Help making an all-time roster

[RamMan12]

I'm making an all-time team roster league and was wondering if I could get some help. I've got about half a team but I need help filling in the blank spots. The thread where I'm showing my progress on this is at Fantasy Baseball and Gaming in the thread "Creating a new historical sim league" if anyone wants to check it out. Any help will be appreciated. Here is the Braves' roster I have as of right now. Corrections are welcomed.

Pos Atlanta
C Joe Torre
C
1B Eddie Matthews
2B Glen Hubbard
3B Rabbit Maranville
SS
LF
CF Hugh Duffy
RF Hank Aaron
IF Fred McGriff
IF
OF Dale Murphy
OF Felipe Alou
OF
Util
Util
SP Kid Nichols
SP Phil Niekro
SP Tommy Bond
SP Warren Spahn
SP Vic Willis
SP
RP
CL
P

[SamtheBravesFan]

Here's what I think you should do. If you're including active players, this is where you should go.

Pos Braves
C Joe Torre
1B Fred Tenney
2B Glenn Hubbard
3B Eddie Mathews
SS Rabbit Maranville
LF Rico Carty
CF Hugh Duffy
RF Hank Aaron
C Javy Lopez
IF Chipper Jones
IF Jeff Blauser
OF Dale Murphy
OF Andruw Jones
OF Wally Berger
Util Herman Long
Util Bobby Lowe
SP Kid Nichols
SP Phil Niekro
SP Greg Maddux
SP Warren Spahn
SP Tom Glavine
SP Vic Willis
RP Gene Garber
RP Greg McMichael
RP Don McMahon
RP Cecil Upshaw
RP Rick Camp
RP John Rocker
CL John Smoltz

Now if you're NOT taking active players, that makes it a bit easier.


Pos Braves
C Joe Torre
1B Fred Tenney
2B Glenn Hubbard
3B Eddie Mathews
SS Rabbit Maranville
LF Rico Carty
CF Hugh Duffy
RF Hank Aaron
C Del Crandall
IF Jeff Blauser
IF Bob Horner
OF Dale Murphy
OF Tommy Holmes
OF Wally Berger
Util Herman Long
Util Bobby Lowe
SP Kid Nichols
SP Warren Spahn
SP Phil Niekro
SP Vic Willis
SP Tommy Bond
SP Dick Rudolph
RP Steve Bedrosian
RP Greg McMichael
RP John Rocker
RP Don McMahon
RP Rick Camp
RP Cecil Upshaw
CL/FM Gene Garber

A pleasure being of assisstance.

[DODGER DEB]

You might want to include:

JOHNNY LOGAN - SS
MAX SURKONT - P
LEW BURDETTE - P
BOB BUHL - P
CHET NICHOLS - P
JOEY JAY - P
GENE CONLEY - P

Most of these played for both the Boston and Milwaukee Braves in the late 1940's, but mostly in the 1950's.

If I think of others, I'll post them.

c.

[cbenson5]

Here's mine. I took some liberties putting Hugh Duffy at second, but he did play a little bit of infield. I've thought about switching out Del Crandall for Lopez and Berger for Justice.
Lineup

1. Hugh Duffy 2B
2. Joe Torre C
3. Chipper Jones 3B
4. Hank Aaron RF
5. Eddie Mathews 1B
6. Aundruw Jones CF
7. Dale Murphy LF
8. Rabbit Maranville SS
9. Starting Pitcher

Bench
Herman Long SS
Bob Horner 3B
Tommy McCarthy OF
Bobby Lowe 2B
David Justice OF
Javy Lopez C


Rotation

1. Warren Spahn
2. Kid Nichols
3. Greg Maddux
4. Tom Glavine
5. Phil Niekro

Bullpen

Al Spalding
Lew Burdette
Johnny Sain
Vic Willis
Kevin Millwood


Closer

John Smoltz

Includes Hall of Famers:
1. Hugh Duffy
2. Hank Aaron
3. Eddie Mathews
4. Rabbit Maranville
5. Warren Spahn
6. Kid Nichols
7. Phil Niekro
8. Al Spalding(elected as pioneer)
9. Vic Willis
10. Tommy McCarhty

[SamtheBravesFan]

You might want to include:

JOHNNY LOGAN - SS
MAX SURKONT - P
LEW BURDETTE - P
BOB BUHL - P
CHET NICHOLS - P
JOEY JAY - P
GENE CONLEY - P

Most of these played for both the Boston and Milwaukee Braves in the late 1940's, but mostly in the 1950's.

If I think of others, I'll post them.

c.

I think Blauser was better than Logan. And Burdette and Buhl, well yeah, I could have done them. Conley's on the bubble. Surkont and Nichols spent just four seasons with the Braves, they weren't really all that great. Kind of like Conley. Joey Jay's Braves career doesn't have enough meat to it, you know?

And before you say it, I realize that a few of the relief pitchers have short Braves careers, but I wanted majority or exclusive relievers. So I had no choice.