Missing the Hall with the most HR

[Utter Chaos]

Mark McGwire now has the record for the most career homer runs for those that failed to get elected to the Hall of Fame in their first year of elligibility.

Who had the record prior to McGwire?

[Brooklyn]

Mark McGwire now has the record for the most career homer runs for those that failed to get elected to the Hall of Fame in their first year of elligibility.

Who had the record prior to McGwire?

Harmon Killebrew

[Utter Chaos]

Harmon it is.

Here are the eligible guys with over 400 homers that didn't make the HOF in their first year.
McGwire 583
Killebrew 573
Mathews 512
Canseco 462
Kingman 442
Dawson 438
B.Williams 426
D.Evans 414
Snider 407

Here are some other possibilities
Bonds 762+
Palmeiro 569
F.Thomas 513
Thome 507+
McGriff 493
Sheffield 480+
Bagwell 449
J.Gonzalez 434
DelGado 431+

[anjo25]

Which player has the most HRs without being in the hall (Players who debuted in 1980 and later excluded)?

[rich]

Big Dave

Was it Kong?

[White Knight]

Mark McGwire now has the record for the most career homer runs for those that failed to get elected to the Hall of Fame in their first year of elligibility.

Who had the record prior to McGwire?

Mac's record will be broken by Sosa, when he is elligible. 600+ HR's, and I really don't see him getting in the first year. Bonds will though.