Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Study of all 1920's and 1930's Starting Outfielders

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Study of all 1920's and 1930's Starting Outfielders

    Go to post #3 for tons of links to individual players.



    This project began when I was trying to determine my own Hall of Fame. There were a lot of 1920's-1930's outfielders in the HOF and I was trying to draw my line for what I thought a 1920's-1930's outfielder should achieve to be in my HOF. I came to a sad conclusion that I didn't have enough information and would have to start digging way deeper. In the end, I decided to take a look at all the starting outfielders from the 1920's and 1930's, all 16 teams for the 20 year span, a total of 960 player seasons.

    I've been working on it for at least 8 months. The first step was to collect the names, the second was to analyze data, and the third was to review first hand accounts (books, magazines, newspapers). The third step has been the hardest, as I've spent too much money on old books for a glimmer of some of these guys. To be honest, I'm only done fully with step one and am slowly progressing on steps two and three. However, the names alone present a lot of baseball history and may be of interest to some of you. I have a feeling this will be dragging along for years as I try to sort out the Harry Rice's from the Taylor Douthit's. Perhaps my short term goal will be to finally finish my HOF list if nothing else.

    I'll get started by listing the outfielders by their teams by year, then go to the yearly outfield grouping, then sort by years played in the 20 year era, and finish up with some preliminary thoughts and percentages.


    General notes:

    1) My primary interest is on regular everyday 1920's-1930's outfielders. In my own mind, I set this as 5 years as a regular - any less I think even a short term superstar (Sandy Koufax) wouldn't be able to make the HOF or my HOF. Sandy had 6, but I set it at 5 to be conservative.

    2) My nomenclature when you see split names like Lee King (Benny Kauff) is that I'd consider this a split season with King having more ABs but Kauff still having a lot of ABs to almost be considered a half regular. For tallying purposes, I give them each a half season as a regular.

    3) When you see a slash (/), that should mean there is a weird positional shift. The most famous is between Bob Muesel and Babe Ruth who shared left and right field duties. They'd get credit for a half season in each, but would add up to a full season for each.

    4) For all these lists, I've gone from left to center to right, in case my formatting still stinks. The info is good, presentation might not be.

    5) I was most concerned with getting the outfielders with most ABs in this study. I'm showing what I consider as the best representation of a team's outfield. In certain rare cases, there might be a not exact fit where I had to really squeeze someone in. Perhaps two outfielders played 90 games in right each and 15-30 in center. I had to list someone as the center fielder, so one guy was shown.

    6) I was pretty generous as what I considered a "regular". I'm sure there are some 350 PA guys listed as regulars when you might not think so. But if there is a team with a 350 PA guy in left, along with another at 150, 100, and 50, well, I'm considering the 350 PA guy the regular. However, if there is a 350 guy and a 250 guy, I tried to count those as partial players.

    7) There may have been some randome 225 PA person who should be considered a partial, but in the end the partial players who only had a cup of coffee weren't my primary goal. I'd estimate these lists are 98-99% correct at least for determining who was a regular and at what position.

    8) Note that teams that have gone through name changes are called by their most common name to aid me (Brooklyn Robins)

    9) I'll be making multiple posts, because I have a hard time myself tracking too long of a post.



    When done, I'd love any additional details you can provide on any of these players to be added to this thread. The HOFers are great, but miscellaneous information on Bruce Campbells, Rube Bresslers, and Eddie Browns is just as great.
    Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 11-10-2015, 05:10 PM.
    I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
    Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

    Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

    Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

  • #2

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
    Code:
    American League					
    					
    	Boston Red Sox				
    					
    	Left		Center		Right
    					
    1920	Mike Menosky		Tim Hendryx		Harry Hooper
    1921	Mike Menosky		Nemo Leibold		Shano Collins
    1922	Mike Menosky (Harris)		Nemo Leibold		Shano Collins
    1923	Joe Harris		Dick Reichle		Ira Flagstead
    1924	Bobby Veach		Ira Flagstead		Ike Boone
    1925	No regular		Ira Flagstead		Ike Boone
    1926	No regular		Ira Flagstead		Baby Doll Jacobsen
    1927	Wally Shaner		Ira Flagstead		Jack Tobin
    1928	Ken Williams		Ira Flagstead		Doug Taitt
    1929	Russ Scaritt		Jack Rothrock		Bill Barrett
    1930	Russ Scaritt		Tom Oliver		Earl Webb
    1931	Jack Rothrock		Tom Oliver		Earl Webb
    1932	Smead Jolley		Tom Oliver		Roy Johnson
    1933	Smead Jolley		Dusty Cooke		Roy Johnson
    1934	Roy Johnson		Reynolds(Solters)		Dick Porter
    1935	Roy Johnson		Mel Almada		Dusty Cooke
    1936	Heinie Manush		Doc Cramer		Almada/Cooke
    1937	Buster Mills		Doc Cramer		Ben Chapman
    1938	Joe Vosmik		Doc Cramer		Ben Chapman
    1939	Joe Vosmik		Doc Cramer		Ted Williams (!)
    					
    					
    	Chicago White Sox				
    					
    	Left		Center		Right
    					
    1920	Joe Jackson		Happy Felsch		Nemo Leibold
    1921	Bibb Falk		Amos Strunk		Harry Hooper
    1922	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Harry Hooper
    1923	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Harry Hooper
    1924	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Harry Hooper
    1925	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Harry Hooper
    1926	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Bill Barrett
    1927	Bibb Falk		Alex Metzler		Bill Barrett
    1928	Bibb Falk		Johnny Mostil		Metzler (Reynolds)
    1929	Alex Metzler		Dutch Hoffman		Carl Reynolds
    1930	No regular		Carl Reynolds		Smead Jolley
    1931	Lew Fonseca		Johnny Watwood		Carl Reynolds
    1932	Bob Fothergill		Liz Funk		Bob Seeds
    1933	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Evar Swanson
    1934	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Evar Swanson
    1935	Rip Radcliff		Al Simmons		Mule Haas
    1936	Rip Radcliff		Mike Kreevich		Mule Haas
    1937	Rip Radcliff		Mike Kreevich		Dixie Walker
    1938	Gee Walker		Mike Kreevich		Hank Steinbacher
    1939	Gee Walker		Mike Kreevich		Larry Rosenthal
    					
    					
    	Cleveland Indians				
    					
    	Left		Center		Right
    					
    1920	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Elmer Smith
    1921	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Elmer Smith
    1922	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Smoky Joe Wood
    1923	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Homer Summa
    1924	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Homer Summa
    1925	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Pat McNulty (Summa)
    1926	Charlie Jamieson		Tris Speaker		Homer Summa
    1927	Charlie Jamieson		Ike Eichrodt		Homer Summa
    1928	Charlie Jamieson		Sam Langford		Homer Summa
    1929	Charlie Jamieson		Earl Averill		Bibb Falk
    1930	Charlie Jamieson		Earl Averill		Dick Porter
    1931	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Dick Porter
    1932	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Dick Porter
    1933	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Dick Porter
    1934	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Sam Rice (Porter)
    1935	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Milt Galatzer (Campbell)
    1936	Joe Vosmik		Earl Averill		Roy Weatherly (Campbell)
    1937	Moose Solters		Earl Averill		Bruce Campbell
    1938	Jeff Heath		Earl Averill		Bruce Campbell
    1939	Jeff Heath		Ben Chapman		Bruce Campbell
    					
    					
    	Detroit Tigers				
    					
    	Left		Center		Right
    					
    1920	Bobby Veach		Ty Cobb		Chick Shorten
    1921	Bobby Veach		Ty Cobb		Harry Heilmann
    1922	Bobby Veach		Ty Cobb		Harry Heilmann
    1923	Veach (Manush)		Ty Cobb		Harry Heilmann
    1924	Heinie Manush		Ty Cobb		Harry Heilmann
    1925	Al Wingo		Ty Cobb (Manush)		Harry Heilmann
    1926	Bob Fothergill (Wingo)		Heinie Manush		Harry Heilmann
    1927	Bob Fothergill		Heinie Manush		Harry Heilmann
    1928	Bob Fothergill (Wingo)		Harry Rice		Harry Heilmann
    1929	Roy Johnson		Harry Rice		Harry Heilmann
    1930	John Stone		Liz Funk		Roy Johnson
    1931	John Stone		Hub Walker		Roy Johnson
    1932	John Stone		Gee Walker		Earl Webb
    1933	Gee Walker		Pete Fox		John Stone
    1934	Goose Goslin		Jo-Jo White (Walker)		Pete Fox
    1935	Goose Goslin		Jo-Jo White (Walker)		Pete Fox
    1936	Goose Goslin		Al Simmons		Gee Walker
    1937	Gee Walker		Jo-Jo White		Pete Fox
    1938	Dixie Walker		Chet Morgan		Pete Fox
    1939	Earl Averill		Bernie McCosky		Pete Fox
    Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 12-30-2014, 05:33 PM.
    I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
    Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

    Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

    Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

    Comment


    • #3
      Toledo Inquisition's master defensive rankings, along with other great posts by others here. If there are multiple links to a player, and if I've done my defensive review, it will be the first link.

      A while back, someone (Bluesky?) commented that all the old time outfielders are considered good defensive players by modern lovers of the old game. I don’t think so, and I’ve put a few thoughts down on the regular 1920’s/1930’s outfielders. Since I’ve not obviously seen them, my estimation is probably half based on statistics and the other half on contemporary reviews of their abilities. To make it quick, I’ve color coded their names for a quick visual inspection. I’ve used five colors as such:

      Purple – this was an elite defensive player – a true Gold Glover and defensive whiz
      Blue – a good defender who was noteworthy but not a legend
      Green – an average defensive player
      Orange – a below average defender with holes in his game
      Red – a bad defensive player who was a for sure liability


      One last thing – I’ve found numerous references to players not able to crack the starting lineup as the GM’s/managers didn’t like their gloves/arms, even if they could hit. These players will be listed. This is tough for me to prove, but in my estimation, defensive skill was more respected and important to the management of the time. That is not to say those defensive players were necessarily better, but that defensive butchers were less acceptable.



      Goslin, Goose - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...76#post2450376
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...99#post2511899
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...28#post2514528
      Ruth, Babe - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...65#post2454065
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...51#post2452951
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...15#post2491815
      Simmons, Al, aka Aloysius Harry Syzmanski - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...89#post2455589
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...97#post2460797
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...59#post2461459
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...52#post2490752
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...00#post2491800
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...16#post2493216
      Manush, Heinie - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...10#post2455610
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...12#post2455612
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...40#post2455640
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...83#post2500283
      Waner, Paul -
      Rice, Sam - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...67#post2529867
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...99#post2494399
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...44#post2495844
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...01#post2496701
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...11#post2496711
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...45#post2498345
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...59#post2498359
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...68#post2498368
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...81#post2502481
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...92#post2502592
      Waner, Lloyd -
      Cuyler, Kiki -
      West, Sam -
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...31#post2491331
      Averill, Earl - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...70#post2473570
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...10#post2491810
      Jamieson, Charlie - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...07#post2389507
      Klein, Chuck -
      Miller, Bing - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...19#post2389119
      Ott, Mel -
      Heilmann, Harry -
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...63#post2491563
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...66#post2491566
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...15#post2491815
      Meusel, Bob -
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...85#post2487185
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...83#post2500283
      Chapman, Ben -
      Combs, Earl - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...64#post2484864
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...43#post2484543
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...85#post2484585
      Falk, Bibb - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...65#post2454065
      Herman, Babe - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...76#post2452176
      Roush, Edd - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...15#post2480215
      Vosmik, Joe - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...68#post2450468
      Walker, Curt -
      Williams, Kenny -
      Berger, Wally -http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...04#post2479804
      Carey, Max -
      Haas, Mule - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...86#post2389686
      Hafey, Chick - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...68#post2480368
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...18#post2491118
      Williams, Cy -
      Wilson, Hack -
      Speaker, Tris -
      Stone, John -
      Cramer, Doc -
      Moore, Jo-Jo -
      Reynolds, Carl -
      Stephenson, Riggs - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...31#post2461431
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...59#post2461459
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...71#post2480371
      Campbell, Bruce -
      Jacobsen, Baby Doll - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...76#post2450376
      Johnson, Bob - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...89#post2454089
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...75#post2396075
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...90#post2484190
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...25#post2484225
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...37#post2484537
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...69#post2484569
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...87#post2484587
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...97#post2484597
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...36#post2522636
      Johnson, Roy -
      Medwick, Joe - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...45#post2389245
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...29#post2493229
      Meusel, Irish -
      Rice, Harry -
      Schulte, Fred -
      Walker, Gee - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...46#post2389546
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...86#post2389686
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...85#post2491885
      Wheat, Zack -
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...94#post2514594
      Youngs, Ross -
      Bressler, Rube - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...08#post2483108
      Cobb, Ty -http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...51#post2456851
      Douthit, Taylor -
      Leach, Freddy -
      Watkins, George - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...91#post2389491
      Allen, Ethan -
      Demaree, Frank -
      Flagstead, Ira -
      Fox, Pete -
      Hooper, Harry -
      Mostil, Johnny - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...39#post2460139
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...87#post2460187
      Tobin, Jack -
      Harper, George -
      Heathcote, Cliff -
      Porter, Dick -
      Smith, Jack -
      Southworth, Billy -
      Summa, Homer -
      Brown, Eddie -
      Burns, George -
      Duncan, Pat -
      Galan, Augie -
      Goodman, Ival -
      Griffith, Tommy -
      Lee, Hal -
      Leibold, Nemo -
      Moore, Johnny -
      Moses, Wally -
      O'Doul, Lefty - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...07#post2398107
      Welsh, Jimmy -
      Witt, Whitey, aka Ladislaw Waldemar Wittkowski - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...49#post2509749
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...41#post2491841
      McHenry, Austin - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...36#post2388536
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...42#post2388542
      Moore, Terry -
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...31#post2490531
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...55#post2490555
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...98#post2490898
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...16#post2491116
      Bob Fothergill - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...61#post2491861
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...81#post2491881
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...13#post2493213
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...49#post2504549
      Smead Jolley http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...81#post2519381


      Good general information:

      Bill James ratings - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...24#post2487324
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...72#post2489172
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...34#post2489334
      Player shifts - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...94#post2489394
      OF comparisons - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...83#post2490783
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...82#post2491182
      Five Star Article http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...44#post2491544
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...00#post2491800
      World Series OF assists - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...60#post2491360
      1934 Japanese Barnstorming - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...23#post2493223
      Gas House Gang - http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...66#post2493466
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...51#post2494551
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...53#post2494553
      http://www.baseball-fever.com/showth...99#post2494599
      Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 01-22-2016, 05:38 PM.
      I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
      Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

      Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

      Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

      Comment


      • #4
        American League New York to Washington

        Code:
        	New York Yankees				
        					
        	Left		Center		Right
        					
        1920	Duffy Lewis		Ping Bodie		Babe Ruth
        1921	Babe Ruth		No regular		Bob Meusel
        1922	Babe Ruth		Whitey Witt		Bob Meusel
        1923	Bob Muesel		Whitey Witt		Babe Ruth
        1924	Bob Muesel		Whitey Witt		Babe Ruth
        1925	Bob Muesel		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1926	Muesel/Ruth		Earle Combs		Muesel/Ruth
        1927	Bob Muesel		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1928	Bob Muesel		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1929	Bob Muesel		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1930	Earl Combs		Harry Rice		Babe Ruth
        1931	Ben Chapman		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1932	Ben Chapman		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1933	Ben Chapman		Earle Combs		Babe Ruth
        1934	No regular		Ben Chapman		Babe Ruth
        1935	Jesse Hill		Ben Chapman		George Selkirk
        1936	Joe DiMaggio		Jake Powell		George Selkirk
        1937	Jake Powell		Joe DiMaggio		Myril Hoag (Selkirk)
        1938	George Selkirk		Joe DiMaggio		Tommy Henrich
        1939	George Selkirk		Joe DiMaggio		Charlie Keller (Henrich)
        					
        					
        	Philadelphia A's				
        					
        	Left		Center		Right
        					
        1920	Tillie Walker		Frank Welch		Whitey Witt
        1921	Tillie Walker		Frank Welch		Whitey Witt
        1922	Tillie Walker		Bing Miller		Frank Welch
        1923	Bing Miller		Wid Mathews		Frank Welch
        1924	Bill Lamar		Al Simmons		Bing Miller (Welch)
        1925	Bill Lamar		Al Simmons		Bing Miller
        1926	Bill Lamar		Al Simmons		Walt French
        1927	Bill Lamar		Al Simmons		Ty Cobb (French)
        1928	Al Simmons		Haas (Miller)		Cobb (Miller)
        1929	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Bing Miller
        1930	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Bing Miller
        1931	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Bing Miller
        1932	Al Simmons		Mule Haas		Bing Miller (Cramer)
        1933	Bob Johnson		Doc Cramer		Ed Coleman
        1934	Bob Johnson		Doc Cramer		Ed Coleman
        1935	Bob Johnson		Doc Cramer		Wally Moses
        1936	Bob Johnson		Wally Moses		George Puccinelli
        1937	Bob Johnson		Jesse Hill		Wally Moses
        1938	Sam Chapman		Bob Johnson		Wally Moses
        1939	Bob Johnson		Sam Chapman		Wally Moses
        					
        					
        	St. Louis Browns				
        					
        	Left		Center		Right
        					
        1920	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen	  Jack Tobin
        1921	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen	  Jack Tobin
        1922	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen	    Jack Tobin
        1923	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen   Jack Tobin
        1924	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen	   Jack Tobin
        1925	Ken Williams		Baby Doll Jacobsen	     Harry Rice
        1926	Ken Williams		Rice/Miller		Rice/Miller
        1927	Ken Williams		Bing Miller		Harry Rice
        1928	Heinie Manush		Fred Schulte		Earl McNeely
        1929	Heinie Manush		Fred Schulte		Beauty McGowan
        1930	Goose Goslin		Fred Schulte		Ted Gullic
        1931	Goose Goslin		Fred Schulte		No regular
        1932	Goose Goslin		Fred Schulte		Bruce Campbell
        1933	Carl Reynolds		Sam West		Bruce Campbell
        1934	Ray Pepper		Sam West		Bruce Campbell
        1935	Moose Solters		Sam West		Ed Coleman
        1936	Moose Solters		Sam West		Beau Bell
        1937	Joe Vosmik		Sam West		Beau Bell
        1938	Buster Mills		Mel Almada		Beau Bell
        1939	Joe Gallagher		Chet Laabs		Myril Hoag
        					
        					
        	Washington Senators				
        					
        	Left		Center		Right
        					
        1920	Clyde Millan		Sam Rice		Braggo Roth
        1921	Bing Miller		Sam Rice		Clyde Millan
        1922	Goose Goslin		Sam Rice		Frank Brower
        1923	Goose Goslin		Nemo Leibold		Sam Rice
        1924	Goose Goslin		Nemo Leibold		Sam Rice
        1925	Goose Goslin		Earl McNeely		Sam Rice
        1926	Goslin/McNeely		McNeely/Goslin		Sam Rice
        1927	Goose Goslin		Tris Speaker		Sam Rice
        1928	Goose Goslin		Sam West		Sam Rice
        1929	Goose Goslin		Sam West		Sam Rice
        1930	Heinie Manush		Sam West		Sam Rice
        1931	Heinie Manush		Sam West		Sam Rice
        1932	Heinie Manush		Sam West		Carl Reynolds (Rice)
        1933	Heinie Manush		Fred Schulte		Goose Goslin
        1934	Heinie Manush		Fred Schulte		John Stone
        1935	Heinie Manush		Jake Powell		John Stone
        1936	John Stone		Ben Chapman		Carl Reynolds 
        1937	Al Simmons		Mel Almada		John Stone
        1938	Al Simmons		Sam West		George Case
        1939	Bobby Estalella		George Case (West)	Taffy Wright


        I have no idea why I can't get the Jack Tobin lines to line up, but mostly easy to read.
        Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 12-31-2014, 07:06 AM.
        I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
        Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

        Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

        Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

        Comment


        • #5
          National League Brooklyn to Cincinnati


          Code:
          Brooklyn Dodgers				
          					
          	Left		Center		Right
          					
          1920	Zack Wheat		Hi Myers		Tommy Griffith
          1921	Zack Wheat		Hi Myers		Tommy Griffith
          1922	Zack Wheat		Hi Myers		Tommy Griffith
          1923	Zack Wheat		Bernie Neis (Gene Bailey)		Tommy Griffith
          1924	Zack Wheat		Eddie Brown		Tommy Griffith
          1925	Zack Wheat		Eddie Brown		Dick Cox
          1926	Zack Wheat		Gus Felix		Dick Cox
          1927	Gus Felix		Jigger Statz		Max Carey
          1928	Rube Bressler		Max Carey		Babe Herman
          1929	Rube Bressler		Johnny Frederick		Babe Herman
          1930	Rube Bressler		Johnny Frederick		Babe Herman
          1931	Lefty O'Doul		Johnny Frederick		Babe Herman
          1932	Lefty O'Doul		Danny Taylor (Frederick)		Hack Wilson
          1933	Hack Wilson (Buzz Boyle)		Danny Taylor		Johnny Frederick
          1934	Danny Taylor		Len Koenecke		Buzz Boyle
          1935	Danny Taylor		Koenecke (Frenchy Bordagaray)		Buzz Boyle
          1936	George Watkins		Johnny Cooney		French Bordagaray
          1937	Tom Winsett		Johnny Cooney(Gibby Brack)		Heinie Manush
          1938	Buddy Hassett		Ernie Koy		Goody Rosen
          1939	Ernie Koy		No regular		Gene Moore
          					
          					
          	Chicago Cubs				
          					
          	Left		Center		Right
          					
          1920	Dave Robertson		Dode Paskert		Max Flack
          1921	Turner Barber		George Maisel		Max Flack
          1922	Hack Miller		Jigger Statz		Bernie Friberg (Heathcote)
          1923	Hack Miller		Jigger Statz		Cliff Heathcote
          1924	Denver Grigsby		Jigger Statz		Cliff Heathcote
          1925	Art Jahn		Mandy Brooks		Cliff Heathcote
          1926	Riggs Stephenson		Hack Wilson		Cliff Heathcote
          1927	Riggs Stephenson		Hack Wilson		Earl Webb
          1928	Riggs Stephenson		Hack Wilson		Kiki Cuyler
          1929	Riggs Stephenson		Hack Wilson		Kiki Cuyler
          1930	Riggs Stephenson		Hack Wilson		Kiki Cuyler
          1931	Stephenson (Danny Taylor)		Hack Wilson		Kiki Cuyler
          1932	Riggs Stephenson		Johnny Moore		Kiki Cuyler
          1933	Riggs Stephenson		Frank Demaree		Babe Herman
          1934	Chuck Klein		Kiki Cuyler		Babe Herman
          1935	Augie Galan		Frank Demaree		Chuck Klein
          1936	Ethan Allen		Augie Galan		Frank Demaree
          1937	Augie Galan		Joe Marty		Frank Demaree
          1938	Augie Galan		Carl Reynolds		Frank Demaree
          1939	Augie Galan		Hank Leiber		Jim Gleeson
          					
          					
          	Cincinnati Reds				
          					
          	Left		Center		Right
          					
          1920	Pat Duncan		Edd Roush		Greasy Neale
          1921	Pat Duncan		Edd Roush		Rube Bressler (Neale)
          1922	Pat Duncan		George Burns		George Harper
          1923	Pat Duncan		Edd Roush		George Burns
          1924	Pat Duncan		Edd Roush		Curt Walker (Burns)
          1925	Rube Bressler		Edd Roush		Curt Walker
          1926	Rube Bressler		Edd Roush		Curt Walker
          1927	Rube Bressler		Ethan Allen		Curt Walker
          1928	Billy Zitzman (Marty Callaghan)		Ethan Allen		Curt Walker
          1929	Evar Swanson		Ethan Allen		Curt Walker
          1930	Bob Meusel		Curt Walker		Harry Heilmann
          1931	Edd Roush		Taylor Douthit		Estel Crabtree
          1932	Wally Roettger(Chick Hafey)		Estel Crabtree (Douthit)		Babe Herman
          1933	Johnny Moore		Chick Hafey		Harry Rice
          1934	Harlin Pool		Chick Hafey		Adam Comorsky
          1935	Babe Herman		Samuel Byrd		Ival Goodman
          1936	Babe Herman		Kiki Cuyler		Ival Goodman
          1937	No regular		Kiki Cuyler		Ival Goodman
          1938	Wally Berger		Harry Craft		Ival Goodman
          1939	Wally Berger (Lee Gamble)		Harry Craft		Ival Goodman


          Sigh, back to trash.
          Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 12-31-2014, 07:18 AM.
          I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
          Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

          Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

          Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

          Comment


          • #6
            National League New York to St. Louis


            Code:
            New York Giants				
            					
            	Left		Center		Right
            					
            1920	George Burns		Lee King (Benny Kauff)		Ross Youngs
            1921	Irish Meusel 		George Burns		Ross Youngs
            1922	Irish Meusel		Casey Stengel (B. Cunningham)		Ross Youngs
            1923	Irish Meusel		Bill Cunningham (C. Stengel)		Ross Youngs
            1924	Irish Meusel		Hack Wilson		Ross Youngs
            1925	Irish Meusel		Billy Southworth		Ross Youngs
            1926	Irish Meusel		Ty Tyson		Ross Youngs
            1927	No regular		Edd Roush		George Harper
            1928	Lefty O'Doul		Jimmy Welsh		Mel Ott
            1929	Freddy Leach		Edd Roush		Mel Ott
            1930	Freddy Leach		Wally Roettger		Mel Ott
            1931	Freddy Leach		Chick Fullis		Mel Ott
            1932	Jo-Jo Moore(Chick Fullis)		Freddie Linsdstrom		Mel Ott
            1933	Jo-Jo Moore		Kiddo Davis		Mel Ott
            1934	Jo-Jo Moore		George Watkins (Hank Leiber)		Mel Ott
            1935	Jo-Jo Moore		Hank Leiber		Mel Ott
            1936	Jo-Jo Moore		Hank Leiber (Jimmy Ripple)		Mel Ott
            1937	Jo-Jo Moore		Jimmy Ripple		Mel Ott
            1938	Jo-Jo Moore		Hank Leiber		Jimmy Ripple
            1939	Jo-Jo Moore		Frank Demaree		Mel Ott
            					
            					
            	Philadelphia Phillies				
            					
            	Left		Center		Right
            					
            1920	Irish Meusel		Cy Williams		Casey Stengel
            1921	Irish Meusel		Cy Williams		Bevo LeBourveau
            1922	Cliff Lee		Cy Williams		Curt Walker
            1923	Johnny Mokan		Cy Williams		Curt Walker
            1924	Johnny Mokan		Cy Williams		George Harper
            1925	George Harper		Freddy Leach (George Burns)		Cy Williams
            1926	Johnny Mokan		Freddy Leach		Cy Williams
            1927	Dick Spalding		Freddy Leach		Cy Williams
            1928	Freddy Leach		Denny Sothern		Cy Williams (Chuck Klein)
            1929	Lefty O'Doul		Denny Sothern(Bernie Friberg)		Chuck Klein
            1930	Lefty O'Doul		Denny Sothern(Fred Brickell)		Chuck Klein
            1931	Chuck Klein		Fred Brickell		Buzz Arlett
            1932	Hal Lee		Kiddo Davis		Chuck Klein
            1933	Wes Schulmerich		Chick Fullis		Chuck Klein
            1934	Ethan Allen		Kiddo Davis		Johnny Moore
            1935	George Watkins		Ethan Allen		Johnny Moore
            1936	Johnny Moore		Ernie Sulik		Chuck Klein
            1937	Morrie Arnoivich		Hersh Martin		Chuck Klein
            1938	Morrie Arnoivich		Hersh Martin		Chuck Klein
            1939	Morrie Arnoivich		Hersh Martin		LeGrant Scott (Joe Marty)
            					
            					
            	Pittsburgh Pirates				
            					
            	Left		Center		Right
            					
            1920	Carson Bigbee		Max Carey		Billy Southworth
            1921	Carson Bigbee		Max Carey		Possum Whitted
            1922	Carson Bigbee		Max Carey		Clyde Barnhart (Reb Russel)
            1923	Carson Bigbee		Max Carey		Clyde Barnhart (Reb Russel)
            1924	Kiki Cuyler		Max Carey		Clyde Barnhart (Carson Bigbee)
            1925	Clyde Barnhart		Max Carey		Kiki Cuyler
            1926	Clyde Barnhart/Kiki Cuyler		Max Carey/Kiki Cuyler		Paul Waner
            1927	Clyde Barnhart (Kiki Cuyler)		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1928	No regular		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1929	Adam Comorosky		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1930	Adam Comorosky		Lloyd Waner(Fred Brickell)		Paul Waner
            1931	Comorosky (Woody Jensen)		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1932	Comorosky (Dave Barbee)		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1933	Lloyd Waner		Freddie Lindstrom		Paul Waner
            1934	Freddie Lindstrom		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1935	Woody Jensen		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1936	Woody Jensen		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1937	Woody Jensen		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1938	Johnny Rizzo		Lloyd Waner		Paul Waner
            1939	Johnny Rizzo(Chuck Klein)		Lloyd Waner(Fern Bell)		Paul Waner
            					
            					
            	St. Louis Cardinals				
            					
            	Left		Center		Right
            					
            1920	Austin McHenry		Cliff Heathcote		Jack Smith/Joe Schultz
            1921	Austin McHenry		Les Mann (Joe Schultz)		Jack Smith
            1922	Austin McHenry (Joe Schultz)		Jack Smith		Joe Schultz (Max Flack)
            1923	Jack Smith/Ray Blades		Hi Myers/Jack Smith		Max Flack
            1924	Ray Blades		Wattie Holm (Max Flack)		Jack Smith
            1925	Ray Blades		No regular		Chick Hafey
            1926	Ray Blades		Taylor Douthit		Billy Southworth
            1927	Chick Hafey		Taylor Douthit		Wattie Holm
            1928	Chick Hafey		Taylor Douthit		George Harper (Wally Roettger)
            1929	Chick Hafey		Taylor Douthit		Ernie Orsatti
            1930	Chick Hafey		Taylor Douthit		George Watkins
            1931	Chick Hafey		Pepper Martin		George Watkins
            1932	Ernie Orsatti		Pepper Martin		George Watkins
            1933	Joe Medwick		Ernie Orsatti		George Watkins
            1934	Joe Medwick		Ernie Orsatti		Jack Rothrock
            1935	Joe Medwick		Terry Moore		Jack Rothrock
            1936	Joe Medwick		Terry Moore		Pepper Martin
            1937	Joe Medwick		Terry Moore		Don Padgett
            1938	Joe Medwick		Terry Moore (Pepper Martin)		Enos Slaughter
            1939	Joe Medwick		Terry Moore		Enos Slaughter
            I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
            Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

            Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

            Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

            Comment


            • #7
              Yearly 1920-1924


              Code:
              1920		Left	Center	Right
              				
              1920	Boston Red Sox	Mike Menosky	Tim Hendryx	Harry Hooper
              1920	Chicago White Sox	Joe Jackson	Happy Felsch	Nemo Leibold
              1920	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Elmer Smith
              1920	Detroit Tigers	Bobby Veach	Ty Cobb	Chick Shorten
              1920	New York Yankees	Duffy Lewis	Ping Bodie	Babe Ruth
              1920	Philadelphia A's	Tillie Walker	Frank Welch	Whitey Witt
              1920	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Jack Tobin
              1920	Washington Senators	Clyde Millan	Sam Rice	Braggo Roth
              1920	Boston Braves	Les Mann	Ray Powell	Walton Cruise (John Sullivan)
              1920	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Hi Myers	Tommy Griffith
              1920	Chicago Cubs	Dave Robertson	Dode Paskert	Max Flack
              1920	Cincinnati Reds	Pat Duncan	Edd Roush	Greasy Neale
              1920	New York Giants	George Burns	Lee King (Benny Kauff)	Ross Youngs
              1920	Philadelphia Phillies	Irish Meusel	Cy Williams	Casey Stengel
              1920	Pittsburgh Pirates	Carson Bigbee	Max Carey	Billy Southworth
              1920	St. Louis Cardinals	Austin McHenry	Cliff Heathcote	Jack Smith/Joe Schultz
              				
              				
              				
              1921	Boston Red Sox	Mike Menosky	Nemo Leibold	Shano Collins
              1921	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Amos Strunk	Harry Hooper
              1921	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Elmer Smith
              1921	Detroit Tigers	Bobby Veach	Ty Cobb	Harry Heilmann
              1921	New York Yankees	Babe Ruth	No regular	Bob Meusel
              1921	Philadelphia A's	Tillie Walker	Frank Welch	Whitey Witt
              1921	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Jack Tobin
              1921	Washington Senators	Bing Miller	Sam Rice	Clyde Millan
              1921	Boston Braves	Walton Cruise	Ray Powell	Billy Southworth
              1921	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Hi Myers	Tommy Griffith
              1921	Chicago Cubs	Turner Barber	George Maisel	Max Flack
              1921	Cincinnati Reds	Pat Duncan	Edd Roush	Rube Bressler (Neale)
              1921	New York Giants	Irish Meusel (Curt Walker)	George Burns	Ross Youngs
              1921	Philadelphia Phillies	Irish Meusel	Cy Williams	Bevo LeBourveau
              1921	Pittsburgh Pirates	Carson Bigbee	Max Carey	Possum Whitted
              1921	St. Louis Cardinals	Austin McHenry	Les Mann (Joe Schultz)	Jack Smith
              				
              				
              				
              1922	Boston Red Sox	Mike Menosky (Harris)	Nemo Leibold	Shano Collins
              1922	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Harry Hooper
              1922	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Smoky Joe Wood
              1922	Detroit Tigers	Bobby Veach	Ty Cobb	Harry Heilmann
              1922	New York Yankees	Babe Ruth	Whitey Witt	Bob Meusel
              1922	Philadelphia A's	Tillie Walker	Bing Miller	Frank Welch
              1922	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Jack Tobin
              1922	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Sam Rice	Frank Brower
              1922	Boston Braves	Al Nixon 	Ray Powell	Cruise (Southworth)
              1922	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Hi Myers	Tommy Griffith
              1922	Chicago Cubs	Hack Miller	Jigger Statz	Bernie Friberg (Heathcote)
              1922	Cincinnati Reds	Pat Duncan	George Burns	George Harper
              1922	New York Giants	Irish Meusel	Casey Stengel (B. Cunningham)	Ross Youngs
              1922	Philadelphia Phillies	Cliff Lee	Cy Williams	Curt Walker
              1922	Pittsburgh Pirates	Carson Bigbee	Max Carey	Clyde Barnhart (Reb Russel)
              1922	St. Louis Cardinals	Austin McHenry (Joe Schultz)	Jack Smith	Joe Schultz (Max Flack)
              				
              				
              				
              1923	Boston Red Sox	Joe Harris	Dick Reichle	Ira Flagstead
              1923	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Harry Hooper
              1923	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Homer Summa
              1923	Detroit Tigers	Veach (Manush)	Ty Cobb	Harry Heilmann
              1923	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Whitey Witt	Babe Ruth
              1923	Philadelphia A's	Bing Miller	Wid Mathews	Frank Welch
              1923	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Jack Tobin
              1923	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Nemo Leibold	Sam Rice
              1923	Boston Braves	Gus Felix	Ray Powell (Nixon)	Billy Southworth
              1923	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Bernie Neis (Gene Bailey)	Tommy Griffith
              1923	Chicago Cubs	Hack Miller	Jigger Statz	Cliff Heathcote
              1923	Cincinnati Reds	Pat Duncan	Edd Roush	George Burns
              1923	New York Giants	Irish Meusel	Bill Cunningham (C. Stengel)	Ross Youngs
              1923	Philadelphia Phillies	Johnny Mokan	Cy Williams	Curt Walker
              1923	Pittsburgh Pirates	Carson Bigbee	Max Carey	Clyde Barnhart (Reb Russel)
              1923	St. Louis Cardinals	Jack Smith/Ray Blades	Hi Myers/Jack Smith	Max Flack
              				
              				
              				
              1924	Boston Red Sox	Bobby Veach	Ira Flagstead	Ike Boone
              1924	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Harry Hooper
              1924	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Homer Summa
              1924	Detroit Tigers	Heinie Manush	Ty Cobb	Harry Heilmann
              1924	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Whitey Witt	Babe Ruth
              1924	Philadelphia A's	Bill Lamar	Al Simmons	Bing Miller (Welch)
              1924	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Jack Tobin
              1924	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Nemo Leibold	Sam Rice
              1924	Boston Braves	Bill Cunningham	No regular	Casey Stengal
              1924	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Eddie Brown	Tommy Griffith
              1924	Chicago Cubs	Denver Grigsby	Jigger Statz	Cliff Heathcote
              1924	Cincinnati Reds	Pat Duncan	Edd Roush	Curt Walker (Burns)
              1924	New York Giants	Irish Meusel	Hack Wilson	Ross Youngs
              1924	Philadelphia Phillies	Johnny Mokan	Cy Williams	George Harper
              1924	Pittsburgh Pirates	Kiki Cuyler	Max Carey	Clyde Barnhart (Carson Bigbee)
              1924	St. Louis Cardinals	Ray Blades	Wattie Holm (Max Flack)	Jack Smith
              I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
              Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

              Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

              Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

              Comment


              • #8
                1925-1929



                Code:
                1925	Boston Red Sox	No regular	Ira Flagstead	Ike Boone
                1925	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Harry Hooper
                1925	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Pat McNulty (Summa)
                1925	Detroit Tigers	Al Wingo	Ty Cobb (Manush)	Harry Heilmann
                1925	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                1925	Philadelphia A's	Bill Lamar	Al Simmons	Bing Miller
                1925	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Baby Doll Jacobsen	Harry Rice
                1925	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Earl McNeely	Sam Rice
                1925	Boston Braves	Dave Harris	Gus Felix	Jimmy Welsh
                1925	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Eddie Brown	Dick Cox
                1925	Chicago Cubs	Art Jahn	Mandy Brooks	Cliff Heathcote
                1925	Cincinnati Reds	Rube Bressler	Edd Roush	Curt Walker
                1925	New York Giants	Irish Meusel	Billy Southworth	Ross Youngs
                1925	Philadelphia Phillies	George Harper	Freddy Leach (George Burns)	Cy Williams
                1925	Pittsburgh Pirates	Clyde Barnhart	Max Carey	Kiki Cuyler
                1925	St. Louis Cardinals	Ray Blades	No regular	Chick Hafey
                				
                				
                				
                1926	Boston Red Sox	No regular	Ira Flagstead	Baby Doll Jacobsen
                1926	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Bill Barrett
                1926	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Tris Speaker	Homer Summa
                1926	Detroit Tigers	Bob Fothergill (Wingo)	Heinie Manush	Harry Heilmann
                1926	New York Yankees	Muesel/Ruth	Earle Combs	Muesel/Ruth
                1926	Philadelphia A's	Bill Lamar	Al Simmons	Walt French
                1926	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Rice/Miller	Rice/Miller
                1926	Washington Senators	Goslin/McNeely	McNeely/Goslin	Sam Rice
                1926	Boston Braves	Eddie Brown	Jack Smith	Jimmy Welsh
                1926	Brooklyn Dodgers	Zack Wheat	Gus Felix	Dick Cox
                1926	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Hack Wilson	Cliff Heathcote
                1926	Cincinnati Reds	Rube Bressler	Edd Roush	Curt Walker
                1926	New York Giants	Irish Meusel	Ty Tyson	Ross Youngs
                1926	Philadelphia Phillies	Johnny Mokan	Freddy Leach	Cy Williams
                1926	Pittsburgh Pirates	Clyde Barnhart/Kiki Cuyler	Max Carey/Kiki Cuyler	Paul Waner
                1926	St. Louis Cardinals	Ray Blades	Taylor Douthit	Billy Southworth
                				
                				
                				
                1927	Boston Red Sox	Wally Shaner	Ira Flagstead	Jack Tobin
                1927	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Alex Metzler	Bill Barrett
                1927	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Ike Eichrodt	Homer Summa
                1927	Detroit Tigers	Bob Fothergill	Heinie Manush	Harry Heilmann
                1927	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                1927	Philadelphia A's	Bill Lamar	Al Simmons	Ty Cobb (French)
                1927	St. Louis Browns	Ken Williams	Bing Miller	Harry Rice
                1927	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Tris Speaker	Sam Rice
                1927	Boston Braves	Eddie Brown	Jimmy Welsh	Lance Richbourg
                1927	Brooklyn Dodgers	Gus Felix	Jigger Statz	Max Carey
                1927	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Hack Wilson	Earl Webb
                1927	Cincinnati Reds	Rube Bressler	Ethan Allen	Curt Walker
                1927	New York Giants	No regular	Edd Roush	George Harper
                1927	Philadelphia Phillies	Dick Spalding	Freddy Leach	Cy Williams
                1927	Pittsburgh Pirates	Clyde Barnhart (Kiki Cuyler)	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                1927	St. Louis Cardinals	Chick Hafey	Taylor Douthit	Wattie Holm
                				
                				
                				
                1928	Boston Red Sox	Ken Williams	Ira Flagstead	Doug Taitt
                1928	Chicago White Sox	Bibb Falk	Johnny Mostil	Metzler (Reynolds)
                1928	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Sam Langford	Homer Summa
                1928	Detroit Tigers	Bob Fothergill (Wingo)	Harry Rice	Harry Heilmann
                1928	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                1928	Philadelphia A's	Al Simmons	Haas (Miller)	Cobb (Miller)
                1928	St. Louis Browns	Heinie Manush	Fred Schulte	Earl McNeely
                1928	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Sam West	Sam Rice
                1928	Boston Braves	Eddie Brown	No regular	Lance Richbourg
                1928	Brooklyn Dodgers	Rube Bressler	Max Carey	Babe Herman
                1928	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Hack Wilson	Kiki Cuyler
                1928	Cincinnati Reds	Billy Zitzman (Marty Callaghan)	Ethan Allen	Curt Walker
                1928	New York Giants	Lefty O'Doul	Jimmy Welsh	Mel Ott
                1928	Philadelphia Phillies	Freddy Leach	Denny Sothern	Cy Williams (Chuck Klein)
                1928	Pittsburgh Pirates	No regular	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                1928	St. Louis Cardinals	Chick Hafey	Taylor Douthit	George Harper (Wally Roettger)
                				
                				
                				
                1929	Boston Red Sox	Russ Scaritt	Jack Rothrock	Bill Barrett
                1929	Chicago White Sox	Alex Metzler	Dutch Hoffman	Carl Reynolds
                1929	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Earl Averill	Bibb Falk
                1929	Detroit Tigers	Roy Johnson	Harry Rice	Harry Heilmann
                1929	New York Yankees	Bob Muesel	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                1929	Philadelphia A's	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Bing Miller
                1929	St. Louis Browns	Heinie Manush	Fred Schulte	Beauty McGowan
                1929	Washington Senators	Goose Goslin	Sam West	Sam Rice
                1929	Boston Braves	George Harper	Earl Clark	Lance Richbourg
                1929	Brooklyn Dodgers	Rube Bressler	Johnny Frederick	Babe Herman
                1929	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Hack Wilson	Kiki Cuyler
                1929	Cincinnati Reds	Evar Swanson	Ethan Allen	Curt Walker
                1929	New York Giants	Freddy Leach	Edd Roush	Mel Ott
                1929	Philadelphia Phillies	Lefty O'Doul	Denny Sothern(Bernie Friberg)	Chuck Klein
                1929	Pittsburgh Pirates	Adam Comorosky	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                1929	St. Louis Cardinals	Chick Hafey	Taylor Douthit	Ernie Orsatti
                I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                Comment


                • #9
                  1930-1934




                  Code:
                  1930	Boston Red Sox	Russ Scaritt	Tom Oliver	Earl Webb
                  1930	Chicago White Sox	No regular	Carl Reynolds	Smead Jolley
                  1930	Cleveland Indians	Charlie Jamieson	Earl Averill	Dick Porter
                  1930	Detroit Tigers	John Stone	Liz Funk	Roy Johnson
                  1930	New York Yankees	Earl Combs	Harry Rice	Babe Ruth
                  1930	Philadelphia A's	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Bing Miller
                  1930	St. Louis Browns	Goose Goslin	Fred Schulte	Ted Gullic
                  1930	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Sam West	Sam Rice
                  1930	Boston Braves	Wally Berger	Jimmy Welsh	Lance Richbourg
                  1930	Brooklyn Dodgers	Rube Bressler	Johnny Frederick	Babe Herman
                  1930	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Hack Wilson	Kiki Cuyler
                  1930	Cincinnati Reds	Bob Meusel	Curt Walker	Harry Heilmann
                  1930	New York Giants	Freddy Leach	Wally Roettger	Mel Ott
                  1930	Philadelphia Phillies	Lefty O'Doul	Denny Sothern(Fred Brickell)	Chuck Klein
                  1930	Pittsburgh Pirates	Adam Comorosky	Lloyd Waner(Fred Brickell)	Paul Waner
                  1930	St. Louis Cardinals	Chick Hafey	Taylor Douthit	George Watkins
                  				
                  				
                  				
                  1931	Boston Red Sox	Jack Rothrock	Tom Oliver	Earl Webb
                  1931	Chicago White Sox	Lew Fonseca	Johnny Watwood	Carl Reynolds
                  1931	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Dick Porter
                  1931	Detroit Tigers	John Stone	Hub Walker	Roy Johnson
                  1931	New York Yankees	Ben Chapman	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                  1931	Philadelphia A's	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Bing Miller
                  1931	St. Louis Browns	Goose Goslin	Fred Schulte	No regular
                  1931	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Sam West	Sam Rice
                  1931	Boston Braves	Red Worthington	Wally Berger	Schulmerich (Richbourg)
                  1931	Brooklyn Dodgers	Lefty O'Doul	Johnny Frederick	Babe Herman
                  1931	Chicago Cubs	Stephenson (Danny Taylor)	Hack Wilson	Kiki Cuyler
                  1931	Cincinnati Reds	Edd Roush	Taylor Douthit	Estel Crabtree
                  1931	New York Giants	Freddy Leach	Chick Fullis	Mel Ott
                  1931	Philadelphia Phillies	Chuck Klein	Fred Brickell	Buzz Arlett
                  1931	Pittsburgh Pirates	Comorosky (Woody Jensen)	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                  1931	St. Louis Cardinals	Chick Hafey	Pepper Martin	George Watkins
                  				
                  				
                  				
                  1932	Boston Red Sox	Smead Jolley	Tom Oliver	Roy Johnson
                  1932	Chicago White Sox	Bob Fothergill	Liz Funk	Bob Seeds
                  1932	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Dick Porter
                  1932	Detroit Tigers	John Stone	Gee Walker	Earl Webb
                  1932	New York Yankees	Ben Chapman	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                  1932	Philadelphia A's	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Bing Miller (Cramer)
                  1932	St. Louis Browns	Goose Goslin	Fred Schulte	Bruce Campbell
                  1932	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Sam West	Carl Reynolds (Rice)
                  1932	Boston Braves	Red Worthington	Wally Berger	Wes Schulmerich
                  1932	Brooklyn Dodgers	Lefty O'Doul	Danny Taylor (Frederick)	Hack Wilson
                  1932	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Johnny Moore	Kiki Cuyler
                  1932	Cincinnati Reds	Wally Roettger(Chick Hafey)	Estel Crabtree (Douthit)	Babe Herman
                  1932	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore(Chick Fullis)	Freddie Linsdstrom	Mel Ott
                  1932	Philadelphia Phillies	Hal Lee	Kiddo Davis	Chuck Klein
                  1932	Pittsburgh Pirates	Comorosky (Dave Barbee)	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                  1932	St. Louis Cardinals	Ernie Orsatti	Pepper Martin	George Watkins
                  				
                  				
                  				
                  1933	Boston Red Sox	Smead Jolley	Dusty Cooke	Roy Johnson
                  1933	Chicago White Sox	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Evar Swanson
                  1933	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Dick Porter
                  1933	Detroit Tigers	Gee Walker	Pete Fox	John Stone
                  1933	New York Yankees	Ben Chapman	Earle Combs	Babe Ruth
                  1933	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Doc Cramer	Ed Coleman
                  1933	St. Louis Browns	Carl Reynolds	Sam West	Bruce Campbell
                  1933	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Fred Schulte	Goose Goslin
                  1933	Boston Braves	Hal Lee	Wally Berger	Randy Moore
                  1933	Brooklyn Dodgers	Hack Wilson (Buzz Boyle)	Danny Taylor	Johnny Frederick
                  1933	Chicago Cubs	Riggs Stephenson	Frank Demaree	Babe Herman
                  1933	Cincinnati Reds	Johnny Moore	Chick Hafey	Harry Rice
                  1933	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Kiddo Davis	Mel Ott
                  1933	Philadelphia Phillies	Wes Schulmerich	Chick Fullis	Chuck Klein
                  1933	Pittsburgh Pirates	Lloyd Waner	Freddie Lindstrom	Paul Waner
                  1933	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Ernie Orsatti	George Watkins
                  				
                  				
                  				
                  1934	Boston Red Sox	Roy Johnson	Reynolds(Solters)	Dick Porter
                  1934	Chicago White Sox	Al Simmons	Mule Haas	Evar Swanson
                  1934	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Sam Rice (Porter)
                  1934	Detroit Tigers	Goose Goslin	Jo-Jo White (Walker)	Pete Fox
                  1934	New York Yankees	No regular	Ben Chapman	Babe Ruth
                  1934	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Doc Cramer	Ed Coleman
                  1934	St. Louis Browns	Ray Pepper	Sam West	Bruce Campbell
                  1934	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Fred Schulte	John Stone
                  1934	Boston Braves	Hal Lee	Wally Berger	Tommy Thompson (R. Moore)
                  1934	Brooklyn Dodgers	Danny Taylor	Len Koenecke	Buzz Boyle
                  1934	Chicago Cubs	Chuck Klein	Kiki Cuyler	Babe Herman
                  1934	Cincinnati Reds	Harlin Pool	Chick Hafey	Adam Comorsky
                  1934	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	George Watkins (Hank Leiber)	Mel Ott
                  1934	Philadelphia Phillies	Ethan Allen	Kiddo Davis	Johnny Moore
                  1934	Pittsburgh Pirates	Freddie Lindstrom	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                  1934	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Ernie Orsatti	Jack Rothrock
                  I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                  Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                  Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                  Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    1935-1939



                    Code:
                    1935	Boston Red Sox	Roy Johnson	Mel Almada	Dusty Cooke
                    1935	Chicago White Sox	Rip Radcliff	Al Simmons	Mule Haas
                    1935	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Milt Galatzer (Campbell)
                    1935	Detroit Tigers	Goose Goslin	Jo-Jo White (Walker)	Pete Fox
                    1935	New York Yankees	Jesse Hill	Ben Chapman	George Selkirk
                    1935	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Doc Cramer	Wally Moses
                    1935	St. Louis Browns	Moose Solters	Sam West	Ed Coleman
                    1935	Washington Senators	Heinie Manush	Jake Powell	John Stone
                    1935	Boston Braves	Hal Lee	Wally Berger	Tommy Thompson (R. Moore)
                    1935	Brooklyn Dodgers	Danny Taylor	Koenecke (Frenchy Bordagaray)	Buzz Boyle
                    1935	Chicago Cubs	Augie Galan	Frank Demaree	Chuck Klein
                    1935	Cincinnati Reds	Babe Herman	Samuel Byrd	Ival Goodman
                    1935	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Hank Leiber	Mel Ott
                    1935	Philadelphia Phillies	George Watkins	Ethan Allen	Johnny Moore
                    1935	Pittsburgh Pirates	Woody Jensen	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                    1935	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Terry Moore	Jack Rothrock
                    				
                    				
                    				
                    1936	Boston Red Sox	Heinie Manush	Doc Cramer	Almada/Cooke
                    1936	Chicago White Sox	Rip Radcliff	Mike Kreevich	Mule Haas
                    1936	Cleveland Indians	Joe Vosmik	Earl Averill	Roy Weatherly (Campbell)
                    1936	Detroit Tigers	Goose Goslin	Al Simmons	Gee Walker
                    1936	New York Yankees	Joe DiMaggio	Jake Powell	George Selkirk
                    1936	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Wally Moses	George Puccinelli
                    1936	St. Louis Browns	Moose Solters	Sam West	Beau Bell
                    1936	Washington Senators	John Stone	Ben Chapman	Carl Reynolds 
                    1936	Boston Braves	Hal Lee	Wally Berger	Gene Moore
                    1936	Brooklyn Dodgers	George Watkins	Johnny Cooney	French Bordagaray
                    1936	Chicago Cubs	Ethan Allen	Augie Galan	Frank Demaree
                    1936	Cincinnati Reds	Babe Herman	Kiki Cuyler	Ival Goodman
                    1936	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Hank Leiber (Jimmy Ripple)	Mel Ott
                    1936	Philadelphia Phillies	Johnny Moore	Ernie Sulik	Chuck Klein
                    1936	Pittsburgh Pirates	Woody Jensen	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                    1936	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Terry Moore	Pepper Martin
                    				
                    				
                    				
                    1937	Boston Red Sox	Buster Mills	Doc Cramer	Ben Chapman
                    1937	Chicago White Sox	Rip Radcliff	Mike Kreevich	Dixie Walker
                    1937	Cleveland Indians	Moose Solters	Earl Averill	Bruce Campbell
                    1937	Detroit Tigers	Gee Walker	Jo-Jo White	Pete Fox
                    1937	New York Yankees	Jake Powell	Joe DiMaggio	Myril Hoag (Selkirk)
                    1937	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Jesse Hill	Wally Moses
                    1937	St. Louis Browns	Joe Vosmik	Sam West	Beau Bell
                    1937	Washington Senators	Al Simmons	Mel Almada	John Stone
                    1937	Boston Braves	Debs Garms	Vince DiMaggio	Gene Moore
                    1937	Brooklyn Dodgers	Tom Winsett	Johnny Cooney(Gibby Brack)	Heinie Manush
                    1937	Chicago Cubs	Augie Galan	Joe Marty	Frank Demaree
                    1937	Cincinnati Reds	No regular	Kiki Cuyler	Ival Goodman
                    1937	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Jimmy Ripple	Mel Ott
                    1937	Philadelphia Phillies	Morrie Arnoivich	Hersh Martin	Chuck Klein
                    1937	Pittsburgh Pirates	Woody Jensen	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                    1937	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Terry Moore	Don Padgett
                    				
                    				
                    				
                    1938	Boston Red Sox	Joe Vosmik	Doc Cramer	Ben Chapman
                    1938	Chicago White Sox	Gee Walker	Mike Kreevich	Hank Steinbacher
                    1938	Cleveland Indians	Jeff Heath	Earl Averill	Bruce Campbell
                    1938	Detroit Tigers	Dixie Walker	Chet Morgan	Pete Fox
                    1938	New York Yankees	George Selkirk	Joe DiMaggio	Tommy Henrich
                    1938	Philadelphia A's	Sam Chapman	Bob Johnson	Wally Moses
                    1938	St. Louis Browns	Buster Mills	Mel Almada	Beau Bell
                    1938	Washington Senators	Al Simmons	Sam West	George Case
                    1938	Boston Braves	Max West	Vince DiMaggio	Johnny Cooney
                    1938	Brooklyn Dodgers	Buddy Hassett	Ernie Koy	Goody Rosen
                    1938	Chicago Cubs	Augie Galan	Carl Reynolds	Frank Demaree
                    1938	Cincinnati Reds	Wally Berger	Harry Craft	Ival Goodman
                    1938	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Hank Leiber	Jimmy Ripple
                    1938	Philadelphia Phillies	Morrie Arnoivich	Hersh Martin	Chuck Klein
                    1938	Pittsburgh Pirates	Johnny Rizzo	Lloyd Waner	Paul Waner
                    1938	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Terry Moore (Pepper Martin)	Enos Slaughter
                    				
                    				
                    				
                    1939	Boston Red Sox	Joe Vosmik	Doc Cramer	Ted Williams (!)
                    1939	Chicago White Sox	Gee Walker	Mike Kreevich	Larry Rosenthal
                    1939	Cleveland Indians	Jeff Heath	Ben Chapman	Bruce Campbell
                    1939	Detroit Tigers	Earl Averill	Bernie McCosky	Pete Fox
                    1939	New York Yankees	George Selkirk	Joe DiMaggio	Charlie Keller (Henrich)
                    1939	Philadelphia A's	Bob Johnson	Sam Chapman	Wally Moses
                    1939	St. Louis Browns	Joe Gallagher	Chet Laabs	Myril Hoag
                    1939	Washington Senators	Bobby Estalella	George Case (West)	Taffy Wright
                    1939	Boston Braves	Max West	Johnny Cooney	Debs Garms
                    1939	Brooklyn Dodgers	Ernie Koy	No regular	Gene Moore
                    1939	Chicago Cubs	Augie Galan	Hank Leiber	Jim Gleeson
                    1939	Cincinnati Reds	Wally Berger (Lee Gamble)	Harry Craft	Ival Goodman
                    1939	New York Giants	Jo-Jo Moore	Frank Demaree	Mel Ott
                    1939	Philadelphia Phillies	Morrie Arnoivich	Hersh Martin	LeGrant Scott (Joe Marty)
                    1939	Pittsburgh Pirates	Johnny Rizzo(Chuck Klein)	Lloyd Waner(Fern Bell)	Paul Waner
                    1939	St. Louis Cardinals	Joe Medwick	Terry Moore	Enos Slaughter
                    I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                    Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                    Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                    Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      List of every outfielder who had at least a half a season as a regular from 1920-1939, with the number showing the number of seasons as a regular.




                      Code:
                      6	Allen, Ethan	
                      3.5	Almada, Mel	
                      1	Arlett, Buzz	
                      3	Arnoivich, Morrie	
                      11	Averill, Earl	
                      0.5	Bailey, Gene	
                      0.5	Barbee, Dave	
                      1	Barber, Turner	
                      3.5	Barnhart, Clyde	
                      3	Barrett, Bill	
                      3	Bell, Beau	
                      0.5	Bell, Fern	
                      8.5	Berger, Wally	
                      4.5	Bigbee, Carson	
                      3.5	Blades, Ray	
                      1	Bodie, Ping	
                      2	Boone, Ike	
                      1.5	Bordogaray, Frenchy	
                      2.5	Boyle, Buzz	
                      0.5	Brack, Gibby	
                      6.5	Bressler, Rube	
                      2	Brickell, Fred	
                      1	Brooks, Mandy	
                      1	Brower, Frank	
                      5	Brown, Eddie	
                      5	Burns, George	
                      1	Byrd, Samuel	
                      0.5	Callaghan, Marty	
                      7	Campbell, Bruce	
                      8.5	Carey, Max	
                      1.5	Case, George	
                      9	Chapman, Ben	
                      2	Chapman, Sam	
                      1	Clark, Earl	
                      6.5	Cobb, Ty	
                      3	Coleman, Ed	
                      2	Collins, Shano	
                      2.5	Cooke, Dusty	
                      9	Combs, Earl	
                      4	Comorosky, Adam	
                      3.5	Cooney, Johnny	
                      2	Cox, Dick	
                      1.5	Crabtree, Estel	
                      2	Craft, Harry	
                      7.5	Cramer, Doc	
                      2	Cruise, Walton	
                      2	Cunningham, Bill	
                      11.5	Cuyler, Kiki	
                      3	Davis, Kiddo	
                      6	Demaree, Frank	
                      4	DiMaggio, Joe	
                      2	DiMaggio, Vince	
                      6.5	Douthit, Taylor	
                      5	Duncan, Pat	
                      1	Eichrodt, Ike	
                      1	Estalella, Bobby	
                      9	Falk, Bibb	
                      4	Felix, Gus	
                      1	Felsch, Happy	
                      4	Flack, Max	
                      6	Flagstead, Ira	
                      1	Fonseca, Lew	
                      3	Fothergill, Bob	
                      6	Fox, Pete	
                      4.5	Frederick, Johnny	
                      1.5	French, Walt	
                      1	Friberg, Bernie	
                      2.5	Fullis, Chick	
                      2	Funk, Liz	
                      5	Galan, Augie	
                      0.5	Galatzer, Milt	
                      1	Gallagher, Joe	
                      0.5	Gamble, Lee	
                      2	Garms, Debs	
                      1	Gleeson, Jim	
                      5	Goodman, Ival	
                      15	Goslin, Goose	
                      1	Grigsby, Denver	
                      5	Griffith, Tommy	
                      1	Gullic, Ted	
                      8.5	Haas, Mule	
                      8.5	Hafey, Chick	
                      5.5	Harper, George	
                      1	Harris, Dave	
                      1.5	Harris, Joe	
                      1	Hassett, Buddy	
                      2	Heath, Jeff	
                      5.5	Heathcote, Cliff	
                      10	Heilmann, Harry	
                      1	Hendryx, Tim	
                      1.5	Henrich,  Tommy	
                      9	Herman, Babe	
                      2	Hill, Jesse	
                      1.5	Hoag, Myril	
                      1	Hoffman, Dutch	
                      1.5	Holm, Wattie	
                      6	Hooper, Harry	
                      1	Jackson, Joe	
                      7	Jacobsen, Baby Doll	
                      1	Jahn, Art	
                      11	Jamieson, Charlie	
                      3.5	Jensen, Woody	
                      7	Johnson, Bob	
                      7	Johnson, Roy	
                      3	Jolley, Smead	
                      0.5	Kauff, Benny	
                      0.5	Keller, Charlie	
                      0.5	King, Lee	
                      11	Klein, Chuck	
                      1.5	Koenecke, Len	
                      2	Koy, Ernie	
                      4	Kreevich, Mike	
                      1	Laabs, Chet	
                      4	Lamar, Bill	
                      1	Langford, Sam	
                      6.5	Leach, Freddy	
                      1	LeBourveau, Bevo	
                      1	Lee, Cliff	
                      5	Lee, Hal	
                      4	Leiber, Hank	
                      5	Leibold, Nemo	
                      1	Lewis, Duffy	
                      3	Lindstrom, Freddie	
                      1	Maisel, George	
                      1.5	Mann, Les	
                      14	Manush, Heinie	
                      3	Martin, Hersh	
                      3.5	Martin, Pepper	
                      1.5	Marty, Joe	
                      1	Mathews, Wid	
                      1	McCosky, Bernie	
                      1	McGowan, Beauty	
                      2.5	McHenry, Austin	
                      3	McNeely, Earl	
                      0.5	McNulty, Pat	
                      7	Medwick, Joe	
                      2.5	Menosky, Mike	
                      2.5	Metzler, Alex	
                      10	Meusel, Bob	
                      7	Meusel, Irish	
                      2	Millan, Clyde	
                      11	Miller, Bing	
                      2	Miller, Hack	
                      2	Mills, Buster	
                      3	Mokan, Johnny	
                      3	Moore, Gene	
                      5	Moore, Johnny	
                      7.5	Moore, Jo-Jo	
                      2	Moore, Randy	
                      4.5	Moore, Terry	
                      1	Morgan, Chet	
                      5	Moses, Wally	
                      6	Mostil, Johnny	
                      3.5	Myers, Hi	
                      1.5	Neale, Greasy	
                      0.5	Neis, Bernie	
                      1.5	Nixon, Al	
                      5	O'Doul, Lefty	
                      3	Oliver, Tom	
                      4	Orsatti, Ernie	
                      11	Ott, Mel	
                      1	Padgett, Don	
                      1	Paskert, Dode	
                      1	Pepper, Ray	
                      1	Pool, Harlin	
                      5.5	Porter, Dick	
                      3	Powell, Jake	
                      3.5	Powell, Ray	
                      1	Puccinelli, George	
                      3	Radcliff, Rip	
                      1	Reichle, Dick	
                      7.5	Reynolds, Carl	
                      1.5	Rizzo, Johnny	
                      7	Rice, Harry	
                      13	Rice, Sam	
                      4.5	Richbourg, Lance	
                      2.5	Ripple, Jimmy	
                      1	Robertson, Dave	
                      2	Roettger, Wally	
                      1	Rosen, Goody	
                      1	Rosenthal, Larry	
                      1	Roth, Braggo	
                      4	Rothrock, Jack	
                      9	Roush, Edd	
                      1	Russel, Reb	
                      15	Ruth, Babe	
                      2	Scaritt, Russ	
                      2.5	Schulmerich, Wes	
                      7	Schulte, Fred	
                      2	Schultz, Joe	
                      0.5	Scott, LeGrant	
                      1	Seeds, Bob	
                      4.5	Selkirk, George	
                      1	Shaner, Wally	
                      1	Shorten, Chick	
                      15	Simmons, Al	
                      2	Slaughter, Enos	
                      2	Smith, Elmer	
                      5.5	Smith, Jack	
                      3.5	Solters, Moose	
                      2	Sothern, Denny	
                      5.5	Southworth, Billy	
                      1	Spalding, Dick	
                      8	Speaker, Tris	
                      4	Statz, Jigger	
                      1	Steinbacher, Hank	
                      3	Stengel, Casey	
                      7.5	Stephenson, Riggs	
                      8	Stone, John	
                      1	Strunk, Amos	
                      1	Sulik, Ernie	
                      0.5	Sullivan, John	
                      5.5	Summa, Homer	
                      3	Swanson, Evar	
                      1	Taitt, Doug	
                      4	Taylor, Danny	
                      1	Thompson, Tommy	
                      6	Tobin, Jack	
                      1	Tyson, Ty	
                      4.5	Veach, Bobby	
                      9	Vosmik, Joe	
                      9	Walker, Curt	
                      2	Walker, Dixie	
                      7	Walker, Gee	
                      1	Walker, Hub	
                      3	Walker, Tillie	
                      12	Waner, Lloyd	
                      14	Waner, Paul	
                      6.5	Watkins, George	
                      1	Watwood, Johnny	
                      0.5	Weatherly, Roy	
                      4	Webb, Earl	
                      4.5	Welch, Frank	
                      5	Welsh, Jimmy	
                      2	West, Max	
                      11.5	West, Sam	
                      7	Wheat, Zack	
                      2	White, Jo-Jo	
                      1	Whitted, Possum	
                      8.5	Williams, Cy	
                      9	Williams, Kenny	
                      1	Williams, Ted	
                      8.5	Wilson, Hack	
                      2	Wingo, Al	
                      1	Winsett, Tom	
                      5	Witt, Whitey	
                      1	Wood, Smokey Joe	
                      2	Worthington, Red	
                      1	Wright, Taffy	
                      7	Youngs, Ross	
                      0.5	Zitzman, Billy	
                      13	No regular

                      I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                      Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                      Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                      Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Sorted by total number of seasons played in the outfield from 1920-1939


                        Code:
                        	HOF			
                        15	HOF	Goslin, Goose		
                        15	HOF	Ruth, Babe		
                        15	HOF	Simmons, Al		
                        14	HOF	Manush, Heinie		
                        14	HOF	Waner, Paul		
                        13	HOF	Rice, Sam		
                        12	HOF	Waner, Lloyd		
                        11.5	HOF	Cuyler, Kiki		
                        11.5		West, Sam		
                        11	HOF	Averill, Earl		
                        11		Jamieson, Charlie		
                        11	HOF	Klein, Chuck		
                        11		Miller, Bing		
                        11	HOF	Ott, Mel		
                        10	HOF	Heilmann, Harry	75% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        10		Meusel, Bob		
                        9		Chapman, Ben		
                        9	HOF	Combs, Earl		
                        9		Falk, Bibb		
                        9		Herman, Babe		
                        9	HOF	Roush, Edd	65% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        9		Vosmik, Joe		
                        9		Walker, Curt		
                        9		Williams, Kenny		
                        8.5		Berger, Wally		
                        8.5	HOF	Carey, Max	50% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        8.5		Haas, Mule		
                        8.5	HOF	Hafey, Chick		
                        8.5		Williams, Cy	63% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        8.5	HOF	Wilson, Hack		
                        8	HOF	Speaker, Tris	42% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        8		Stone, John		
                        7.5		Cramer, Doc	56% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        7.5		Moore, Jo-Jo		
                        7.5		Reynolds, Carl		
                        7.5		Stephenson, Riggs		
                        7		Campbell, Bruce		
                        7		Jacobsen, Baby Doll		
                        7		Johnson, Bob	55% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        7		Johnson, Roy		
                        7	HOF	Medwick, Joe	58% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        7		Meusel, Irish		
                        7		Rice, Harry		
                        7		Schulte, Fred		
                        7		Walker, Gee	61% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        7	HOF	Wheat, Zack	43% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        7	HOF	Youngs, Ross		
                        6.5		Bressler, Rube		
                        6.5	HOF	Cobb, Ty	37% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        6.5		Douthit, Taylor		
                        6.5		Leach, Freddy		
                        6.5		Watkins, George		
                        6		Allen, Ethan		
                        6		Demaree, Frank		
                        6		Flagstead, Ira		
                        6		Fox, Pete	 63% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        6	HOF	Hooper, Harry	35% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        6		Mostil, Johnny		
                        6		Tobin, Jack	62% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        5.5		Harper, George		
                        5.5		Heathcote, Cliff		
                        5.5		Porter, Dick		
                        5.5		Smith, Jack	69% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        5.5		Southworth, Billy		
                        5.5		Summa, Homer		
                        5		Brown, Eddie		
                        5		Burns, George	58% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        5		Duncan, Pat		
                        5		Galan, Augie	48% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        5		Goodman, Ival		
                        5		Griffith, Tommy	47% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        5		Lee, Hal		
                        5		Leibold, Nemo	44% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        5		Moore, Johnny		
                        5		Moses, Wally	35% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        5		O'Doul, Lefty		
                        5		Welsh, Jimmy		
                        5		Witt, Whitey	65% 1920's-1930's ball (1910's)	
                        4.5		Bigbee, Carson		
                        4.5		Frederick, Johnny		
                        4.5		Moore, Terry		
                        4.5		Richbourg, Lance		
                        4.5		Selkirk, George		
                        4.5		Veach, Bobby		
                        4.5		Welch, Frank		
                        4		Comorosky, Adam		
                        4	HOF	DiMaggio, Joe	33% 1920's-1930's ball (1940's)	
                        4		Felix, Gus		
                        4		Flack, Max		
                        4		Kreevich, Mike		
                        4		Lamar, Bill		
                        4		Leiber, Hank		
                        4		Orsatti, Ernie		
                        4		Rothrock, Jack		
                        4		Statz, Jigger		
                        4		Taylor, Danny		
                        4		Webb, Earl		
                        3.5		Almada, Mel		
                        3.5		Barnhart, Clyde		
                        3.5		Blades, Ray		
                        3.5		Cooney, Johnny		
                        3.5		Jensen, Woody		
                        3.5		Martin, Pepper		
                        3.5		Myers, Hi		
                        3.5		Powell, Ray		
                        3.5		Solters, Moose		
                        3		Arnoivich, Morrie		
                        3		Barrett, Bill		
                        3		Bell, Beau		
                        3		Coleman, Ed		
                        3		Davis, Kiddo		
                        3		Fothergill, Bob		
                        3		Jolley, Smead		
                        3	HOF	Lindstrom, Freddie		
                        3		Martin, Hersh		
                        3		McNeely, Earl		
                        3		Mokan, Johnny		
                        3		Moore, Gene		
                        3		Oliver, Tom		
                        3		Powell, Jake		
                        3		Radcliff, Rip		
                        3		Stengel, Casey		
                        3		Swanson, Evar		
                        3		Walker, Tillie		
                        2.5		Boyle, Buzz		
                        2.5		Cooke, Dusty		
                        2.5		Fullis, Chick		
                        2.5		McHenry, Austin		
                        2.5		Menosky, Mike		
                        2.5		Metzler, Alex		
                        2.5		Ripple, Jimmy		
                        2.5		Schulmerich, Wes		
                        2		Boone, Ike		
                        2		Brickell, Fred		
                        2		Chapman, Sam		
                        2		Collins, Shano		
                        2		Cox, Dick		
                        2		Craft, Harry		
                        2		Cruise, Walton		
                        2		Cunningham, Bill		
                        2		DiMaggio, Vince		
                        2		Funk, Liz		
                        2		Garms, Debs		
                        2		Heath, Jeff		
                        2		Hill, Jesse		
                        2		Koy, Ernie		
                        2		Millan, Clyde		
                        2		Miller, Hack		
                        2		Mills, Buster		
                        2		Moore, Randy		
                        2		Roettger, Wally		
                        2		Scaritt, Russ		
                        2		Schultz, Joe		
                        2	HOF	Slaughter, Enos		
                        2		Smith, Elmer		
                        2		Sothern, Denny		
                        2		Walker, Dixie		
                        2		West, Max		
                        2		White, Jo-Jo		
                        2		Wingo, Al		
                        2		Worthington, Red		
                        1.5		Bordogaray, Frenchy		
                        1.5		Case, George		
                        1.5		Crabtree, Estel		
                        1.5		French, Walt		
                        1.5		Harris, Joe		
                        1.5		Henrich,  Tommy		
                        1.5		Hoag, Myril		
                        1.5		Holm, Wattie		
                        1.5		Koenecke, Len		
                        1.5		Mann, Les		
                        1.5		Marty, Joe		
                        1.5		Neale, Greasy		
                        1.5		Nixon, Al		
                        1.5		Rizzo, Johnny		
                        1		Arlett, Buzz		
                        1		Barber, Turner		
                        1		Bodie, Ping		
                        1		Brooks, Mandy		
                        1		Brower, Frank		
                        1		Byrd, Samuel		
                        1		Clark, Earl		
                        1		Eichrodt, Ike		
                        1		Estalella, Bobby		
                        1		Felsch, Happy		
                        1		Fonseca, Lew		
                        1		Friberg, Bernie		
                        1		Gallagher, Joe		
                        1		Gleeson, Jim		
                        1		Grigsby, Denver		
                        1		Gullic, Ted		
                        1		Harris, Dave		
                        1		Hassett, Buddy		
                        1		Hendryx, Tim		
                        1		Hoffman, Dutch		
                        1		Jackson, Joe		
                        1		Jahn, Art		
                        1		Laabs, Chet		
                        1		Langford, Sam		
                        1		LeBourveau, Bevo		
                        1		Lee, Cliff		
                        1		Lewis, Duffy		
                        1		Maisel, George		
                        1		Mathews, Wid		
                        1		McCosky, Bernie		
                        1		McGowan, Beauty		
                        1		Morgan, Chet		
                        1		Padgett, Don		
                        1		Paskert, Dode		
                        1		Pepper, Ray		
                        1		Pool, Harlin		
                        1		Puccinelli, George		
                        1		Reichle, Dick		
                        1		Robertson, Dave		
                        1		Rosen, Goody		
                        1		Rosenthal, Larry		
                        1		Roth, Braggo		
                        1		Russel, Reb		
                        1		Seeds, Bob		
                        1		Shaner, Wally		
                        1		Shorten, Chick		
                        1		Spalding, Dick		
                        1		Steinbacher, Hank		
                        1		Strunk, Amos		
                        1		Sulik, Ernie		
                        1		Taitt, Doug		
                        1		Thompson, Tommy		
                        1		Tyson, Ty		
                        1		Walker, Hub		
                        1		Watwood, Johnny		
                        1		Whitted, Possum		
                        1	HOF	Williams, Ted		
                        1		Winsett, Tom		
                        1		Wood, Smokey Joe		
                        1		Wright, Taffy		
                        0.5		Bailey, Gene		
                        0.5		Barbee, Dave		
                        0.5		Bell, Fern		
                        0.5		Brack, Gibby		
                        0.5		Callaghan, Marty		
                        0.5		Galatzer, Milt		
                        0.5		Gamble, Lee		
                        0.5		Kauff, Benny		
                        0.5		Keller, Charlie		
                        0.5		King, Lee		
                        0.5		McNulty, Pat		
                        0.5		Neis, Bernie		
                        0.5		Scott, LeGrant		
                        0.5		Sullivan, John		
                        0.5		Weatherly, Roy		
                        0.5		Zitzman, Billy




                        I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                        Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                        Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                        Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Some thoughts and then some initial percentages.

                          1) I thought I knew baseball history. I was sadly mistaken. You have no idea how many names I had never even heard of in this list.

                          2) Finding first hand accounts on some of these players is nigh high impossible. I think I'll have to go to newspapers, which is by far my least favorite choice.

                          3) Okay, first huge thing I found out - defensively the 1920's and 1930's managers often played a different strategy. While today the outfield plays mostly the same LF-CF-RF configuration day to day, back then especially the better corner outfielder was placed in the tougher outfield position based on the ballpark. Today the ballparks are usually symmetrical; back then there were many more unique ballparks with a tougher LF or RF. The managers would use different outfielders in different spots based on the ballplayers' skills and the outfield needs. There are many ballplayers who might play 90 games in right and 40 in left or something like that.

                          4) In today's game, teams expect the first sacker to normally be the biggest stick, back in the 1920's and 1930's, the outfielders were just as prominent as the major bats, if not moreso. Sure you had Gehrig, Foxx, Terry, Sisler, Greenberg, but you had at least as a high percentage in the outfield. Team expected the outfielders to have a good, if not great bat. Look at the batting totals of the outfielders relative to the rest of the team, and players who didn't outperform were quickly replaced.

                          5) Since the outfielders were such big bats, if you didn't have a star or superstar in the outfield, you were a bad team. Look at the dog teams of the era (White Sox, St. Louis Browns, Boston Braves especially), and they had no great outfielders.
                          Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 12-31-2014, 07:44 AM.
                          I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                          Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                          Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                          Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Okay, some general stats:

                            251 outfielders with at least a half season as a regular.

                            78 outfielders who were 1920's-1930's regulars (5 or more seasons)

                            27 Hall of Famers played at least one season in the outfield in this era. Freddie Lindstrom, an infielder played outfield for 3. Joe DiMaggio played in 4 seasons, Enos Slaughter in 2, Ted Williams in 1. These four players weren't really part of my focus group.

                            So 23 Hall of Famers were regulars in the outfield in this era (Goslin, Ruth, Simmons, Manush, P. Waner, Rice, L. Waner, Cuyler, Averill, Klein, Ott, Heilmann, Combs, Roush, Carey, Hafey, H. Wilson, Speaker, Medwick, Wheat, Youngs, Cobb, Hooper).

                            I've included notes on players with significant plate appearances in the dead ball era or the 1940's (eras I'm not too concerned with). I'm considering players with 55% or more of their plate appearances outside of the 1920's or 1930's as not primarily 1920's/1930's players. This will then exclude Tris Speaker, Zack Wheat, Ty Cobb, Harry Hooper, Nemo Leibold and Wally Moses from my primary analysis. While their 1920's/1930's work needs to be considered, they shouldn't be considered as mostly 1920's/1930's players.

                            Hall of Famers played 247.5 of the 960 outfield seasons in this era (26%)

                            Of the 72 outfielders who can be considered as 1920's/1930's based regular outfielders, 19 are Hall of Famers (26%).

                            Of the 78 outfielders who can be considered as 1920's/1930's regular outfielders, 23 are Hall of Famers (29%).

                            As to my previous point of having to be good to stick around in the outfield or you'd be replaced, 12/16 outfielders (75%) with 10+ years in this era were HOFers. Goslin, Ruth, Simmons, Manush, P. Waner, Rice, L. Waner, Cuyler, Averill, Klein, Ott, Heilmann are in. Sam West, Charlie Jamieson, Bing Miller, Bob Meusel are not.


                            Okay, that is it for pure facts. Anyone with any comments or questions, fire away.
                            Last edited by Toledo Inquisition; 12-31-2014, 08:37 AM.
                            I don't think either one of them can win it.-one sportswriter's assessment of the 1945 world series between the tigers and cubs.
                            Play the Who am I? game in trivia and you can make this signature line yours for 3 days (baseball signatures only!)

                            Go here for a link to all player links! http://www.baseball-fever.com/forum/...player-threads

                            Go here for all your 1920's/1930's OF info

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Looks like we are a go to post now. Anyway, I saw that you mentioned how much you would like to see beyond the numbers on many of these outfielders and I agree. That is the history side of the game, really. If you have any questions about specific outfielders from the Cardinals or Browns during the 20s and 30s (or anytime) I can help you out with a lot of that, I have a bunch of books sitting right here around my computer that talk about those outfielders along the Big River. We had some very fine outfielders during that time.

                              Another thing about the outfielders I learned going over my squads in that period was the outfield assists. I wanted to look into this more, but haven't had the time, but I noticed it during the 1926 World Series with both the Cardinals and Yankees outfielders throwing out a bunch of runners trying to advance during those seven games. I was going to look and see what effect they had during the season as well compared to now.
                              "It ain't braggin' if you can do it." Dizzy Dean

                              Comment

                              Ad Widget

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X