All-Time Phillies Team

[bluesky5]

From a between innings thread:

Philadelphia Phillies All-Time Team

Manager - Dallas Green [Harry Wright]

1. CF - Billy Hamilton [Richie Ashburn]
2. 2B - Chase Utley [Kid Gleason]
3. LF - Ed Delahanty [Sherry Magee]
4. 3B - Mike Schmidt [Dick Allen]
5. RF - Big Sam Thompson [Chuck Klein]
6. 1B - Ryan Howard
7. SS - Jimmy Rollins [Dave Bancroft]
8. C - Bob Boone [Mike Lieberthal]

1. Pete Alexander
2. Steve Carlton
3. Robin Roberts
4. Curt Schilling
5. Jim Bunning
[Charlie Ferguson, Curt Simmons, Cole Hamels, Chris Short]

Bullpen - Jim Konstanty, Ron Reed, Mitch Williams [Rheal Cormier, Turk Farrell]
CL - Tug McGraw

[]-HM
*I didn't select the players to fit a desired batting order. I arranged them after picking the best by position.

Thoughts?

[Ben Grimm]

A few close ones. I'll take Charlie over Dallas only because Green wasn't around long enough and was handed a contending team when he took over.

For LF, I prefer Sherry Magee over Luzinski. As unpopular as this will be, I'll also take Bobby Abreu as the top RFer. And 3B, I'll take Scott Rolen over Dick Allen only because Dick should have been playing 1B with that concrete glove of his.

[bluesky5]

A few close ones. I'll take Charlie over Dallas only because Green wasn't around long enough and was handed a contending team when he took over.

For LF, I prefer Sherry Magee over Luzinski. As unpopular as this will be, I'll also take Bobby Abreu as the top RFer. And 3B, I'll take Scott Rolen over Dick Allen only because Dick should have been playing 1B with that concrete glove of his.

I do like Magee over Big Lu.