An outlaw league was nothing to baseball during this time. Though unheard of today (the last attempt was the Continental League of the 1960s), baseball had seen five leagues since 1876, two of which folded after a year. In those pre-Commissioner days, the leagues were quite independent of each other. Today the leagues are really just geographical conferences, but there was a time when American League affiliates almost never interacted with the National League and vice-versa. Hence McGraw’s refusal to play Boston in 1904. The interleague, “we’re all playing the same sport” mentality didn’t come into play until much later.
New leagues were always regarded by purists as: inferior, financially insecure, built solely on greed, or a combination of those. Players were discouraged from joining the Union Association of 1884 with threats of being blacklisted from their league, a hefty threat since the UA was predicted to collapse quickly. It did after one season. An result of early labor disputes, the 1890 Players’ League also lasted one season. Owners were too hesitant to fund the league’s exploits despite the prominent players it boasted from the National League. The 1901 American League was no different; the likes of McGraw believed it was a poor version of baseball only functioning because of its ransacking of the NL.
A Federal League consisting of eight more clubs followed suit. Stars like Tris Speaker, Ty Cobb, and Walter Johnson were tempted by lucrative offers. McGraw was offered a whopping 100,000 dollars to manage. These offers fell through, but others were enticed. Youngster Edd Roush fled from the White Sox for a 500 dollar increase. Eddie Plank and Three Finger Brown doubled their salaries. Chief Bender received an undetermined amount from Baltimore. At 12,000 a year, Joe Tinker nabbed a managing position for the Chi-Feds.
The raids of talent continued in the 1913 offseason. However, the FL had yet to secure respect. Picking up Matty would do just that. Speculation of his thoughts ran wild even though Matty never voiced the urge to ditch New York. Age and overused took their toll, but diehard Giants fans believed the tired Matty wouldn’t jump for the sake of money, at least not now. It wouldn’t have been unreasonable for him to secure a spot in the future, perhaps in five or so years. The Federal League disbanded well before that time.
Matty stuck to the New York, a place he’d grown almost as fond of his hometown Factoryville. Besides, he was already making 12,000 a year for a team destined for a fourth straight pennant. In July, this looked to be the case for the first-place Giants, a sight becoming as usual as McGraw’s on-field tantrums. Shortly after, the Giants’ pitching toppled over. Matty retained a steady workload at a fatigued pace. Drawing a walk was still out of the question, but batters were beginning to throttle his failing fastball. Throwing past the first few innings became more difficult than ever. Matty tried to compensate by pitching to contact, a tact that worked in younger years when the pitches zipped quicker. A sterling 24-13 record didn’t reflect the pounding he took in 312 innings: a 3.00 ERA and league-leading 104 ER and 16 homers.
Staff deficiences by Marquard (12 straight losses after a 21-inning bout against Pittsburgh) as well as Al Demaree caused the Giants to drop the pennant as they were running with it. The Miracle Braves took it instead. On the bright side, an 84-70 record proved the strength of New York. A pennant can’t be won every year.
Then again, most of the losses came after July. If there were ever any stubborn doubts against Matty’s decline, there weren’t anymore.
New leagues were always regarded by purists as: inferior, financially insecure, built solely on greed, or a combination of those. Players were discouraged from joining the Union Association of 1884 with threats of being blacklisted from their league, a hefty threat since the UA was predicted to collapse quickly. It did after one season. An result of early labor disputes, the 1890 Players’ League also lasted one season. Owners were too hesitant to fund the league’s exploits despite the prominent players it boasted from the National League. The 1901 American League was no different; the likes of McGraw believed it was a poor version of baseball only functioning because of its ransacking of the NL.
A Federal League consisting of eight more clubs followed suit. Stars like Tris Speaker, Ty Cobb, and Walter Johnson were tempted by lucrative offers. McGraw was offered a whopping 100,000 dollars to manage. These offers fell through, but others were enticed. Youngster Edd Roush fled from the White Sox for a 500 dollar increase. Eddie Plank and Three Finger Brown doubled their salaries. Chief Bender received an undetermined amount from Baltimore. At 12,000 a year, Joe Tinker nabbed a managing position for the Chi-Feds.
The raids of talent continued in the 1913 offseason. However, the FL had yet to secure respect. Picking up Matty would do just that. Speculation of his thoughts ran wild even though Matty never voiced the urge to ditch New York. Age and overused took their toll, but diehard Giants fans believed the tired Matty wouldn’t jump for the sake of money, at least not now. It wouldn’t have been unreasonable for him to secure a spot in the future, perhaps in five or so years. The Federal League disbanded well before that time.
Matty stuck to the New York, a place he’d grown almost as fond of his hometown Factoryville. Besides, he was already making 12,000 a year for a team destined for a fourth straight pennant. In July, this looked to be the case for the first-place Giants, a sight becoming as usual as McGraw’s on-field tantrums. Shortly after, the Giants’ pitching toppled over. Matty retained a steady workload at a fatigued pace. Drawing a walk was still out of the question, but batters were beginning to throttle his failing fastball. Throwing past the first few innings became more difficult than ever. Matty tried to compensate by pitching to contact, a tact that worked in younger years when the pitches zipped quicker. A sterling 24-13 record didn’t reflect the pounding he took in 312 innings: a 3.00 ERA and league-leading 104 ER and 16 homers.
Staff deficiences by Marquard (12 straight losses after a 21-inning bout against Pittsburgh) as well as Al Demaree caused the Giants to drop the pennant as they were running with it. The Miracle Braves took it instead. On the bright side, an 84-70 record proved the strength of New York. A pennant can’t be won every year.
Then again, most of the losses came after July. If there were ever any stubborn doubts against Matty’s decline, there weren’t anymore.
Comment