD BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Art Devlin**        New York      13   7   6   1
Jim Delahanty*      Boston         7   5   2   3
Tommy Leach         Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1

NL SHORTSTOPS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    16   8   8   0
Bill Dahlen*        New York       3   3   0   3
Dave Brain          St. Louis      3   3   0   3
Charlie Babb        Brooklyn       1   1   0   1

NL OUTFIELDERS      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Cy Seymour**        Cincinnati    13   8   5   3
Roy Thomas**        Philadelphia  12   7   5   2
Harry Lumley**      Brooklyn      10   6   4   2
Sam Mertes*         New York      10   7   3   4
Mike Donlin*        Cincinnati     8   6   2   4
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       8   7   1   6
Ginger Beaumont*    Pittsburgh     7   4   3   1
John Titus          Philadelphia   3   2   1   1

1904 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    16   8   8   0  SS
Joe McGinnity**     New York      15   8   7   1  P
Frank Chance**      Chicago       15   8   7   1  1B
Mike Grady**        St. Louis     14   8   6   2  C
Cy Seymour**        Cincinnati    13   8   5   3  OF
Art Devlin**        New York      13   7   6   1  3B
Roy Thomas**        Philadelphia  12   7   5   2  OF
Sam Mertes*         New York      10   7   3   4  OF
Harry Lumley**      Brooklyn      10   6   4   2  OF
Christy Mathewson*  New York       9   8   1   7  P
Claude Ritchey**    Pittsburgh     9   5   4   1  2B
Jake Beckley*       St. Louis      8   7   1   6  1B
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       8   7   1   6  OF
Mike Donlin*        Cincinnati     8   6   2   4  OF
Miller Huggins*     Cincinnati     7   5   2   3  2B
Jim Delahanty*      Boston         7   5   2   3  3B
Ginger Beaumont*    Pittsburgh     7   4   3   1  OF
Kid Nichols*        St. Louis      6   6   0   6  P
Jake Weimer*        Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Patsy Flaherty*     Pittsburgh     5   5   0   5  P
Noodles Hahn*       Cincinnati     5   5   0   5  P
Jack Harper*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3  P
Bill Dahlen*        New York       3   3   0   3  SS
Mordecai Brown      Chicago        3   3   0   3  P
Jack Taylor*        St. Louis      3   3   0   3  P
Dan McGann          New York       3   3   0   3  1B
Dave Brain          St. Louis      3   3   0   3  SS
John Titus          Philadelphia   3   2   1   1  OF
Buttons Briggs      Chicago        2   2   0   2  P
Kid Gleason         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  2B
Johnny Kling*       Chicago        2   1   1   0  C
Red Dooin           Philadelphia   2   1   1   0  C
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0  2B
Billy Gilbert       New York       2   1   1   0  2B
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Chappie McFarland   St. Louis      1   1   0   1  P
Dummy Taylor        New York       1   1   0   1  P
Joe Kelley          Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  1B
Tommy Leach         Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  3B
Charlie Babb        Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  SS

1904 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jack Chesbro**     New York      14   8   6   2
Cy Young*          Boston         9   8   1   7
Rube Waddell*      Philadelphia   8   7   1   6
Eddie Plank*       Philadelphia   7   7   0   7
Frank Owen*        Chicago        6   6   0   6
Jesse Tannehill*   Boston         6   6   0   6
Bill Dinneen*      Boston         4   4   0   4
Bill Bernhard      Cleveland      2   2   0   2
Addie Joss         Cleveland      2   2   0   2
Chief Bender       Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Lew Drill**        Washington     8   5   3   2
Joe Sugden*        St. Louis      7   4   3   1
Billy Sullivan*    Chicago        5   3   2   1

AL FIRST BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Davis**      Philadelphia  13   7   6   1
Jake Stahl         Washington     3   2   1   1
John Anderson      New York       2   1   1   0
Charlie Hickman    Cleveland      2   2   0   2

AL SECOND BASEMEN  TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**       Cleveland     16   8   8   0
Danny Murphy*      Philadelphia   7   7   0   7
Jimmy Williams     New York       1   1   0   1

AL THIRD BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Bill Bradley**     Cleveland     16   8   8   0
Lave Cross*        Philadelphia   3   3   0   3
Jimmy Collins      Boston         2   2   0   2

AL SHORTSTOPS      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Freddy Parent**    Boston        12   7   5   2
George Davis*      Chicago       11   8   3   5
Bobby Wallace*     St. Louis      5   5   0   5

AL OUTFIELDERS     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Elmer Flick**      Cleveland     16   8   8   0
Chick Stahl**      Boston        15   8   7   1
Willie Keeler**    New York      12   7   5   2
Buck Freeman*      Boston         7   6   1   5
Jesse Burkett*     St. Louis      6   5   1   4
Jimmy Barrett*     Detroit        3   2   1   1
Socks Seybold      Philadelphia   3   2   1   1
Danny Green*       Chicago        3   3   0   3
Sam Crawford       Detroit        1   1   0   1
Patsy Dougherty    New York       1   1   0   1
Kip Selbach        Boston         1   1   0   1

1904 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Nap Lajoie**       Cleveland     16   8   8   0  2B
Bill Bradley**     Cleveland     16   8   8   0  3B
Elmer Flick**      Cleveland     16   8   8   0  OF
Chick Stahl**      Boston        15   8   7   1  OF
Jack Chesbro**     New York      14   8   6   2  P
Harry Davis**      Philadelphia  13   7   6   1  1B
Freddy Parent**    Boston        12   7   5   2  SS
Willie Keeler**    New York      12   7   5   2  OF
George Davis*      Chicago       11   8   3   5  SS
Cy Young*          Boston         9   8   1   7  P
Rube Waddell*      Philadelphia   8   7   1   6  P
Lew Drill**        Washington     8   5   3   2  C
Eddie Plank*       Philadelphia   7   7   0   7  P
Danny Murphy*      Philadelphia   7   7   0   7  2B
Buck Freeman*      Boston         7   6   1   5  OF
Joe Sugden*        St. Louis      7   4   3   1  C
Frank Owen*        Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Jesse Tannehill*   Boston         6   6   0   6  P
Jesse Burkett*     St. Louis      6   5   1   4  OF
Bobby Wallace*     St. Louis      5   5   0   5  SS
Billy Sullivan*    Chicago        5   3   2   1  C
Bill Dinneen*      Boston         4   4   0   4  P
Lave Cross*        Philadelphia   3   3   0   3  3B
Danny Green*       Chicago        3   3   0   3  OF
Jimmy Barrett*     Detroit        3   2   1   1  OF
Jake Stahl         Washington     3   2   1   1  1B
Socks Seybold      Philadelphia   3   2   1   1  OF
Bill Bernhard      Cleveland      2   2   0   2  P
Addie Joss         Cleveland      2   2   0   2  P
Charlie Hickman    Cleveland      2   2   0   2  1B
Jimmy Collins      Boston         2   2   0   2  3B
John Anderson      New York       2   1   1   0  1B
Chief Bender       Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Jimmy Williams     New York       1   1   0   1  2B
Sam Crawford       Detroit        1   1   0   1  OF
Patsy Dougherty    New York       1   1   0   1  OF
Kip Selbach        Boston         1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
New York      6  2  4   |   Boston        6  2  4
Cincinnati    5  1  4   |   Philadelphia  5  1  4
Pittsburgh    4  2  2   |   Chicago       4  0  4
St. Louis     4  1  3   |   Cleveland     3  3  0
Chicago       3  1  2   |   St. Louis     3  0  3
Brooklyn      1  1  0   |   New York      2  2  0
Philadelphia  1  1  0   |   Washington    1  1  0
Boston        1  0  1   |   Detroit       1  0  1

**Nerdlinger** · 03-30-2010, 02:42 PM

1905 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #5
Tuesday, July 11, 1905
NL Manager: John McGraw, New York
AL Manager: Jimmy Collins, Boston

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1905 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Christy Mathewson, New York (5)
C: Roger Bresnahan, New York (3)
1B: Frank Chance, Chicago (3)
2B: Miller Huggins, Cincinnati (2)
3B: Ernie Courtney, Philadelphia
SS: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (5)
OF: Mike Donlin, New York (4)
OF: Cy Seymour, Cincinnati (3)
OF: John Titus, Philadelphia

NL Reserve Players

P: Red Ames, New York
P: Mordecai Brown, Chicago
P: Bob Ewing, Cincinnati
P: Sam Leever, Pittsburgh (2)
P: Deacon Phillippe, Pittsburgh (4)
P: Ed Reulbach, Chicago
P: Jake Weimer, Chicago (3)
C: Mike Grady, St. Louis (2)
1B: Dan McGann, New York
3B: Art Devlin, New York (2)
SS: Ed Abbaticchio, Boston
OF: Sherry Magee, Philadelphia
OF: Sam Mertes, New York (2)
OF: Jimmy Sheckard, Brooklyn (4)
OF: Homer Smoot, St. Louis
OF: Roy Thomas, Philadelphia (5)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1905 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Rube Waddell, Philadelphia (4)
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Philadelphia (4)
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia (4)
2B: Frank Isbell, Chicago
3B: Jimmy Collins, Boston (4)
SS: George Davis, Chicago (4)
OF: Sam Crawford, Detroit (4)
OF: Elmer Flick, Cleveland (4)
OF: George Stone, St. Louis

AL Reserve Players

P: Nick Altrock, Chicago
P: Jack Chesbro, New York (4)
P: Andy Coakley, Philadelphia
P: Addie Joss, Cleveland (2)
P: Eddie Plank, Philadelphia (4)
P: Jesse Tannehill, Boston (3)
P: Doc White, Chicago (2)
P: Cy Young, Boston (5)
C: Ed McFarland, Chicago
1B: Jiggs Donahue, Chicago
2B: Danny Murphy, Philadelphia (2)
2B: Charlie Hickman, Washington (3)
3B: Wid Conroy, New York
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis (4)
OF: Harry Bay, Cleveland
OF: Topsy Hartsel, Philadelphia (3)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 03-30-2010, 03:05 PM

1905 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A total of 8 ballots were submitted, tying the record set last season.

Fifteen players were unanimously elected for the roster. Of these, 7 received all their votes as starting players: in the NL (4), P Christy Mathewson, SS Honus Wagner, OF Mike Donlin, and OF Cy Seymour; and in the AL (3), 1B Harry Davis, 3B Jimmy Collins, and OF Sam Crawford.

In each league, every team was represented by at least one player on the final roster. As of this season, only 4 players have been elected to every single All-Star Game (1901-1905): Christy Mathewson, Roy Thomas, Honus Wagner, and Cy Young. Whose streak will last the longest? Only future elections will tell.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1905 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Christy Mathewson**  New York      16   8   8   0
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7
Mordecai Brown*      Chicago        6   6   0   6
Bob Ewing*           Cincinnati     6   6   0   6
Ed Reulbach*         Chicago        6   6   0   6
Red Ames*            New York       4   4   0   4
Sam Leever*          Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4
Jake Weimer*         Chicago        4   4   0   4
Irv Young            Boston         3   3   0   3
Tully Sparks         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Joe McGinnity        New York       1   1   0   1
Hooks Wiltse         New York       1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Roger Bresnahan**    New York      15   8   7   1
Mike Grady*          St. Louis      8   7   1   6
Red Dooin            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

NL FIRST BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank Chance**       Chicago       14   8   6   2
Dan McGann*          New York      10   8   2   6
Shad Barry           Cincinnati     1   1   0   1

NL SECOND BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Miller Huggins**     Cincinnati    15   8   7   1
Sammy Strang         New York       4   3   1   2
Claude Ritchey       Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1

NL THIRD BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ernie Courtney**     Philadelphia  11   6   5   1
Art Devlin*          New York       8   5   3   2

NL SHORTSTOPS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh    16   8   8   0
Ed Abbaticchio*      Boston         5   5   0   5
Bill Dahlen          New York       3   3   0   3

NL OUTFIELDERS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Mike Donlin**        New York      16   8   8   0
Cy Seymour**         Cincinnati    16   8   8   0
John Titus**         Philadelphia  12   7   5   2
Sherry Magee*        Philadelphia   6   5   1   4
Homer Smoot*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6
Sam Mertes*          New York       5   3   2   1
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   5   5   0   5
Jimmy Sheckard*      Brooklyn       4   4   0   4
Ginger Beaumont      Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3
Fred Clarke          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Jimmy Slagle         Chicago        1   1   0   1

1905 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Christy Mathewson**  New York      16   8   8   0  P
Honus Wagner**       Pittsburgh    16   8   8   0  SS
Mike Donlin**        New York      16   8   8   0  OF
Cy Seymour**         Cincinnati    16   8   8   0  OF
Roger Bresnahan**    New York      15   8   7   1  C
Miller Huggins**     Cincinnati    15   8   7   1  2B
Frank Chance**       Chicago       14   8   6   2  1B
John Titus**         Philadelphia  12   7   5   2  OF
Ernie Courtney**     Philadelphia  11   6   5   1  3B
Dan McGann*          New York      10   8   2   6  1B
Mike Grady*          St. Louis      8   7   1   6  C
Art Devlin*          New York       8   5   3   2  3B
Deacon Phillippe*    Pittsburgh     7   7   0   7  P
Mordecai Brown*      Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Bob Ewing*           Cincinnati     6   6   0   6  P
Ed Reulbach*         Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Homer Smoot*         St. Louis      6   6   0   6  OF
Sherry Magee*        Philadelphia   6   5   1   4  OF
Ed Abbaticchio*      Boston         5   5   0   5  SS
Roy Thomas*          Philadelphia   5   5   0   5  OF
Sam Mertes*          New York       5   3   2   1  OF
Red Ames*            New York       4   4   0   4  P
Sam Leever*          Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4  P
Jake Weimer*         Chicago        4   4   0   4  P
Jimmy Sheckard*      Brooklyn       4   4   0   4  OF
Sammy Strang         New York       4   3   1   2  2B
Irv Young            Boston         3   3   0   3  P
Bill Dahlen          New York       3   3   0   3  SS
Ginger Beaumont      Pittsburgh     3   3   0   3  OF
Tully Sparks         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  P
Joe McGinnity        New York       1   1   0   1  P
Hooks Wiltse         New York       1   1   0   1  P
Red Dooin            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  C
Shad Barry           Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  1B
Claude Ritchey       Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  2B
Fred Clarke          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  OF
Jimmy Slagle         Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF

1905 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Rube Waddell**         Philadelphia  15   8   7   1
Cy Young*              Boston         7   6   1   5
Nick Altrock*          Chicago        7   7   0   7
Andy Coakley*          Philadelphia   6   6   0   6
Addie Joss*            Cleveland      6   6   0   6
Jack Chesbro*          New York       5   5   0   5
Jesse Tannehill*       Boston         5   5   0   5
Eddie Plank*           Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Doc White*             Chicago        4   4   0   4
Ed Killian             Detroit        1   1   0   1
Frank Owen             Chicago        1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  15   8   7   1
Ed McFarland*          Chicago        6   5   1   4
Lou Criger             Boston         2   2   0   2
Harry Bemis            Cleveland      1   1   0   1

AL FIRST BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Davis**          Philadelphia  16   8   8   0
Jiggs Donahue*         Chicago        5   5   0   5

AL SECOND BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank Isbell**         Chicago       10   6   4   2
Danny Murphy*          Philadelphia   8   5   3   2
Charlie Hickman*       Washington     5   5   0   5
Nap Lajoie             Cleveland      2   1   1   0
Ike Rockenfield        St. Louis      1   1   0   1

AL THIRD BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jimmy Collins**        Boston        16   8   8   0
Wid Conroy*            New York       4   4   0   4
Bill Bradley           Cleveland      3   3   0   3
Lave Cross             Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

AL SHORTSTOPS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
George Davis**         Chicago       15   8   7   1
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      9   8   1   7
Monte Cross            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

AL OUTFIELDERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       16   8   8   0
Elmer Flick**          Cleveland     15   8   7   1
George Stone**         St. Louis     13   8   5   3
Topsy Hartsel*         Philadelphia  10   7   3   4
Harry Bay*             Cleveland      5   5   0   5
Frank Huelsman         Washington     3   3   0   3
Socks Seybold          Philadelphia   3   3   0   3
Fielder Jones          Chicago        2   1   1   0
Willie Keeler          New York       1   1   0   1

1905 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS             TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Harry Davis**          Philadelphia  16   8   8   0  1B
Jimmy Collins**        Boston        16   8   8   0  3B
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       16   8   8   0  OF
Rube Waddell**         Philadelphia  15   8   7   1  P
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia  15   8   7   1  C
George Davis**         Chicago       15   8   7   1  SS
Elmer Flick**          Cleveland     15   8   7   1  OF
George Stone**         St. Louis     13   8   5   3  OF
Topsy Hartsel*         Philadelphia  10   7   3   4  OF
Frank Isbell**         Chicago       10   6   4   2  2B
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      9   8   1   7  SS
Danny Murphy*          Philadelphia   8   5   3   2  2B
Nick Altrock*          Chicago        7   7   0   7  P
Cy Young*              Boston         7   6   1   5  P
Andy Coakley*          Philadelphia   6   6   0   6  P
Addie Joss*            Cleveland      6   6   0   6  P
Ed McFarland*          Chicago        6   5   1   4  C
Jack Chesbro*          New York       5   5   0   5  P
Jesse Tannehill*       Boston         5   5   0   5  P
Jiggs Donahue*         Chicago        5   5   0   5  1B
Charlie Hickman*       Washington     5   5   0   5  2B
Harry Bay*             Cleveland      5   5   0   5  OF
Eddie Plank*           Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  P
Doc White*             Chicago        4   4   0   4  P
Wid Conroy*            New York       4   4   0   4  3B
Bill Bradley           Cleveland      3   3   0   3  3B
Frank Huelsman         Washington     3   3   0   3  OF
Socks Seybold          Philadelphia   3   3   0   3  OF
Lou Criger             Boston         2   2   0   2  C
Nap Lajoie             Cleveland      2   1   1   0  2B
Fielder Jones          Chicago        2   1   1   0  OF
Ed Killian             Detroit        1   1   0   1  P
Frank Owen             Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
Harry Bemis            Cleveland      1   1   0   1  C
Ike Rockenfield        St. Louis      1   1   0   1  2B
Lave Cross             Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  3B
Monte Cross            Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  SS
Willie Keeler          New York       1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
New York      7  3  4   |   Philadelphia  7  3  4
Philadelphia  4  2  2   |   Chicago       6  2  4
Chicago       4  1  3   |   Boston        3  1  2
Cincinnati    3  2  1   |   Cleveland     3  1  2
Pittsburgh    3  1  2   |   St. Louis     2  1  1
St. Louis     2  0  2   |   New York      2  0  2
Boston        1  0  1   |   Detroit       1  1  0
Brooklyn      1  0  1   |   Washington    1  0  1

**Nerdlinger** · 04-05-2010, 11:01 PM

1906 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #6
Tuesday, July 10, 1906
NL Manager: John McGraw, New York
AL Manager: Connie Mack, Philadelphia

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1906 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Mordecai Brown, Chicago (2)
C: Johnny Kling, Chicago (4)
1B: Frank Chance, Chicago (4)
2B: Sammy Strang, New York
3B: Harry Steinfeldt, Chicago (3)
SS: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (6)
OF: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh (4)
OF: Harry Lumley, Brooklyn (2)
OF: Sherry Magee, Philadelphia (2)

NL Reserve Players

P: Sam Leever, Pittsburgh (3)
P: Joe McGinnity, New York (5)
P: Jack Pfiester, Chicago
P: Ed Reulbach, Chicago (2)
P: Jake Weimer, Cincinnati (4)
P: Vic Willis, Pittsburgh (3)
C: Roger Bresnahan, New York (4)
1B: Tim Jordan, Brooklyn
2B: Miller Huggins, Cincinnati (3)
2B: Claude Ritchey, Pittsburgh (4)
3B: Art Devlin, New York (3)
SS: Bill Dahlen, New York (3)
OF: Cy Seymour, Cincinnati (4)
OF: Frank Schulte, Chicago
OF: Jimmy Sheckard, Chicago (5)
OF: John Titus, Philadelphia (2)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1906 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Addie Joss, Cleveland (3)
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Philadelphia (5)
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia (5)
2B: Nap Lajoie, Cleveland (5)
3B: Frank LaPorte, New York
SS: Terry Turner, Cleveland
OF: Sam Crawford, Detroit (5)
OF: Elmer Flick, Cleveland (5)
OF: George Stone, St. Louis (2)

AL Reserve Players

P: Otto Hess, Cleveland
P: Al Orth, New York (2)
P: Jack Powell, St. Louis
P: Bob Rhoads, Cleveland
P: Ed Walsh, Chicago
P: Doc White, Chicago (3)
C: Harry Bemis, Cleveland (3)
1B: Hal Chase, New York
2B: Danny Murphy, Philadelphia (3)
3B: Bill Bradley, Cleveland (4)
3B: Charlie Hickman, Washington (4)
SS: George Davis, Chicago (5)
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis (5)
OF: Charlie Hemphill, St. Louis
OF: Socks Seybold, Philadelphia (4)
OF: Chick Stahl, Boston (3)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 04-05-2010, 11:03 PM

1906 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A total of 6 ballots were submitted.

Seventeen players were unanimously elected for the roster. Of these, 9 received all their votes as starting players: in the NL (5), P Mordecai Brown, 1B Frank Chance, SS Honus Wagner, OF Harry Lumley, and OF Sherry Magee; and in the AL (4), 1B Harry Davis, 2B Nap Lajoie, OF Elmer Flick, and OF George Stone.

In the AL, every team was represented by at least one player on the final roster, while in the NL, all teams but Boston and St. Louis were represented by at least one player. A tie between Johnny Kling and Roger Bresnahan for starting NL catcher (both with 3 starter votes and 3 reserve votes) was broken in favor of Kling due to his final starter vote having come earlier in the election.

As of this season, only 1 player has been elected to every single All-Star Game (1901-1906): Honus Wagner. Off seasons for 5-time All-Stars Christy Mathewson, Roy Thomas, and Cy Young have left the Flying Dutchman alone with the honor.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1906 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Mordecai Brown**    Chicago       12   6   6   0
Jack Pfiester*      Chicago        6   6   0   6
Vic Willis*         Pittsburgh     6   6   0   6
Sam Leever*         Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4
Joe McGinnity*      New York       4   4   0   4
Ed Reulbach*        Chicago        4   4   0   4
Jake Weimer*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3
Tully Sparks        Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Jack Taylor         Chicago        2   2   0   2
Fred Beebe          St. Louis      1   1   0   1
Bob Ewing           Cincinnati     1   1   0   1
Lefty Leifield      Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Deacon Phillippe    Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Johnny Kling**      Chicago        9   6   3   3
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       9   6   3   3

NL FIRST BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank Chance**      Chicago       12   6   6   0
Tim Jordan*         Brooklyn       4   4   0   4
Fred Tenney         Boston         1   1   0   1

NL SECOND BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Sammy Strang**      New York       7   5   2   3
Miller Huggins*     Cincinnati     6   4   2   2
Claude Ritchey*     Pittsburgh     5   4   1   3
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0
Pug Bennett         St. Louis      1   1   0   1

NL THIRD BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Steinfeldt**  Chicago       10   6   4   2
Art Devlin*         New York       7   5   2   3
Tommy Leach         Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1

NL SHORTSTOPS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0
Bill Dahlen*        New York       2   2   0   2

NL OUTFIELDERS      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Lumley**      Brooklyn      12   6   6   0
Sherry Magee**      Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh     8   5   3   2
Cy Seymour*         Cincinnati     6   4   2   2
Frank Schulte*      Chicago        4   3   1   2
Jimmy Sheckard*     Chicago        3   3   0   3
John Titus*         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Johnny Bates        Boston         1   1   0   1
Jack McCarthy       Brooklyn       1   1   0   1
Roy Thomas          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

1906 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Mordecai Brown**    Chicago       12   6   6   0  P
Frank Chance**      Chicago       12   6   6   0  1B
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0  SS
Harry Lumley**      Brooklyn      12   6   6   0  OF
Sherry Magee**      Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  OF
Harry Steinfeldt**  Chicago       10   6   4   2  3B
Johnny Kling**      Chicago        9   6   3   3  C
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       9   6   3   3  C
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh     8   5   3   2  OF
Sammy Strang**      New York       7   5   2   3  2B
Art Devlin*         New York       7   5   2   3  3B
Jack Pfiester*      Chicago        6   6   0   6  P
Vic Willis*         Pittsburgh     6   6   0   6  P
Miller Huggins*     Cincinnati     6   4   2   2  2B
Cy Seymour*         Cincinnati     6   4   2   2  OF
Claude Ritchey*     Pittsburgh     5   4   1   3  2B
Sam Leever*         Pittsburgh     4   4   0   4  P
Joe McGinnity*      New York       4   4   0   4  P
Ed Reulbach*        Chicago        4   4   0   4  P
Tim Jordan*         Brooklyn       4   4   0   4  1B
Frank Schulte*      Chicago        4   3   1   2  OF
Jake Weimer*        Cincinnati     3   3   0   3  P
Jimmy Sheckard*     Chicago        3   3   0   3  OF
Bill Dahlen*        New York       2   2   0   2  SS
John Titus*         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  OF
Tully Sparks        Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  P
Jack Taylor         Chicago        2   2   0   2  P
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0  2B
Fred Beebe          St. Louis      1   1   0   1  P
Bob Ewing           Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  P
Lefty Leifield      Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Deacon Phillippe    Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Fred Tenney         Boston         1   1   0   1  1B
Pug Bennett         St. Louis      1   1   0   1  2B
Tommy Leach         Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  3B
Johnny Bates        Boston         1   1   0   1  OF
Jack McCarthy       Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  OF
Roy Thomas          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  OF

1906 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Addie Joss**           Cleveland      9   6   3   3
Doc White*             Chicago        8   6   2   4
Ed Walsh*              Chicago        4   3   1   2
Al Orth*               New York       4   4   0   4
Bob Rhoads*            Cleveland      4   4   0   4
Otto Hess*             Cleveland      3   3   0   3
Jack Powell*           St. Louis      2   2   0   2
Chief Bender           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Barney Pelty           St. Louis      2   2   0   2
Eddie Plank            Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Rube Waddell           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Nick Altrock           Chicago        1   1   0   1
Jack Chesbro           New York       1   1   0   1
Case Patten            Washington     1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia   7   4   3   1
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      6   4   2   2
Billy Sullivan         Chicago        2   1   1   0
Branch Rickey          St. Louis      1   1   0   1

AL FIRST BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Davis**          Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Hal Chase*             New York       5   5   0   5

AL SECOND BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     12   6   6   0
Danny Murphy*          Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Jimmy Williams         New York       1   1   0   1

AL THIRD BASEMEN       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Frank LaPorte**        New York       6   3   3   0
Bill Bradley*          Cleveland      4   3   1   2
Lave Cross             Washington     3   2   1   1
Charlie Hickman*       Washington     2   1   1   0

AL SHORTSTOPS          TEAM           P   T   S   R
Terry Turner**         Cleveland      9   6   3   3
George Davis*          Chicago        7   4   3   1
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      3   3   0   3

AL OUTFIELDERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Elmer Flick**          Cleveland     12   6   6   0
George Stone**         St. Louis     12   6   6   0
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       10   6   4   2
Socks Seybold*         Philadelphia   7   6   1   5
Charlie Hemphill*      St. Louis      5   4   1   3
Chick Stahl*           Boston         3   3   0   3
Bunk Congalton         Cleveland      2   2   0   2
Ty Cobb                Detroit        1   1   0   1
Topsy Hartsel          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Charlie Hickman        Washington     1   1   0   1
Fielder Jones          Chicago        1   1   0   1
Willie Keeler          New York       1   1   0   1

1906 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS             TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Harry Davis**          Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  1B
Nap Lajoie**           Cleveland     12   6   6   0  2B
Elmer Flick**          Cleveland     12   6   6   0  OF
George Stone**         St. Louis     12   6   6   0  OF
Sam Crawford**         Detroit       10   6   4   2  OF
Addie Joss**           Cleveland      9   6   3   3  P
Terry Turner**         Cleveland      9   6   3   3  SS
Doc White*             Chicago        8   6   2   4  P
Socks Seybold*         Philadelphia   7   6   1   5  OF
Ossee Schreckengost**  Philadelphia   7   4   3   1  C
George Davis*          Chicago        7   4   3   1  SS
Harry Bemis*           Cleveland      6   4   2   2  C
Frank LaPorte**        New York       6   3   3   0  3B
Hal Chase*             New York       5   5   0   5  1B
Charlie Hemphill*      St. Louis      5   4   1   3  OF
Al Orth*               New York       4   4   0   4  P
Bob Rhoads*            Cleveland      4   4   0   4  P
Danny Murphy*          Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  2B
Ed Walsh*              Chicago        4   3   1   2  P
Bill Bradley*          Cleveland      4   3   1   2  3B
Otto Hess*             Cleveland      3   3   0   3  P
Bobby Wallace*         St. Louis      3   3   0   3  SS
Chick Stahl*           Boston         3   3   0   3  OF
Charlie Hickman*       Washington     3   2   1   1  3B-OF
Lave Cross             Washington     3   2   1   1  3B
Jack Powell*           St. Louis      2   2   0   2  P
Chief Bender           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  P
Barney Pelty           St. Louis      2   2   0   2  P
Eddie Plank            Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  P
Rube Waddell           Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  P
Bunk Congalton         Cleveland      2   2   0   2  OF
Billy Sullivan         Chicago        2   1   1   0  C
Nick Altrock           Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
Jack Chesbro           New York       1   1   0   1  P
Case Patten            Washington     1   1   0   1  P
Branch Rickey          St. Louis      1   1   0   1  C
Jimmy Williams         New York       1   1   0   1  2B
Ty Cobb                Detroit        1   1   0   1  OF
Topsy Hartsel          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  OF
Fielder Jones          Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF
Willie Keeler          New York       1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
Chicago       8  4  4   |   Cleveland     8  4  4
Pittsburgh    5  2  3   |   Philadelphia  4  2  2
New York      5  1  4   |   St. Louis     4  1  3
Cincinnati    3  0  3   |   New York      3  1  2
Brooklyn      2  1  1   |   Chicago       3  0  3
Philadelphia  2  1  1   |   Detroit       1  1  0
Boston        0  0  0   |   Boston        1  0  1
St. Louis     0  0  0   |   Washington    1  0  1

**Nerdlinger** · 04-14-2010, 08:46 PM

1907 Retrospective All-Star Game Final Rosters

Retrospective All-Star Game #7
Tuesday, July 9, 1907
NL Manager: Frank Chance, Chicago
AL Manager: Fielder Jones, Chicago

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1907 NATIONAL LEAGUE ROSTER

NL Starting Players

P: Mordecai Brown, Chicago (3)
C: Johnny Kling, Chicago (5)
1B: Tim Jordan, Brooklyn (3)
2B: Ed Abbaticchio, Pittsburgh (2)
3B: Dave Brain, Boston
SS: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh (7)
OF: Ginger Beaumont, Boston (5)
OF: Fred Clarke, Pittsburgh (5)
OF: Sherry Magee, Philadelphia (3)

NL Reserve Players

P: Bob Ewing, Cincinnati (2)
P: Carl Lundgren, Chicago
P: Christy Mathewson, New York (6)
P: Orval Overall, Chicago
P: Jack Pfiester, Chicago (2)
P: Tully Sparks, Philadelphia
P: Ed Karger, St. Louis
P: Ed Reulbach, Chicago (3)
C: Roger Bresnahan, New York (5)
1B: Frank Chance, Chicago (5)
1B: Fred Tenney, Boston (3)
2B: Otto Knabe, Philadelphia
3B: Art Devlin, New York (4)
OF: Tommy Leach, Pittsburgh (4)
OF: Harry Lumley, Brooklyn (3)
OF: Cy Seymour, New York (5)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1907 AMERICAN LEAGUE ROSTER

AL Starting Players

P: Ed Walsh, Chicago (2)
C: Nig Clarke, Cleveland
1B: Harry Davis, Philadelphia (6)
2B: Nap Lajoie, Cleveland (6)
3B: Jimmy Collins, Philadelphia (5)
SS: Simon Nicholls, Philadelphia
OF: Ty Cobb, Detroit
OF: Sam Crawford, Detroit (6)
OF: George Stone, St. Louis (3)

AL Reserve Players

P: Chief Bender, Philadelphia
P: Bill Donovan, Detroit (2)
P: Addie Joss, Cleveland (4)
P: Ed Killian, Detroit
P: Eddie Plank, Philadelphia (5)
P: Rube Waddell, Philadelphia (5)
P: Doc White, Chicago (4)
P: Cy Young, Boston (6)
C: Ossee Schreckengost, Philadelphia (6)
1B: Hal Chase, New York (2)
2B: Jim Delahanty, Washington (2)
SS: Dave Altizer, Washington
SS: Kid Elberfeld, New York (3)
SS: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis (6)
OF: Elmer Flick, Cleveland (6)
OF: Topsy Hartsel, Philadelphia (4)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note: Number in parentheses is how many Retrospective All-Star teams to which the player has been elected, including this election.

**Nerdlinger** · 04-15-2010, 07:56 PM

1907 Retrospective All-Star Game Election: Recap

A total of 7 ballots were submitted.

Thirteen players were unanimously elected for the roster. Of these, 4 received all their votes as starting players: in the NL (2), SS Honus Wagner and OF Sherry Magee; and in the AL (2), 2B Nap Lajoie and OF Ty Cobb. Detroit's 3rd-year outfielder Cobb shows real potential; expect a lot from this talented youngster in the future.

In both leagues, every team was represented by at least one player on the final roster. Interestingly, while the NL team only had Wagner at shortstop, the AL team was jam-packed with a record 4 shortstops.

==================================================
==================================================

Voting Breakdown
** = All-Star starter
* = All-Star reserve
P = points
T = total votes
S = starter votes
R = reserve votes

1907 National League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

NL PITCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Mordecai Brown**    Chicago       11   7   4   3
Orval Overall*      Chicago        9   6   3   3
Christy Mathewson*  New York       6   6   0   6
Bob Ewing*          Cincinnati     5   5   0   5
Carl Lundgren*      Chicago        5   5   0   5
Tully Sparks*       Philadelphia   5   5   0   5
Jack Pfiester*      Chicago        3   3   0   3
Ed Karger*          St. Louis      3   3   0   3
Ed Reulbach*        Chicago        3   3   0   3
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Lefty Leifield      Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1
Nap Rucker          Brooklyn       1   1   0   1
Vic Willis          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1

NL CATCHERS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Johnny Kling**      Chicago       13   7   6   1
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       7   6   1   5
Larry McLean        Cincinnati     1   1   0   1

NL FIRST BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Tim Jordan**        Brooklyn       9   6   3   3
Frank Chance*       Chicago        9   6   3   3
Fred Tenney*        Boston         4   3   1   2
Dan McGann          New York       1   1   0   1

NL SECOND BASEMEN   TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ed Abbaticchio**    Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0
Otto Knabe*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0
Miller Huggins      Cincinnati     1   1   0   1
Whitey Alperman     Brooklyn       1   1   0   1

NL THIRD BASEMEN    TEAM           P   T   S   R
Dave Brain**        Boston        11   7   4   3
Art Devlin*         New York       7   5   2   3
Tommy Leach         Pittsburgh     2   1   1   0
Ernie Courtney      Philadelphia   1   1   0   1

NL SHORTSTOPS       TEAM           P   T   S   R
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0
Hans Lobert         Cincinnati     1   1   0   1

NL OUTFIELDERS      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Sherry Magee**      Philadelphia  14   7   7   0
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0
Ginger Beaumont**   Boston        12   7   5   2
Tommy Leach*        Pittsburgh     9   6   3   3
Cy Seymour*         New York       4   4   0   4
Harry Lumley*       Brooklyn       3   3   0   3
Mike Mitchell       Cincinnati     2   2   0   2
Spike Shannon       New York       1   1   0   1
Jimmy Sheckard      Chicago        1   1   0   1
Sammy Strang        New York       1   1   0   1

1907 National League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

NL PLAYERS          TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Honus Wagner**      Pittsburgh    14   7   7   0  SS
Sherry Magee**      Philadelphia  14   7   7   0  OF
Johnny Kling**      Chicago       13   7   6   1  C
Ginger Beaumont**   Boston        12   7   5   2  OF
Ed Abbaticchio**    Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0  2B
Fred Clarke**       Pittsburgh    12   6   6   0  OF
Mordecai Brown**    Chicago       11   7   4   3  P
Dave Brain**        Boston        11   7   4   3  3B
Tommy Leach*        Pittsburgh    11   7   4   3  OF
Orval Overall*      Chicago        9   6   3   3  P
Tim Jordan**        Brooklyn       9   6   3   3  1B
Frank Chance*       Chicago        9   6   3   3  1B
Roger Bresnahan*    New York       7   6   1   5  C
Art Devlin*         New York       7   5   2   3  3B
Christy Mathewson*  New York       6   6   0   6  P
Bob Ewing*          Cincinnati     5   5   0   5  P
Carl Lundgren*      Chicago        5   5   0   5  P
Tully Sparks*       Philadelphia   5   5   0   5  P
Otto Knabe*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  2B
Cy Seymour*         New York       4   4   0   4  OF
Fred Tenney*        Boston         4   3   1   2  1B
Jack Pfiester*      Chicago        3   3   0   3  P
Ed Karger*          St. Louis      3   3   0   3  P
Ed Reulbach*        Chicago        3   3   0   3  P
Harry Lumley*       Brooklyn       3   3   0   3  OF
Mike Mitchell       Cincinnati     2   2   0   2  OF
Johnny Evers        Chicago        2   1   1   0  2B
Sam Leever          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Lefty Leifield      Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Nap Rucker          Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  P
Vic Willis          Pittsburgh     1   1   0   1  P
Larry McLean        Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  C
Dan McGann          New York       1   1   0   1  1B
Miller Huggins      Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  2B
Whitey Alperman     Brooklyn       1   1   0   1  2B
Ernie Courtney      Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  3B
Hans Lobert         Cincinnati     1   1   0   1  SS
Spike Shannon       New York       1   1   0   1  OF
Jimmy Sheckard      Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF
Sammy Strang        New York       1   1   0   1  OF

1907 American League: Votes by Position

HTML Code:

AL PITCHERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ed Walsh**            Chicago        9   6   3   3
Addie Joss*           Cleveland      9   7   2   5
Cy Young*             Boston         6   6   0   6
Eddie Plank*          Philadelphia   5   4   1   3
Ed Killian*           Detroit        5   5   0   5
Doc White*            Chicago        5   5   0   5
Chief Bender*         Philadelphia   4   3   1   2
Bill Donovan*         Detroit        4   4   0   4
Rube Waddell*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4
Harry Howell          St. Louis      2   2   0   2
Jimmy Dygert          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1
Tom Hughes            Washington     1   1   0   1
Frank Smith           Chicago        1   1   0   1

AL CATCHERS           TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nig Clarke**          Cleveland     12   7   5   2
Ossee Schreckengost*  Philadelphia   8   6   2   4

AL FIRST BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Harry Davis**         Philadelphia  12   6   6   0
Hal Chase*            New York       3   3   0   3
John Anderson         Washington     2   1   1   0
Charlie Hickman       Washington     1   1   0   1

AL SECOND BASEMEN     TEAM           P   T   S   R
Nap Lajoie**          Cleveland     14   7   7   0
Jim Delahanty*        Washington     5   5   0   5
Jimmy Williams        New York       2   2   0   2

AL THIRD BASEMEN      TEAM           P   T   S   R
Jimmy Collins**       Philadelphia  11   6   5   1
Frank LaPorte         New York       3   2   1   1
Jim Delahanty         Washington     2   1   1   0
George Moriarty       New York       1   1   0   1

AL SHORTSTOPS         TEAM           P   T   S   R
Simon Nicholls**      Philadelphia   7   4   3   1
Bobby Wallace*        St. Louis      6   4   2   2
Kid Elberfeld*        New York       5   4   1   3
Dave Altizer*         Washington     5   4   1   3

AL OUTFIELDERS        TEAM           P   T   S   R
Ty Cobb**             Detroit       14   7   7   0
Sam Crawford**        Detroit       13   7   6   1
George Stone**        St. Louis     12   7   5   2
Elmer Flick*          Cleveland      9   6   3   3
Topsy Hartsel*        Philadelphia   6   6   0   6
Davy Jones            Detroit        2   2   0   2
Socks Seybold         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2
Otis Clymer           Washington     1   1   0   1
Bob Ganley            Washington     1   1   0   1
Fielder Jones         Chicago        1   1   0   1

1907 American League: Votes by Player

HTML Code:

AL PLAYERS            TEAM           P   T   S   R  POS
Nap Lajoie**          Cleveland     14   7   7   0  2B
Ty Cobb**             Detroit       14   7   7   0  OF
Sam Crawford**        Detroit       13   7   6   1  OF
Nig Clarke**          Cleveland     12   7   5   2  C
George Stone**        St. Louis     12   7   5   2  OF
Harry Davis**         Philadelphia  12   6   6   0  1B
Jimmy Collins**       Philadelphia  11   6   5   1  3B
Addie Joss*           Cleveland      9   7   2   5  P
Ed Walsh**            Chicago        9   6   3   3  P
Elmer Flick*          Cleveland      9   6   3   3  OF
Ossee Schreckengost*  Philadelphia   8   6   2   4  C
Jim Delahanty*        Washington     7   6   1   5  2B-3B
Simon Nicholls**      Philadelphia   7   4   3   1  SS
Cy Young*             Boston         6   6   0   6  P
Topsy Hartsel*        Philadelphia   6   6   0   6  OF
Bobby Wallace*        St. Louis      6   4   2   2  SS
Ed Killian*           Detroit        5   5   0   5  P
Doc White*            Chicago        5   5   0   5  P
Eddie Plank*          Philadelphia   5   4   1   3  P
Kid Elberfeld*        New York       5   4   1   3  SS
Dave Altizer*         Washington     5   4   1   3  SS
Bill Donovan*         Detroit        4   4   0   4  P
Rube Waddell*         Philadelphia   4   4   0   4  P
Chief Bender*         Philadelphia   4   3   1   2  P
Hal Chase*            New York       3   3   0   3  1B
Frank LaPorte         New York       3   2   1   1  3B
Harry Howell          St. Louis      2   2   0   2  P
Jimmy Williams        New York       2   2   0   2  2B
Davy Jones            Detroit        2   2   0   2  OF
Socks Seybold         Philadelphia   2   2   0   2  OF
John Anderson         Washington     2   1   1   0  1B
Jimmy Dygert          Philadelphia   1   1   0   1  P
Tom Hughes            Washington     1   1   0   1  P
Frank Smith           Chicago        1   1   0   1  P
Charlie Hickman       Washington     1   1   0   1  1B
George Moriarty       New York       1   1   0   1  3B
Otis Clymer           Washington     1   1   0   1  OF
Bob Ganley            Washington     1   1   0   1  OF
Fielder Jones         Chicago        1   1   0   1  OF

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All-Stars Per Team
T = total players
S = starting players
R = reserve players

HTML Code:

NL ALL-STARS  T  S  R   |   AL ALL-STARS  T  S  R
Chicago       7  2  5   |   Philadelphia  8  3  5
Pittsburgh    4  3  1   |   Cleveland     4  2  2
New York      4  0  4   |   Detroit       4  2  2
Boston        3  2  1   |   Chicago       2  1  1
Philadelphia  3  1  2   |   St. Louis     2  1  1
Brooklyn      2  1  1   |   New York      2  0  2
Cincinnati    1  0  1   |   Washington    2  0  2
St. Louis     1  0  1   |   Boston        1  0  1

Announcement

Retrospective All-Star Game Election Results

Retrospective All-Star Game Election Results

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Ad Widget