#1 Starter

[NJMetfan4life]

Who will be the #1 Starter for the D-Backs?

Stat wise

Webb and Haren: Last Three Seasons

Webb Haren
W-L 48-30 43-34
ERA 3.21 3.64
Opp. BA .249 .253
Starts 100 102

[Imgran]

tie goes to the incumbent

[KCGHOST]

Nothing to discuss here. Webb is a no-brainer.

[PJ-34]

Pffft you'd have to be stupid to not get this one. No offence but Webb is the definition of a power, controlling pitcher. He'd be the #1 guy almost anywhere he'd go.

[Rotoprofessor]

I agree with the consensus here, it's Webb hands down. He's not only the better of the two, but one of the Top 5 pitchers in the game. Outside of Johan Santana, Webb can be debated with, and possibly taken over, any other pitcher out there.

[NJMetfan4life]

My list of top 5 pitchers is:

1. Santana (duh)
2. Peavy (Great ERA, Wins, strikeouts, and will get better)
3. Webb(Lot's of wins and K's)
4. Lackey (averages 15+ wins and 2.00 and under ERA)
5. Berdard(Getting better)

[dbacksfan95]

Order of Importance:
1.Brandon Webb
2.Micah Owings
3.Dan Haren

All three are solid though

[JordanDL3891]

My list of top 5 pitchers is:

1. Santana (duh)
2. Peavy (Great ERA, Wins, strikeouts, and will get better)
3. Webb(Lot's of wins and K's)
4. Lackey (averages 15+ wins and 2.00 and under ERA)
5. Berdard(Getting better)

I'd put Becket in 4th other than Lackey, but other than that, that list looks good.