Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

A question

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • A question

    After watching an episode of Numb3ers the other night, I was wondering whether it would be possible to calculate using sabermetrics, whether a player was a roid user or not. This was the central line of the plot, and no matter what calculations I put together, I can't seem to do it. Can anyone here help me??
    MySpace Codes

  • #2
    I hate the fact that people say "he's on steroids." Oh, really? What kind of steroids? Deca-Durabolin? Winstrol? Anavar? Dianabol?

    There are many, MANY types of steroids used for multiple purposes. Hitters and position players might use one type, relievers another, and starters still yet a different package. Some help you add LBM extremely fast, some help maintain integrity, some are injectable, some are orally available.

    So, without actually understanding what the many types of steroids do, no, you couldn't figure out if a player was using them.
    Owner of Driveline Baseball - Seattle, WA

    Comment


    • #3
      Well, could you do different formula for different roids?
      MySpace Codes

      Comment


      • #4
        How do you know what player is on what?

        It's pointless, really.
        Owner of Driveline Baseball - Seattle, WA

        Comment


        • #5
          I don't think you have got the question. I was wondering whether it would be possible to sabermetrially work out if a player was on some sort of roids, by his stats and injuries.
          MySpace Codes

          Comment


          • #6
            No. No. No.

            (For some reason, I'm not allowed to post something with only 3 characters... minimum 10, so that's why I posted it 3 times.)
            Author of THE BOOK -- Playing The Percentages In Baseball

            Comment


            • #7
              Bill James himself just did an article last week on his new site Bill James Online. He starts by presenting a hierarchy of departure from the norm. The hierarchy is 1) Criminal, 2) Suspicious, 3) Unusual and 4) Normal. He states that we certainly cannot conclude based on statistical evidence that a player has engaged in criminal activity and he regards it as "reckless" to suggest that a player's statistics are suspicious.

              He then proceeds to present a new series of 10 formulas called U scores. The "U" stands for unusual. Basically they attempt to score seasons on how unusual they are. I think that the formulas can be separated into two groups. The first group is things that are just statistically odd, like having more walks than hits. The next group I would categorize as capturing seasons that are out of whack with a players previous accomplishments, either in general or for his age. It's this second group that kind of hints at the subject of this thread.

              At the end, he totals everything up and presents a top 25 list of players with the most unusual careers. There is a clear #1, which I'm sure most could guess. The rest of the list is a mix of HOFers, confessed PED users, people who have talked to congress, some who are probably bordering on suspicious and other assorted oddballs.

              Oddly, Jose Canseco doesn't make the list. I guess if you use from day one then nothing ever seems out of line.

              Comment


              • #8
                Could you post the 25? You need to pay for suscription
                MySpace Codes

                Comment


                • #9
                  Bill James himself just did an article last week on his new site Bill James Online. He starts by presenting a hierarchy of departure from the norm. The hierarchy is 1) Criminal, 2) Suspicious, 3) Unusual and 4) Normal. He states that we certainly cannot conclude based on statistical evidence that a player has engaged in criminal activity and he regards it as "reckless" to suggest that a player's statistics are suspicious.
                  I'm a huge fan of Bill James, but I'm guessing he didn't read this post on Kermit The Blog about how suspicious Bonds' 2001 season was.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Sorry, I was trying to respect Bill's right to try and turn a dime. I'm still not convinced that it's worth my $3/month, when I can read everybody else's stuff for free. Anyways, here's the list...

                    1 Barry Bonds 1974
                    2 Mark McGwire 803
                    3 Sammy Sosa 521
                    4 Babe Ruth 511
                    5 Roy Thomas 393
                    6 Yank Robinson 323
                    7 Max Bishop 303
                    8 Andres Galarraga 293
                    9 Ken Griffey Jr. 293
                    10 Luis Gonzalez 288
                    11 Rogers Hornsby 288
                    12 Cy Williams 283
                    13 Jack Crooks 278
                    14 Rafael Palmeiro 268
                    15 Brady Anderson 262
                    16 Hank Aaron 246
                    17 Eddie Yost 244
                    18 Willie Keeler 240
                    19 Gene Tenace 237
                    20 Ken Caminiti 237
                    21 Albert Belle 237
                    22 Jack Clark 228
                    23 Edgar Martinez 227
                    24 Willie McCovey 222
                    25 Juan Gonzalez 212

                    BTW, I saw the NUMB3RS episode last year and found it amusing. As I recall, the stats-geek creates his formula to get an edge in fantasy baseball. But word gets out that he is able to identify players who have used PED's and a suspected player ends up murdered.

                    So let's be careful out there guys.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Some names on that list have surprised me. Aaron? Hornsby? Keeler? Anderson? Thanks a lot for the list buddy.
                      MySpace Codes

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        That episode got me thinking to why I always lose fantasy baseball too lol
                        MySpace Codes

                        Comment

                        Ad Widget

                        Collapse
                        Working...
                        X