Never Lost a Series

[Tyrus4189Cobb]

Can you name the players who appeared in at least three WS and was never on the losing end? I'll keep the master list in this post, which remains blank for the time being because there's no way to give a hint without giving answers. No looking, no cheating, you know the drill. In order the qualify, the player has to have won all the Series he's appeared in, not just been on the team. It doesn't count if the player's team lost the Series but he made no appearance.

Sal Bando- 1972-1974 OAK
Vida Blue- 1972-1974 OAK
Bobby Brown- 1947, 1949-1951 NYY
Bert Campaneris- 1972-1974 OAK
David Cone- 1996, 1997-2000 NYY
Chili Davis- 1991 MIN, 1998-1999 NYY
Rollie Fingers- 1972-1974 OAK. Though his 1982 Brewers lost the Series, he made no appearance
Joe Girardi- 1996, 1998-1999 NYY
Lefty Gomez- 1932, 1936-1939 NYY
Dick Green- 1972-1974 OAK
Alfredo Griffin- 1988 LAD, 1992-1993 TOR
Tommy Henrich- 1938, 1941, 1947, 1949 NYY
Ken Holtzman- 1972-1974 OAK
Harry Hooper- 1912, 1915-1916, 1918 BOS
Ed Lopat- 1949-1953 NYY
Johnny Mize- 1949-1953 NYY
Jack Morris- 1984 DET, 1991 MIN, 1992 TOR
Blue Moon Odom- 1972-1974 OAK
Allie Reynolds- 1947, 1949-1953 NYY
Vic Raschi- 1947, 1949-1953 NYY
Joe Rudi- 1972-1974 OAK
Tris Speaker- 1912, 1915 BOS, 1920 CLE
Snuffy Stirnweiss- 1943, 1947, 1949 NYY
Darryl Strawberry- 1986 NYM, 1996, 1999 NYY
Gene Tenace- 1972-1974 OAK, 1982 STL
Mike Timlin- 1992-1993 TOR, 2004, 2007 BOS
Devon White- 1992-1993 TOR, 1997 FLA
Gene Woodling- 1949-1953 NYY

[Brooklyn]

Can you name the players who appeared in at least three WS and was never on the losing end? I'll keep the master list in this post, which remains blank for the time being because there's no way to give a hint without giving answers. No looking, no cheating, you know the drill. In order the qualify, the player has to have won all the Series he's appeared in, not just been on the team. It doesn't count if the player's team lost the Series but he made no appearance.

I think Joe Girardi meets this criteria

[Brooklyn]

how about Strawberry?

[Reds5]

Lonnie Smith

[Ben Grimm]

Trying to think of older guys who played with the Yankees and possibly retired after their WS runs in the '90. Best I can come up with is Paul O'Neill and Chili Davis.

[Tyrus4189Cobb]

Joe Girardi- Correct. Played in the Yankees' 1996-1999 run
Darryl Strawberry- Correct. 1986 Mets, 1996 and 1999 Yankees
Lonnie Smith- Incorrect. Lost the '91-'92 Series as a Brave
Paul O'Neill- Incorrect. Lost in his final year as a 2001 Yankee
Chili Davis- Correct. 1991 Twins, 1998-1999 Yankees

[PVNICK]

Joe Rudi?
Sal Bando?

[Tyrus4189Cobb]

Both Rudi and Bando are correct because of the '70s A's run

[EdTarbusz]

Tom Henrich
Billy Martin

[Brooklyn]

Vida Blue, Blue Moon Odom, Catfish Hunter, David Cone, Allie Reynolds, El Duque

[chicagowhitesox1173]

Tris Speaker

[Tyrus4189Cobb]

Tom Henrich
Billy Martin

Vida Blue, Blue Moon Odom, Catfish Hunter, David Cone, Allie Reynolds, El Duque

Tris Speaker

Tommy Henrich- 1938, 1941, 1947, 1949 NYY
Billy Martin- Incorrect. Lost 1955 WS
Vida Blue- 1972-1974 A's
Blue Moon Odom- 1972-1974 A's
Catfish Hunter- Incorrect. Lost 1976 WS
David Cone- 1996, 1997-2000 NYY
Allie Reynolds- 1947, 1949-1953 NYY
El Duque Hernandez- Incorrect lost 2001 WS
Tris Speaker- 1912, 1915 BOS, 1920 CLE

[Brooklyn]

Bert Campaneris, Rollie Fingers

[BigRon]

Two who come to mind are

Bobby Brown and

Johnny Mize.

They played together during the Yankees 5 year run 1949-1953. I know that Mize played on each of those teams and I think Brown did.

[ian2813]

Vic Raschi
Gene Woodling
Ed Lopat
Mike Timlin