If you saw them play, who did you think was better? It's a limited question, since many didn't have the luxury of seeing many of these players' games. The idea is that if you followed baseball when they played, who did you think was better back then? Don't vote on who you think was better now, but who you thought was better back then.
This is the beginning of a series of polls on the subject. I am doing it this way because I want it in head-to-head matchups. There are no winners or losers, so the polls should stay open. I'll spread the threads out so the History Forum doesn't get clogged with them. And please, only those who followed baseball when they played should vote. I am ineligible for this poll, and I hope everyone else who isn't either will follow the honor system and not vote. I encourage anyone to participate in the discussion though.
This is the beginning of a series of polls on the subject. I am doing it this way because I want it in head-to-head matchups. There are no winners or losers, so the polls should stay open. I'll spread the threads out so the History Forum doesn't get clogged with them. And please, only those who followed baseball when they played should vote. I am ineligible for this poll, and I hope everyone else who isn't either will follow the honor system and not vote. I encourage anyone to participate in the discussion though.
Comment