Announcement

**PVNICK** · 08-09-2012, 07:55 AM

I think this is a little less complicated, at least for me. Marichal beats everyone on peak and is generally the highest ranked by career as well (only Perry might be rated higher by some).

**3and2Fastball** · 08-09-2012, 07:58 AM

Marichal, for now, but Lincecum & Cain have the potential to eventually be considered better. I like Cain's 0.00 postseason ERA

**9RoyHobbsRF** · 08-09-2012, 08:09 AM

Catfish Hunter had 5 straight 20 win seasons, was an excellent hitter and was the best pitcher on three world series champions

Vida Blue probably had the best individual year - 1971

Gaylord Perry won 300 games

Fingers and Eckersley were awesome as was Robb Nenn

Juan Marichal	100.00%	5 votes
Gaylord Perry	0.00%	0 votes
Mike McCormick	0.00%	0 votes
Catfish Hunter	0.00%	0 votes
Vida Blue	0.00%	0 votes
Rollie Fingers	0.00%	0 votes
Ken Holtzman	0.00%	0 votes
Mike Krukow	0.00%	0 votes
Bob Welch	0.00%	0 votes
Dennis Eckersley	0.00%	0 votes
Dave Stewart	0.00%	0 votes
Jason Schmidt	0.00%	0 votes
Mike Mulder	0.00%	0 votes
Tim Hudson	0.00%	0 votes
Barry Zito	0.00%	0 votes
Robb Nen	0.00%	0 votes
Matt Cain	0.00%	0 votes
Tim Lincecum	0.00%	0 votes
other - please name	0.00%	0 votes

Announcement

Greatest ML Pitcher in Bay Area ML History

Greatest ML Pitcher in Bay Area ML History

Comment

Comment

Comment

Ad Widget