had a weird thought. 1968 Bob Gibson was so off the chart and a desrving double Cy Young MVP.
Who would have been Cy Young if Gibson was eliminated from consideration? I am thinking you can't just look at WAR because WAR will have Gibson factored into the equation for that year.
so here are a few years/awards I would like thoughts and comments on:
NL: 1963 who wins Cy Young, who wins VP if Koufax is removed from the equation
- well I guess Cy Young would be for both leagues
AL: 1964 who wins Cy Young if Dean Chance is removed from consideration (both leagues thing again)
PLUS 1964 AL MVP - who wins MVP if Brooks Robinson is removed from consideration
1966 NL MVP - who wins if Clemente is removed from consideration
1966 CY YOUNG (both leages) who wins CY if Koufax is removed from consideration
1967 NL CY YOUNG - who wins if McCormick is removed from consideration
1968 NL CY YOUNG AND MVP (previously mentioned - no Gibson)
1969 NL CY YOUNG - no Seaver
1969 AL MVP - no Killebrew
1970 AL MVP - no Powell
1971 AL MVP - no Blue
1972 AL CY YOUNG - no Gaylord Perry
1972 NL CYYOUNG - no Steve Carlton
and any other years that interest someone
Who would have been Cy Young if Gibson was eliminated from consideration? I am thinking you can't just look at WAR because WAR will have Gibson factored into the equation for that year.
so here are a few years/awards I would like thoughts and comments on:
NL: 1963 who wins Cy Young, who wins VP if Koufax is removed from the equation
- well I guess Cy Young would be for both leagues
AL: 1964 who wins Cy Young if Dean Chance is removed from consideration (both leagues thing again)
PLUS 1964 AL MVP - who wins MVP if Brooks Robinson is removed from consideration
1966 NL MVP - who wins if Clemente is removed from consideration
1966 CY YOUNG (both leages) who wins CY if Koufax is removed from consideration
1967 NL CY YOUNG - who wins if McCormick is removed from consideration
1968 NL CY YOUNG AND MVP (previously mentioned - no Gibson)
1969 NL CY YOUNG - no Seaver
1969 AL MVP - no Killebrew
1970 AL MVP - no Powell
1971 AL MVP - no Blue
1972 AL CY YOUNG - no Gaylord Perry
1972 NL CYYOUNG - no Steve Carlton
and any other years that interest someone
Comment